Does this complaint need an investigation? When to investigate, when not to, and the alternatives

Updated 17 November 2026

Investigate when the complaint, if true, could lead to discipline or dismissal, or when an agreement, policy, contract or statute requires you to look into it. Do not investigate a performance problem, a trivial matter or a rumour with nothing behind it, and never use an investigation to remove someone you have already decided to lose. Most complaints sit somewhere in between, and the decision you make there, and the record you keep of it, matters as much as the investigation itself.

Five questions to ask before you decide:

  1. If everything in the complaint is true, what would you do about it?
  2. Is this about how someone behaved, or how well they do their job?
  3. Does an enterprise agreement, contract, policy or insurance policy tell you what to do?
  4. Does a statute put a duty on you: sexual harassment, a psychosocial hazard, a whistleblower or public interest disclosure?
  5. Is anyone at risk while you decide? If so, deal with safety first.

What would you do if the complaint were true?

A formal investigation ends in findings. It is worth the cost when those findings could change what happens next: a warning, a dismissal or a change to how your workplace runs. If nothing would change even if every allegation were proved, a conversation may solve the problem faster. And a short preliminary inquiry (checking records and messages, asking the complainant for detail) can tell you whether there is anything to investigate; the step-by-step guide explains the difference.

Is it a conduct problem or a performance problem?

Conduct is behaviour: what someone did, said or chose not to do. Performance is capability: whether someone can do the job to the standard required. Ask whether it is a matter of will or of skill.

The law treats them differently. In a national system unfair dismissal claim, if the dismissal related to unsatisfactory performance, the Fair Work Commission must consider whether the employee was warned about it first (Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 387(e)). Performance is managed with expectations, support and warnings, not allegations. The WA state system has no equivalent list, but the WAIRC asks the same kind of question in deciding whether a dismissal was harsh, oppressive or unfair. See performance management.

The two often blur. A policy breach may be misconduct, or a sign the employee was never trained, so check the training records. And a complaint of bullying against the manager running a performance plan usually needs to be looked at separately, and quickly.

Are you already bound to investigate?

Enterprise agreements

Many enterprise agreements set out a disciplinary procedure: when an investigation must happen, who runs it, the time limits and what the employee must be told. A person must not contravene a term of an enterprise agreement that applies to them (Fair Work Act s 50). In the WA state system, a WA award or industrial agreement can do the same, and its terms are enforceable in the Industrial Magistrates Court (Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) s 83). Breaching the procedure exposes you to a penalty claim and gives the employee a strong argument if a dismissal follows.

Contracts and policies

If a disciplinary policy is part of the employment contract, failing to follow it is a breach of contract. In Elisha v Vision Australia Limited [2024] HCA 50, the High Court held that the employee's particular contract incorporated the employer's disciplinary policies, and that damages for psychiatric injury caused by the employer's breach in running the disciplinary process were recoverable (at [1]-[2]).

A policy that says it is not contractual still matters, because a tribunal will ask why you did not follow your own procedure. In the WA state system, the Full Bench of the Western Australian Industrial Relations Commission (WAIRC) has said that even a departure from a procedure you said you would follow "may not constitute procedural unfairness": the issue is whether it caused demonstrated procedural unfairness to the employee (Trestrail v City of Karratha [2025] WAIRC 00820 at [203]). The employer in that case still lost the appeal, on other grounds. Follow your policy, or record why you did not, and update it if it no longer fits; see employment contracts and policies.

The WA public sector

A WA public sector employing authority aware of a possible breach of discipline may deal with it as a disciplinary matter under the Public Sector Commissioner's instructions, or take improvement action or no action (Public Sector Management Act 1994 (WA) s 81(1)). Read the instructions before you choose. See WA public sector employees.

Insurance

Check your management liability or employment practices insurance before you start. Many policies require you to notify the insurer of certain allegations, and some give the insurer a say in how the matter is handled.

Sexual harassment: the positive duty

Under the Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth) s 47C, an employer or a person conducting a business or undertaking must take reasonable and proportionate measures to eliminate, as far as possible:

(a) sexual harassment;

(b) harassment on the ground of sex;

(c) sex discrimination;

(d) hostile workplace environments on the ground of sex;

(e) related victimisation.

It covers conduct by you, your employees and agents, and harassment of your workers by third parties such as customers. What is reasonable depends on matters including the size, nature and circumstances of your business and your resources (s 47C(6)). The duty applies to every employer, whether in the national or the WA state system.

The duty does not wait for a formal complaint. If you learn of possible sexual harassment from an exit interview, a survey or an anonymous tip, respond proportionately and record what you did. You are also liable for sexual harassment by your employees unless you prove you took all reasonable steps to prevent it (Sex Discrimination Act s 106(2); Fair Work Act s 527E(2)). See our page on the positive duty.

The Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (WA) has no equivalent duty. The Equal Opportunity Bill 2026 (WA), which would replace that Act, would create one. As at 17 November 2026 it is still before the Legislative Assembly and has not passed.

Bullying and psychosocial hazards

A person conducting a business or undertaking in WA must ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, the health and safety of its workers (Work Health and Safety Act 2020 (WA) s 19(1)). This does not depend on which industrial relations system you are in (Commonwealth agencies are covered by the Commonwealth Act instead).

Since 24 December 2022, the Work Health and Safety (General) Regulations 2022 (WA) have dealt with psychosocial risks expressly. A psychosocial hazard includes one arising from workplace interactions or behaviours that may cause psychological harm (reg 55A). You must manage psychosocial risks and eliminate them, or if that is not reasonably practicable, minimise them, so far as is reasonably practicable (regs 55C, 55D(1)), having regard to matters including how work is managed, organised and supported and workplace interactions or behaviours (reg 55D(2)(d), (h)). A bullying complaint is a safety issue, not just an HR one.

Investigating properly is not bullying. In the national anti-bullying jurisdiction, reasonable management action carried out in a reasonable manner is not bullying (Fair Work Act s 789FD(2)), and management action includes disciplinary matters (Blagojevic v AGL Macquarie Pty Ltd [2018] FWCFB 4174 at [19]-[20]). The WA state system has the same exclusion (Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) s 51BI(2)).

In the WA state system, when the WAIRC considers the terms of a stop bullying order it must take into account, so far as it is aware of them, the final or interim outcomes of any investigation into the bullying, any grievance procedure available to the worker, and the outcomes of that procedure (Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) s 51BN(1)). In interim orders in Zhu v Department of Education [2026] WAIRC 00842, the WAIRC, satisfied that the allegations had not been exhaustively investigated under the employer's grievance framework, ordered the employer to investigate and deal with the grievance by a fixed date. See bullying and sexual harassment in the WA state system.

Whistleblower and public interest disclosures

Companies

A disclosure qualifies for protection under Part 9.4AAA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) if an eligible whistleblower makes it to an eligible recipient (including an officer, senior manager, auditor or authorised person) and has reasonable grounds to suspect misconduct, an improper state of affairs or certain contraventions of law (ss 1317AA, 1317AAC). If it qualifies:

(a) the discloser need not identify themselves (s 1317AA, note);

(b) disclosing the whistleblower's identity, or information likely to identify them, is an offence and a civil penalty contravention, except in limited cases, such as other information reasonably necessary to investigate, with all reasonable steps taken to reduce the risk of identification (s 1317AAE);

(c) causing or threatening detriment because of a disclosure is prohibited (s 1317AC).

A disclosure that is only a personal work-related grievance, such as a conflict with a colleague or a decision about the discloser's own promotion or discipline, generally does not qualify (s 1317AADA). Public companies and large proprietary companies must have a whistleblower policy (s 1317AI); if yours says how disclosures are investigated, follow it.

WA public authorities

For state government bodies, local governments and other public authorities, the Public Interest Disclosure Act 2003 (WA) applies:

(a) a disclosure can be made anonymously (s 5(6A));

(b) if the disclosure is made to your PID officer, your authority must investigate it, or cause it to be investigated, where it relates to the authority, its officers or contractors, or a matter it has power to investigate (ss 5(3)(h), 8(1)), although it may refuse or discontinue on grounds such as a trivial matter or a vexatious or frivolous disclosure (s 8(2));

(c) identifying a person who made a disclosure is an offence, with a penalty of $24,000 or two years' imprisonment, unless an exception such as consent, natural justice or effective investigation applies. Before relying on natural justice or effective investigation, you must take reasonable steps to tell the discloser first, unless the disclosure was anonymous (s 16(1), (2), (3A));

(d) information that might identify the person the disclosure is about is restricted in the same way (s 16(3));

(e) detrimental action because a disclosure was made is victimisation (s 15).

Anonymous complaints

An anonymous complaint is not a reason to do nothing, but it limits what you can do. Check whether it is a protected disclosure, look for evidence that does not depend on the complainant (records, messages, CCTV, other witnesses), and consider whether a culture review fits better than allegations against one person. But never discipline someone on allegations they have had no fair chance to answer. See terms of reference and allegation letters.

Repeated or vexatious complaints

Be careful before writing off a frequent complainer. In the national system, an employee's ability to make a complaint or inquiry in relation to their employment is a workplace right (Fair Work Act s 341(1)(c)(ii)), and adverse action because of it is prohibited (s 340), with the employer bearing the burden of proving the complaint was not the reason (s 361). In the WA state system, an employer must not take damaging action against an employee because the employee is able to make an employment-related inquiry or complaint, and once the damaging action is proved, the employer must prove that was not the reason (Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) s 97A(1), (2)).

Assess each complaint on its content. A repeat of one already investigated can be answered by pointing to the outcome.

When not to investigate

A formal investigation is usually the wrong choice when:

(a) the issue is performance, not conduct;

(b) the matter is trivial, or is rumour with nothing behind it;

(c) the conduct, even if proved, would not lead to any disciplinary outcome;

(d) the purpose is to exit an employee you have already decided to lose. If the real reason is a complaint they made, that may be adverse action or damaging action.

Some situations need judgement, and usually advice:

(a) out-of-hours conduct, which justifies action only in limited circumstances, such as where, viewed objectively, it is likely to cause serious damage to the employment relationship, damages your interests, or is incompatible with the employee's duties (Rose v Telstra Corporation Ltd [1998] AIRC 1592);

(b) the person affected does not want an investigation. If the conduct is serious or others are at risk, you may need to act anyway;

(c) police or WorkSafe is already investigating. You may still need your own process, but coordinate the timing;

(d) the person complained about is a contractor, customer or labour hire worker: you may have no disciplinary power, but your safety and positive duty obligations remain.

Can you stop an investigation part-way?

Yes, unless an agreement, policy, contract or statute says otherwise, for example when the issue turns out to be performance or the evidence will never be enough. Record why, tell the complainant and the person complained about what happens next, and make sure the decision cannot be read as punishing anyone for complaining.

Why the decision matters if a dismissal follows

In the national system, the Fair Work Commission decides for itself, on the evidence before it, whether the conduct occurred; a flawed investigation is irrelevant to whether there was a valid reason, but the process goes to the procedural fairness factors in s 387 (Illawarra Coal Holdings Pty Ltd v Gosek [2018] FWCFB 749 at [92]). In Wilson v Anglo Coal (Moranbah North Management) Pty Ltd [2017] FWC 4386, a technician was not told of allegations until about seven months after the events, and the Commission found no valid reason for his dismissal (at [68], [108], [124]; see our case study).

In the WA state system, the investigation carries more weight. The employer meets its evidentiary onus by showing it conducted as full and extensive an investigation as was reasonable in the circumstances, gave the employee every reasonable opportunity to answer, and honestly and genuinely believed, on reasonable grounds, that the misconduct occurred. The gravity of the alleged offence dictates the nature and extent of the inquiry. This is the approach in Bi-Lo Pty Ltd v Hooper (1992) 53 IR 224, which the Full Bench applied in Trestrail v City of Karratha [2025] WAIRC 00820 at [23]-[26]. For a serious allegation, a decision not to investigate is very hard to defend.

The alternatives

For an individual: a frank conversation, a letter of expectations, a facilitated discussion, coaching or performance management. For a team: training, a culture review or a policy refresh. Our workplace investigations page describes these. Mediation is rarely suitable for sexual harassment, serious misconduct or a large power imbalance, and choosing an alternative is still a decision about a complaint: tell the complainant what you are doing.

Record the decision either way

Write down the concern, what you considered, what you decided and why, and what you told the people involved. A tribunal or regulator will often ask for that note first.

If you investigate, next come who should investigate, the terms of reference, whether to stand anyone down, the interviews, the evidence and the report.

How we can help

Early advice saves the most time and money at this point. We advise WA employers in both systems on whether a complaint needs an investigation and the best alternative where it does not. Contact us for a confidential discussion, or read more about our workplace investigations service.