A workplace investigation report should set out the allegations, how they were investigated, the evidence on each one and a finding on each, and nothing about what discipline should follow. Write it on the assumption that the employee, a tribunal or a regulator will read it, because privilege protects a report only if getting legal advice was the dominant (paramount) reason it was created, and you can lose that protection by the way you use the report. The employee usually has no right to the report itself, but must be told the substance of the evidence against them and given a fair chance to answer it.
Our step-by-step guide covers the process from the start, and our page on weighing evidence and making findings covers how the investigator reaches each finding.
Before you sign off on a report, check:
- Is there a separate finding for each allegation, with the evidence and the reasons for it?
- Has the respondent seen and answered the substance of the evidence against them before any finding was made?
- Are any recommendations, and any advice on discipline, kept out of the findings report?
What should a workplace investigation report contain?
There is no form the law requires, but a report that will hold up later usually has these parts:
- A short summary: what was alleged, against whom, and the finding on each allegation.
- The scope: who commissioned the investigation, the terms of reference and any changes to them along the way (see our page on terms of reference and allegations).
- The method: who was interviewed and when, the documents and records reviewed, who was asked but declined, and the standard of proof applied.
- The allegations, one at a time. For each:
- the allegation as it was put to the respondent;
- the evidence for and against it, including the respondent's answer;
- the reasoning, including why one account was preferred over another;
- the finding, such as substantiated, not substantiated or unable to be determined.
- Attachments: the allegation letters, interview records, key documents and the terms of reference.
Write it for a reader who was not there
Assume a tribunal member, regulator or judge who knows nothing about your workplace will read it months later. Explain why each piece of evidence matters and leave out what does not bear on a finding. Never let a finding rest on something the respondent was not given a chance to answer.
A tribunal will not take your findings on trust: in a national system unfair dismissal claim based on misconduct, the Commission decides for itself, on the evidence before it, whether the conduct happened. The question is not whether the employer reasonably believed it did (King v Freshmore (Vic) Pty Ltd [2000] AIRC 1019 at [23]-[24], under the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth)).
Keep the findings, the recommendations and the decision apart
The investigator finds facts; the decision-maker decides what to do about them, after hearing from the employee. Keep separate:
- The findings report: facts and findings only.
- Recommendations, if you want them: a separate document, under a separate written instruction, given after the findings.
- Advice on discipline: from your lawyer, to the decision-maker, not inside the report.
A report that recommends dismissal suggests the decision was made before the employee responded. Advice kept out of the findings report is easier to protect if the report is later produced.
Is a workplace investigation report protected by legal professional privilege?
Only if the dominant purpose of creating it was for you to get legal advice, or for use in actual or expected legal proceedings. That is the common law test (Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (1999) 201 CLR 49 at [61]-[62]). "Dominant" means the paramount purpose, not just an important one. The purpose is judged objectively, at the time the report was created, and the employer claiming privilege has to prove it.
Privilege matters because it limits what a tribunal can make you hand over. The Commission can order a person to produce documents (Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 590(2)(c)), and it is not bound by the rules of evidence (s 591). A Full Bench has held that this power is still subject to legal professional privilege, because privilege is a substantive legal right that the Fair Work Act does not take away (Stephen v Seahill Enterprises Pty Ltd [2021] FWCFB 2623 at [61]). The WAIRC applies the same common law principles (Mullen v Gisborne [2009] WAIRC 01360; (2010) 90 WAIG 3 at [11]).
Having a lawyer run the investigation is not enough
A Full Bench has said that an ordinary investigation is not privileged merely because a lawyer conducts it. An investigation run under your policy, whose outcome is meant to be made known to the people involved and which may lead to discipline, does not ordinarily have a purpose confidential to the employer (Stephen v Seahill Enterprises at [71]).
Two decisions show the line:
- Privilege upheld. In a Perth case, the employer's lawyers prepared a protocol, marked privileged, saying the only purpose of the investigation was to help them advise the employer, and they engaged the external investigator. The report and the investigation documents were privileged (Tainsh v Co-Operative Bulk Handling Ltd [2021] FWC 3381 at [58]). Likewise where a law firm engaged an HR investigator by a letter saying the work was to help it advise its client (Kirkman v DP World Melbourne Ltd [2016] FWC 605 at [33]-[34]).
- Privilege rejected. A council told its employees that a law firm would investigate a complaint under its internal complaints procedure and that findings would be made. No proceedings were in contemplation, and the council gave no evidence of a legal advice purpose at the start. The Commission found the dominant purpose was to look into the complaint and hold people to account, and observed that the investigator could just as easily have been someone who was not a lawyer (Gaynor King [2018] FWC 6006 at [14]-[16]).
Even there, a record of the original complaint was not privileged: marking it "privileged" was not enough without evidence of a legal advice purpose (Tainsh at [63]).
Be straight with the people you interview
If the investigation is privileged, do not tell the people you interview it is something else. In Stephen v Seahill Enterprises, an employee was told an investigation was an independent inquiry under the bullying policy, when it was really run to help the employer's lawyers defend his own claim. The Full Bench found those statements misleading. He could not lawfully be directed to an interview whose real purpose was to help defend the claim he had brought, and had the employer persisted, it would have waived privilege (at [70]-[75]).
Decide whether you want privilege before the investigation starts. See who should investigate on when to bring in a lawyer.
How do you lose privilege over an investigation report?
Privilege is waived when you act inconsistently with keeping the advice confidential, whether or not you meant to give it up, and fairness can inform whether you have (Mann v Carnell (1999) 201 CLR 1 at [28]-[29], [34]).
Telling people the outcome, compared with relying on the report
Telling the respondent which allegations were substantiated, so that they can respond, does not usually waive privilege over the whole report:
- In Kirkman, a disciplinary letter saying that allegations were substantiated in the investigation did not waive privilege over the report (at [41]-[46]).
- In Tainsh, telling the employees which allegations against them were substantiated, so they could respond, did not waive privilege. The decision to dismiss rested on several factors and the employees' responses, not only on the report (at [70]-[75]).
Going further can cost you the privilege:
- In Gaynor King, the complainant was sent the investigator's close-out letter setting out the findings and why they were made, the investigation process was described in detail to the union, and the employer then asked the Commission to make findings based on the report. The Commission found the report was never privileged, but added that, even if it had been, that conduct waived privilege (at [14]-[19]).
- In a general protections (adverse action) claim, a board recommended dismissal after receiving a law firm's privileged investigation report. The employer's defence put the board's reasons in issue, and those reasons likely came from the report, so it would be unfair to let the employer rely on them without disclosing their factual basis. The court ordered the report produced (Bartolo v Doutta Galla Aged Services Ltd [2014] FCCA 1517 at [85], [90]-[95]).
If you will need the report to defend a dismissal, plan on the basis that it will be produced.
Can you give the report to a regulator without waiving privilege?
Sometimes. Disclosure for a limited purpose, on terms that keep the document confidential, is not necessarily a waiver (Mann v Carnell at [30], [32], [35]). The Full Federal Court held that a company did not waive privilege when it gave an investigation report to ASIC under a written agreement that kept the report confidential and limited what ASIC could do with it (Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Macleod [2024] FCAFC 174 at [13], [141]-[154]). Get the terms agreed in writing, and get advice, before any report goes to a regulator. A regulator's power to demand documents does not usually override privilege (Daniels Corporation International Pty Ltd v ACCC (2002) 213 CLR 543 at [11]). But a WA public body cannot claim privilege against the Corruption and Crime Commission (Corruption, Crime and Misconduct Act 2003 (WA) s 144(2)).
Does the employee get a copy of the investigation report?
Usually not, unless an enterprise agreement, contract or policy gives them that right. But they are entitled to know the case against them.
In Aurizon Operations Ltd v Webb [2024] FWCFB 318, a Full Bench held that the enterprise agreement did not give a worker facing a show cause letter a right to the investigation report. But the agreement required natural justice in the investigation, and the investigator had to put the substance of the credible, relevant and significant adverse evidence to him before making findings. That had not happened. The Full Bench said it would be prudent for the employer to reopen the investigation (at [56], [60]-[63]). We explain the case in Told to show cause, he asked to see the investigation report.
The same idea runs through national system unfair dismissal law: the Commission must consider whether the employee was told the reason for dismissal and given an opportunity to respond (Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 387(b), (c)). In practice:
- before any finding, give the respondent the allegations with particulars, and the substance of the evidence against them (what witnesses said and the documents relied on, with names withheld where there is a genuine reason);
- after the findings, tell them which allegations were substantiated. If you are relying on privilege, think carefully before also handing over the investigator's reasoning: disclosing only conclusions has been held not to waive privilege, while sending out findings and reasons and then relying on the report has been held to waive it (see above).
If a claim follows, from the respondent or the complainant, the Commission can order the report produced unless it is privileged. In Gaynor King, the complainant's own anti-bullying application, the Commission ordered the full report produced on its own motion, leaving the employer to seek redaction of some names (at [1]-[2], [21], [23]).
The complainant has no general right to the report either. Tell them in writing whether their complaint was substantiated, without the details of anyone's discipline.
What happens after a workplace investigation?
The findings go to a decision-maker
Someone other than the investigator should decide the outcome. If dismissal is possible, put the proposed outcome and reasons in a show cause letter, consider the response properly, then decide. See show cause letters and terminating employees.
Make the outcome consistent
Treating employees differently for comparable conduct can be relevant to whether a dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable, in a national system claim, as an "other matter" under Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 387(h). The cases must truly be comparable, and there must be enough evidence about them to make a proper comparison (Darvell v Australian Postal Corporation [2010] FWAFB 4082 at [21]-[24]). In Appeal by Jetstar Services Pty Ltd [2013] FWCFB 7030, a finding of harshness built on a comparison with another employee was quashed on appeal, because the two employees' conduct was not properly comparable (at [39]-[40]). Check what you did last time, and record why this case is the same or different.
The WA state system has its own unfair dismissal test: see unfair dismissal in the WA state system.
When a regulator or the police are also involved
WorkSafe may be investigating a serious incident at the same time as you, or police may be involved where the conduct could be a crime. In WA public bodies, the principal officer of a notifying authority (which includes public sector agencies, statutory authorities and local governments) must notify the Corruption and Crime Commission in writing of any matter relevant to their official role that they suspect on reasonable grounds concerns or may concern serious misconduct, as soon as reasonably practicable (Corruption, Crime and Misconduct Act 2003 (WA) s 28(2)-(3)). Minor misconduct is notified to the Public Sector Commissioner in the same way (s 45H). The duty arises on a reasonable suspicion, which may be well before your report is finished.
A parallel inquiry is not usually a reason to stop: you still have to deal with the conduct in your workplace. The exception is a written direction from the Corruption and Crime Commission not to start, or to stop, your investigation, which must be followed (s 42(2)-(3)). Keep to your own question (whether your policies were breached), do not interfere with the regulator's process, and get advice on what you share and when. Our page on WA public sector employees covers the separate rules for public bodies.
Do not leave someone stood down for months
Waiting on a regulator or a slow investigation can leave an employee stood down on full pay for months, which is costly and makes a return harder if nothing is proved. Set a timetable, review it regularly and consider other duties. See suspension and stand down.
Fix what the investigation found
Findings often point to wider problems, such as a manager who did nothing or a policy nobody was trained on. Act on them and record what you did. Check on the complainant and witnesses afterwards, and act quickly on any sign of victimisation. For sexual harassment, also consider your positive duty to prevent it, explained in when to investigate.
Getting help
If you have a report and a decision to make, or want an investigation set up so the report and advice are protected, contact us. We can run an independent investigation for you, or advise you on one someone else runs, and help you defend a claim if one follows. See our workplace investigations page.