Terms of reference and allegation letters for a workplace investigation

Updated 17 November 2026

Terms of reference set out what an investigation is for, how it will be done and what the report will contain. Allegations are the specific things the person accused is said to have done, each set out with enough detail that they can answer it. Get both right in writing before the first interview, and most of the procedural arguments an employee can later raise in the Fair Work Commission or the Western Australian Industrial Relations Commission (WAIRC) fall away.

This page is part of our guide to running a workplace investigation and deals with the planning documents.

In short:

  • Write the terms of reference before anyone is interviewed, and change them only in writing.
  • Put each allegation as a separate numbered item with who, what, when and where. An allegation states what is said to have happened, not a conclusion that the person bullied or harassed someone.
  • If the investigation could lead to dismissal, a tribunal will ask whether the person was told the reason and given a real chance to answer it before the decision was made. Anything you later rely on that was not put to them is a weak point.

What are terms of reference for a workplace investigation?

Terms of reference are the investigation's research plan. Written by the employer, or agreed with an external investigator, they fix the scope: what is being looked at, what is not, and what the employer wants at the end.

They are a different document from the allegations. Terms of reference describe the task, for example "to establish whether the conduct described in the complaint of 3 March occurred and, if so, whether it breached the Code of Conduct". Allegations describe the conduct. Do not send the person accused "terms of reference" that read as a list of conclusions about them: that suggests the outcome is decided.

Neither the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) nor the Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) (IR Act) requires an employer to write terms of reference. They matter because, if a dismissal follows, a written scope agreed at the start is the best evidence that the process was planned, fair and confined to the issues. Whether you need to investigate at all is covered in when to investigate.

What should terms of reference include?

Good terms of reference answer these questions:

(a) Who is commissioning the investigation, who is conducting it (internal or external, and who they report to) and what started it, by date and source. See who should investigate.

(b) The questions to be answered. Usually: did each allegation occur, on the balance of probabilities, and if it did, does it breach a named policy, contract term or procedure.

(c) What is out of scope, such as a broader culture complaint or an earlier grievance already dealt with.

(d) Who will be spoken to, and whether the investigator may add others.

(e) What documents and records will be collected: emails, work messaging, rosters, CCTV and the policies said to be breached.

(f) The standard of proof. Findings are made on the balance of probabilities, with the extra care for serious allegations described in Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336. How that works in practice is on our page on evidence and findings.

(g) What the report will contain. Findings on each allegation only, or recommendations as well. Keep the decision on any disciplinary outcome with a manager, not the investigator. See investigation reports and privilege.

(h) Timing, confidentiality, and who may approve a change, which is recorded in writing.

Is it a preliminary inquiry or an investigation?

Say which you are running. A preliminary inquiry decides whether there is anything to investigate and makes no findings against anyone. An investigation does.

The difference matters when you direct an employee to attend a meeting. In Avenia v Railway & Transport Health Fund Ltd [2017] FCA 859 the employer's suspension letter presented the meeting as part of a disciplinary investigation that could end in termination. The Federal Court held that, in that context, a direction to attend required either "reasonable particulars" of the allegations, or a clear statement that the meeting was only fact-finding and preliminary. Without either, the direction was unreasonable and the employee did not breach his contract by refusing (at [219]-[220]). That turned on one contract, but the lesson is general: tell people what a disciplinary meeting is about.

Describe the purpose truthfully

What you tell employees about why the investigation is being run must match the real reason. In Stephen v Seahill Enterprises Pty Ltd [2021] FWCFB 2623 the employee was told an investigation was independent, required by the employer's bullying policy and conducted in accordance with the Commission's directions. The Full Bench found those statements "not consistent with the true basis upon which" the investigator had been engaged, and "to that extent were misleading" (at [70]). If lawyers are running it for the purpose of legal advice, set that up at the start and say so accurately.

How do you write an allegation?

An allegation is a statement of what the person is said to have done, specific enough to admit, deny or explain. Each one should:

(a) deal with one incident or one course of conduct;

(b) give the particulars: the date (or the closest date range that can honestly be given), the place, what was said or done, to whom, and who else is said to have seen or heard it;

(c) describe conduct, not a conclusion. "You bullied Ms A" or "you sexually harassed a colleague" tells the person nothing they can answer. Say what the words or acts were, then separately identify the policy or term they are said to breach;

(d) be numbered, so each can be answered and decided separately.

A fictional example:

Weak: "It is alleged that you behaved inappropriately towards a team member during the Christmas function."

Better: "Allegation 2. It is alleged that at about 9.30 pm on Friday 12 December 2025, at the staff Christmas function at [venue], you said to Employee B, in front of Employee C, words to the effect of '[words]'. If substantiated, this conduct may breach clause 4.2 (respectful behaviour) of the Code of Conduct."

What does the law require?

For a national system employer (most companies), the unfair dismissal test in s 387 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) requires the Commission to consider, among other things, "whether the person was notified of that reason" and "whether the person was given an opportunity to respond to any reason related to the capacity or conduct of the person" (s 387(b), (c)). The Full Bench has said:

(a) notification of the reason must be given before the decision to dismiss is made, "and in explicit, plain and clear terms" (Wang v Springtime Poultry Pty Ltd [2025] FWCFB 190 at [78]);

(b) the person must be notified "with sufficient particularity to enable the person to respond to that reason" (Austin v Sandgate Taphouse Pty Ltd [2024] FWCFB 323 at [68]);

(c) no particular formality is needed: the object is that the employee is "aware of the precise nature of the employer’s concerns" and has "a full opportunity to respond to those concerns" (Austin at [53]).

That is consistent with the long-standing test, stated under the former federal legislation, that an employee "must be made aware of the particular matters that are putting his or her job at risk" (Gibson v Bosmac Pty Ltd [1995] IRCA 222). A small business employer (fewer than 15 employees) can also rely on having complied with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (ss 385(c), 388). These are matters the Commission weighs after a dismissal, not rules that make an investigation unlawful. But an allegation the person could not understand is one they could not answer, and that counts against the employer.

For a WA state system employer (sole traders, partnerships and other unincorporated employers, most state public sector bodies and local governments), the question for the WAIRC is whether the employee was "harshly, oppressively or unfairly dismissed" (IR Act s 29(1)(c)). There is no s 387 checklist, but the Full Bench in Trestrail v City of Karratha [2025] WAIRC 00820 adopted a long-standing statement of what fairness requires, quoting an earlier decision (at [25]): "The gravity of the alleged offence will dictate the nature and extent of the inquiry which the employer must conduct." The employer "must ensure that an employee is given as detailed particulars of the allegations against him/her as is possible, an opportunity to be heard in respect of such allegations, and a chance to bring forward any witnesses he/she may wish to answer those allegations". Not sure which system you are in? See am I covered.

Does an allegation letter have to be in writing?

Not under the Fair Work Act or the IR Act. The Full Bench has said there is no requirement for the reason to be given in writing for s 387(b) (Austin at [68]), and the IR Act has no equivalent rule. Put it in writing anyway. A letter is how you later prove what the person was told and when, and it gives them something to answer point by point. Check your enterprise agreement, contract and policies too: they may require written allegations.

Should you name the complainant or the witnesses?

Usually the person accused needs to know who made the allegation to answer it. If you hold back a name because of a genuine fear of reprisal, give every other detail. Anonymous complaints and whistleblower disclosures are covered in when to investigate.

Notifying the person accused

When should you tell them?

Ordinarily, once the complaint has been taken down in enough detail to particularise the allegations, and before the person is interviewed. In a fraud, data or IT matter there may be a good reason to secure records first so that nothing is deleted. If you do, keep it short and do not question the person about the conduct until they have the allegations. For how employees read these letters, see our pages on allegations and show cause letters.

The letter itself is outlined at the end of this page.

Support persons

For a national system employer, s 387(d) asks about "any unreasonable refusal by the employer to allow the person to have a support person present to assist at any discussions relating to dismissal". It is about refusing, not about failing to offer (Jurisic v ABB Australia Pty Limited [2014] FWCFB 5835 at [84]), though the Full Bench said whether the person was told may be relevant under s 387(h). Offer one in the letter. The IR Act has no equivalent provision. What a support person can and cannot do in an interview is on our page on investigation interviews.

How much time should they get to respond?

There is no fixed period. It depends on the number and age of the allegations and what is at stake. In Appeal by Grant [2014] FWCFB 3027 the Full Bench said that if the questions "had some unusual character or complexity to them it might be reasonable to seek to have a meeting adjourned and the questions or allegations particularised", but not where the inquiry was "very narrow, and clearly articulated" in advance (at [173]). Reasonable requests for an extension, or to move a meeting so a support person can attend, should usually be granted.

Suspension during the investigation

Suspend on full pay unless a contract, award, enterprise agreement or statute gives you the right to do otherwise: "At common law, an employer has no right to suspend an employee without pay for misconduct, even if that misconduct would justify summary dismissal" (Avenia at [154]). The WA public service is different. Under the Public Sector Management Act 1994 (WA) s 82(1), which applies to public service officers, ministerial officers and other prescribed employees (s 76(1)), once an employing authority decides to deal with a suspected breach of discipline as a disciplinary matter, it may, in accordance with the Commissioner's instructions, "suspend the employee on full pay, partial pay or without pay". See WA public sector employees.

Say that the suspension is not a finding, and keep it short. See also suspension and stand down.

How do you avoid scope creep?

Interviews surface older grievances and other incidents. The terms of reference decide what is in.

If something new is within scope and serious enough to rely on, treat it as a new allegation: write it up with particulars, amend the terms of reference in writing, give it to the person, and allow time to respond. Do not fold it into the findings without doing that. In Bartlett v Ingleburn Bus Services Pty Ltd [2020] FWCFB 6429 the employee was asked to respond to one incident, but the reason found for his dismissal was that incident together with three earlier ones. The Full Bench held he had not been notified of the reason for his dismissal, and having answered each earlier incident when it happened was not an opportunity to respond to all four taken together (at [22]-[24]).

If the new matter is outside scope, record it and deal with it separately or not at all.

Keep the language of the allegations stable, too. In Matthews v Qantas Airways Limited [2022] FWC 654 the investigation and the dismissal letter had described where the employee looked as the complainant's "chest". At the hearing the employer's counsel began describing it as her "breast area", which had never been suggested before (at [57]). The Commissioner said the late change seemed "potentially to involve at least the appearance of an attempted bolstering" of a "questionable and/or highly contestable dismissal ground" (at [62]), and found the employee had never been told the allegation was about the complainant's breasts (at [121]). The full story is in our case study.

A short illustrative structure

This is an outline, not a template. For terms of reference, use headings (a) to (h) above. An allegation letter usually covers:

  1. Why you are writing, and that no decision has been made.
  2. The numbered allegations, each with particulars and the policy or term said to be breached.
  3. The material relied on.
  4. The interview or written response, with dates, and the right to a support person.
  5. Any suspension, and its terms.
  6. Confidentiality, welfare support and a contact person.

Get the scope right before you start

Mistakes here are hard to fix once interviews start. If you have a complaint to investigate, we can draft or review the terms of reference and allegations, advise on suspension, or run the investigation for you. See our workplace investigations service or contact us.