Running a workplace investigation in WA: a step-by-step guide for employers

Updated 17 November 2026

A workplace investigation is a fact-finding exercise: you put specific allegations to the person accused, hear every side, and make a finding on each allegation on the balance of probabilities before anyone decides what to do. Done badly, it can turn justified discipline into an unfair dismissal.

This guide for Perth and WA employers takes you through the process in order, and explains what the Fair Work Commission and the Western Australian Industrial Relations Commission (WAIRC) check afterwards, because they do not apply the same test.

In short:

  • No Act sets one procedure for every private sector employer, but your policies, agreement and contracts may, and a policy in the contract can be enforced against you.
  • In the national system, the Fair Work Commission decides for itself whether the conduct happened. In the WA state system, the WAIRC usually asks whether you investigated as fully as was reasonable, gave the employee a fair chance to answer, and genuinely believed on reasonable grounds that the misconduct occurred.
  • You cannot promise a complainant or witness total confidentiality. The person accused must be told the substance of the allegations and of the evidence against them.

The steps at a glance

Step What fairness requires Read more
1. Decide whether to investigate Check your policy, agreement and contracts; consider any legal duty to act When to investigate
2. Appoint the investigator No conflict of interest, and ideally not the decision-maker Who should investigate
3. Set the scope Written terms of reference and particularised allegations Terms of reference and allegations
4. Decide on stand down A power to do it, and pay unless you have a clear right otherwise Suspension and stand down
5. Interview Notice, a support person, and a chance to answer the evidence Investigation interviews
6. Assess the evidence The balance of probabilities, with care for serious allegations Evidence and findings
7. Report A finding on each allegation, kept separate from penalty Reports and privilege
8. Decide and act A decision-maker who weighs the findings and the employee's response Show cause letters

What is a workplace investigation?

It is an inquiry into a complaint or concern about how someone at work has behaved, to establish what happened and whether that breached the law, a policy or the contract. It is not the disciplinary decision: keep the two apart.

Is a preliminary inquiry the same as an investigation?

No. A preliminary inquiry is a quiet first look, such as reading system logs, to decide whether there is anything to investigate; no allegations are put and no findings made. Be clear with the employee which one you are doing. Where a suspension letter presented a meeting as part of a disciplinary investigation, a Federal Court judge held that, on those facts and that contract, a direction to attend needed either reasonable particulars of the allegations or a clear statement that the meeting was only fact-finding (Avenia v Railway & Transport Health Fund Ltd [2017] FCA 859 at [219]-[220]).

Which system are you in?

Which tribunal tests your investigation depends on the employer:

(a) Most companies are national system employers. A constitutional corporation (in practice, a trading or financial corporation) is in the national system (Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 14(1)(a)), and unfair dismissal claims go to the Fair Work Commission.

(b) The WA state system covers employers outside the national system: typically sole traders, partnerships, unincorporated associations and trusts with individual trustees; most WA state public sector employers; and, since 1 January 2023, WA local governments, each declared out of the national system by name under Fair Work Act s 14(2) (the two Indian Ocean Territories shires stay national). Unfair dismissal claims go to the WAIRC. See Am I covered?

(c) Public service officers, and other public sector employees to whom Part 5 of the Public Sector Management Act 1994 (WA) applies (s 76(1)), also have a statutory discipline process. Health service employees have a separate one under the Health Services Act 2016 (WA). The employing authority may deal with a suspected breach as a disciplinary matter, take improvement action or take no action (s 81(1)); a disciplinary matter proceeds informally and is not bound by the rules of evidence (s 82A(1)). See our public sector employees page and the case study School IT officer forwarded a colleague's resignation email to herself.

What does procedural fairness require, and what will a tribunal check?

The national system: Fair Work Act s 387

In deciding whether a dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable, the Fair Work Commission must take into account:

(a) whether there was a valid reason related to the employee's capacity or conduct, including its effect on the safety and welfare of other employees;

(b) whether the employee was notified of that reason;

(c) whether the employee was given an opportunity to respond to it;

(d) any unreasonable refusal to allow a support person to be present to assist at discussions relating to dismissal;

(e) for unsatisfactory performance, whether the employee was warned before the dismissal;

(f) and (g) how the size of the business, and the absence of dedicated human resources expertise, would be likely to affect the procedures followed; and

(h) any other matter the Commission considers relevant (Fair Work Act s 387).

On valid reason, the Commission decides for itself, on the evidence before it, whether the conduct happened. The test is not whether the employer believed on reasonable grounds, after sufficient inquiry, that the employee was guilty (King v Freshmore (Vic) Pty Ltd [2000] AIRC 1019; Print S4213 at [24]). If the employer reached its conclusion through a flawed investigation, that is irrelevant to whether there was a valid reason (Illawarra Coal Holdings Pty Ltd t/a South32 v Gosek [2018] FWCFB 749 at [92]).

That does not make process unimportant. Your evidence must be strong enough to prove the conduct again at a hearing, and your process is still weighed under s 387(b), (c), (d) and (h), so it can make a dismissal unfair even where the conduct happened.

An employer cannot simply rely on a reasonable belief that the conduct occurred; the standard is the balance of probabilities (Coogee Legion Ex-Service Club Ltd v Giblin [2024] FWCFB 270 at [55]). The exception is the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code, which treats summary dismissal by a small business employer as fair when the employer "believes on reasonable grounds that the employee's conduct is sufficiently serious to justify immediate dismissal". An investigation is how you get those reasonable grounds.

The WA state system: harsh, oppressive or unfair

The WAIRC asks whether the dismissal was "harsh, oppressive or unfair" (Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) s 23A(1); the employee refers the claim under s 29(1)(c)). Section 23A(2) lists only two matters (a short agreed probation and work in a private home); there is no procedural checklist like s 387. Where the dismissal is for dishonesty, misconduct serious enough to harm the business, or a grave allegation that raises safety or public interest concerns, the WAIRC Full Bench applies a long-standing test drawn from a South Australian decision. The employer meets the evidentiary onus on it if it shows that:

(a) it investigated the relevant matters as fully and extensively as was reasonable in the circumstances;

(b) it gave the employee every reasonable opportunity and enough time to answer all the allegations;

(c) it then honestly and genuinely believed, on reasonable grounds, that the employee was guilty of the misconduct alleged; and

(d) the misconduct, allowing for any mitigating circumstances, justified dismissal (Trestrail v City of Karratha [2025] WAIRC 00820 at [23]-[26], Full Bench; Minister for Health v Drake-Brockman [2012] WAIRC 00150 at [56], [62], Full Bench).

The belief must be that the misconduct occurred: a belief that there was a "real and substantial risk" of misconduct is not enough (Trestrail v City of Karratha [2025] WAIRC 00820 at [26], [28]). The standard is practical. Employers need not have the skills of police investigators or lawyers, and need not chase every avenue suggested to them, but they must gather the information central to whether the conduct occurred (Minister for Health v Drake-Brockman [2012] WAIRC 00150 at [107]-[109]). The overall onus of showing the dismissal was unfair stays with the employee (at [47], [67]).

Outside that kind of case, be ready to prove that the misconduct actually happened: where misconduct is relied on, there is a burden on the employer to demonstrate that the incident did occur (Garbett v Midland Brick Company Pty Ltd [2003] WASCA 36 at [72]; Minister for Health v Drake-Brockman [2012] WAIRC 00150 at [61], [63]). Even under the four-part test, the WAIRC may decide whether the conduct occurred (at [58], [70]), though it need not: where a teacher was accused of sexually assaulting a student, the employer was entitled to act on a well-founded belief without proving the conduct (Parnell v Roman Catholic Archbishop of Perth [2021] WAIRC 00102 at [118], Full Bench). The safe course is the same as in the national system: investigate so that you can prove the conduct, not only show that you believed it. See what makes a dismissal unfair in the WA state system.

Step 1: decide whether to investigate

Start with your own documents: an enterprise agreement, policy or contract may require an investigation or say how it is run. Follow it. In Elisha v Vision Australia Limited [2024] HCA 50 the High Court held that the contract incorporated the employer's disciplinary policies, and restored damages for psychiatric injury caused by a process that breached them (at [1]-[3]).

Employers must take reasonable and proportionate measures to eliminate sexual harassment and related conduct as far as possible (Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth) s 47C), so an informal or anonymous report of sexual harassment can rarely be ignored. See the employer's positive duty.

Not every complaint needs an investigation, for example a performance concern or a trivial matter: see Does this complaint need an investigation? Tell the complainant your decision in writing, and check any insurer notification terms.

Step 2: appoint the investigator

You can use a manager, human resources, an external investigator or a lawyer, provided they have no real or perceived conflict of interest; if the complaint is about someone senior, use an outsider. Where you can, keep the investigator and the decision-maker separate. That helps if a general protections claim follows, because the employer must then prove its reason was not a prohibited one (Fair Work Act s 361).

Tell people the truth about the investigation's purpose. An employer that called an investigation independent and required by policy, when it was really to help its lawyers defend the employee's own anti-bullying application, was found to have made those representations misleadingly and "disingenuously" to justify directing him to a compulsory interview (Stephen v Seahill Enterprises Pty Ltd [2021] FWCFB 2623 at [70], [72]).

WA also has an investigator licensing rule. A person who, for remuneration, investigates the conduct of individuals is an "investigator" under the Security and Related Activities (Control) Act 1996 (WA) (s 28(1)), and acting as one without an investigator's licence carries a fine of up to $15,000 (s 30). Investigations by a legal practitioner acting in the ordinary course of practice as a lawyer, and by the lawyer's clerk, fall outside that definition (s 28(2)(a), (b)). Who else is exempt is covered in Who should investigate a workplace complaint in WA?

Step 3: set the scope

Write terms of reference before anyone is interviewed: the questions to be answered, who is likely to be spoken to, what records will be gathered, the standard of proof and what the report will contain. Then turn the complaint into allegations, one per item, each with who, what, when and where, written as a claim to be tested. Widen the scope only deliberately and in writing. See Terms of reference and allegation letters.

Step 4: stand down or not

Standing someone down is not the statutory stand down in Fair Work Act s 524, which covers only industrial action, a breakdown of machinery and a stoppage of work the employer is not responsible for. A right to suspend without pay has to come from the contract, award or agreement: at common law there is none (Avenia v Railway & Transport Health Fund Ltd [2017] FCA 859 at [154]). Suspend on full pay unless you have that right. Where Part 5 of the Public Sector Management Act applies, an employing authority that has decided to deal with a suspected breach as a disciplinary matter may suspend on full pay, partial pay or without pay, in accordance with the Commissioner's instructions (s 82(1)).

Keep it short, and take particular care if the person has recently complained about their employment (see below). See suspension and stand down.

Step 5: interview

Usually the complainant goes first, then the person accused, then other witnesses. Give notice of what each interview is about, and allow a support person. In the national system, s 387(d) is about an unreasonable refusal to allow one, not a failure to offer one, though that may still count under s 387(h) (Jurisic v ABB Australia Pty Limited [2014] FWCFB 5835 at [84]). For a national system small business employer, the Code says the support person cannot be a lawyer acting in a professional capacity. The WA state system has no equivalent provision, but refusing a reasonable request for a support person can still count against the fairness of the process.

The key fairness rule is to put the adverse evidence to the person accused before findings. Where an enterprise agreement required natural justice during the investigation, the Full Bench held that the substance of credible, relevant and significant adverse material from the complainant and other witnesses had to be put to the employee before findings were made, and suggested the employer re-open the investigation (Aurizon Operations Ltd v Webb [2024] FWCFB 318 at [61]-[62]). A policy that forms part of the contract may require the same. See the case study Told to show cause, he asked to see the investigation report and, for technique and recording, Interviewing in a workplace investigation.

Step 6: assess the evidence

Findings are made on the balance of probabilities, even where the conduct alleged is criminal (Neat Holdings Pty Ltd v Karajan Holdings Pty Ltd [1992] HCA 66 at [2]). But the seriousness of an allegation and the gravity of its consequences affect whether you can be reasonably satisfied it is proved, and that satisfaction should not come from "inexact proofs, indefinite testimony, or indirect inferences" (Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336 at 361-362).

Test each account against the documents and the other accounts, and ask what is most probable; demeanour is a poor guide to truth. See Weighing evidence and making findings, and the case study Sacked over harassment claims the Commission found were not proved.

Step 7: report

The report sets out the scope, what the investigator did, the evidence, and a finding on each allegation with reasons. Write it as if a tribunal or regulator will read it, and keep findings separate from recommendations on discipline. A report is privileged only if it was prepared for the dominant purpose of legal advice or litigation (Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (1999) 201 CLR 49 at [61]), and privilege can be lost. See Investigation reports, privilege and what happens next.

Step 8: decide and act

If a serious outcome is possible, tell the employee the findings and the proposed outcome and give them a genuine chance to respond, usually by a show cause letter. Consider the response with an open mind, and treat similar conduct consistently. See terminating employees and defending a claim.

Confidentiality: what you can and cannot promise

Complainants and witnesses

You cannot promise that the person accused will not learn what is alleged, or what a witness said against them. Fairness means telling them the substance of the allegations and of the adverse evidence (see step 5), and the Commission weighs this under s 387(b), (c) and (h). Sometimes the substance can be put without naming the source. What you can promise is that information goes only to those who need it, and that retaliation will not be tolerated.

The person accused

Ask the person accused to keep the matter confidential and not to approach witnesses, without stopping them preparing with their support person and adviser.

Whistleblowers and public interest disclosures

Some disclosures carry statutory confidentiality. If a complaint qualifies for protection under the whistleblower provisions of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (s 1317AAE) or as a public interest disclosure under the Public Interest Disclosure Act 2003 (WA) (s 16), the discloser's identity can be revealed only in limited cases, such as with their consent or, for a WA public interest disclosure, where natural justice or an effective investigation requires it. See when to investigate.

Protecting people who take part

In the national system, being able to make a complaint about one's employment is a workplace right (Fair Work Act s 341(1)(c)(ii)), and adverse action because of it is prohibited (s 340(1)). In the WA state system, an employer must not take damaging action against an employee because the employee is able to make an employment-related inquiry or complaint, and once the damaging action is proved the employer must prove that was not its reason (Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) s 97A).

Get advice early

The cheapest point to get an investigation right is before it starts. If you are a Perth or WA employer with a complaint to investigate, or want an investigation run or reviewed, contact us or see our workplace investigations page.