You can investigate a complaint yourself, engage an external HR consultant, or ask a lawyer to do it. No law requires a private sector employer to use an outside investigator. The choice depends on who is involved, how serious the allegations are, and whether anyone inside the business can look at them without a conflict.
One rule applies only in Western Australia. Under the Security and Related Activities (Control) Act 1996 (WA), a person paid to investigate someone's conduct must hold an investigator's licence unless an exemption applies. Lawyers acting in the ordinary course of legal practice are exempt. An external HR consultant generally is not.
Before you engage an outside investigator in WA, ask for their investigator's licence. Unless they are a lawyer acting in legal practice, or fall within another exemption below, the Act requires one. A licensed investigator must also be employed by a business holding an inquiry agent's licence, unless they hold both licences themselves (s 31).
Can you investigate a complaint yourself?
As far as unfair dismissal law goes, yes. A manager, an HR officer, an outside consultant or a lawyer can all run a workplace investigation, and the law does not rank them (the WA licensing question is separate, and covered below). What matters is how the investigation holds up if a dismissal is challenged. The step-by-step guide sets out what the Fair Work Commission and the Western Australian Industrial Relations Commission (WAIRC) look at; two points bear on who investigates.
In the national system (most companies), the Commission's role is "to determine if the conduct occurred based on the evidence before the Commission and not based on the evidence before the decision maker" (Illawarra Coal Holdings Pty Ltd t/a South32 v Gosek [2018] FWCFB 749 at [92]). A flawed internal investigation does not on its own defeat a valid reason, but a one-sided process still counts against you, and your investigator's work is usually most of your evidence.
In the WA state system (sole traders, partnerships, other unincorporated employers such as a trust with individual trustees, most WA public sector bodies and local governments), the WAIRC looks at whether you investigated as fully as was reasonable and honestly believed, on reasonable grounds, that the misconduct occurred (Trestrail v City of Karratha [2025] WAIRC 00820, Full Bench). Employers "are not required to have the skills of police investigators or lawyers" (Minister for Health v Drake-Brockman [2012] WAIRC 00150, Full Bench), so an internal investigation can meet that standard. A conflicted one is much harder to defend, because your belief, and the grounds for it, are what is being tested.
WA public sector bodies have their own discipline rules under the Public Sector Management Act 1994 (WA). See WA public sector employees.
When should you use an external workplace investigator?
Internal investigations suit lower-level complaints and an investigator with no stake in the outcome. Look outside the business when any of the following applies:
(a) the person complained about is senior, an owner, or the investigator's own manager;
(b) the obvious internal investigator is a witness, was told about the conduct at the time, or has been complained about by either party;
(c) the allegations are serious: sexual harassment, assault, dishonesty, or anything that may also go to the police or a regulator;
(d) the complainant has already said the internal process is unfair, or the complaint is about how an earlier complaint was handled;
(e) nobody inside has the time, skills or training to do it properly.
Conflicts of interest and apparent bias
The risk is not only actual bias but a process that looks biased. In a general protections case, RPS AAP Consulting Pty Ltd v Lamb [2023] FCA 1310, a manager who had been the subject of an employee's complaint then drove the process that led to her demotion. On appeal, a judge of the Federal Court said the trial judge had not been persuaded of the employer's account partly because the manager "was conflicted, having been the subject of Ms Lamb's complaint", and that this "was unobjectionable" (at [86]). The manager "should not have been an author of the decision to demote, nor an active participant in that process" (at [88]).
That case was about who made the decision, not who investigated, but the lesson carries over. If an employee has complained about a person, keep that person out of the investigation and out of the decision. See also our case study of a manager who won his own adverse action case. Ask a proposed investigator, in writing, whether they know the parties or were involved in the events, record why you chose them, and if a party raises a conflict, deal with it on the record.
Does an HR consultant need a licence to investigate in WA?
Generally yes, if they are paid to investigate.
What the Act says
Section 28(1) of the Security and Related Activities (Control) Act 1996 (WA) defines an investigator as:
a person who for remuneration conducts — (a) investigations into the conduct of individuals or bodies corporate or the character of individuals; (b) surveillance work in relation to the matters referred to in paragraph (a); or (c) investigations concerning missing persons.
"Remuneration" includes "any forbearance or other valuable consideration" (s 3). A workplace investigation into whether an employee did what a complaint alleges is an investigation into the conduct of an individual, so an outside consultant paid to run one comes within the words of s 28(1)(a) unless an exemption applies.
Section 30 then provides that "a person must not act as an investigator except under the authority of an investigator's licence". A business that supplies investigators is an inquiry agent (s 27) and needs an inquiry agent's licence (s 29). Advertising or holding out that you will supply investigators without an inquiry agent's licence is a separate offence (s 33).
Who is exempt
These people do not need an investigator's licence for the work described (the Regulations also exempt some inquiries under the court security, prisons and declared places laws):
(a) a legal practitioner "while acting in the ordinary course of his or her profession as such", and a clerk of the practitioner acting in the ordinary course of the practitioner's profession (s 28(2)(a) and (b)). A legal practitioner means an Australian legal practitioner (Interpretation Act 1984 (WA) s 5). Whether a lawyer engaged only as an independent fact-finder, rather than to give legal advice, is acting in the ordinary course of the profession has not been tested in any decision we found;
(b) an insurer authorised under the Insurance Act 1973 (Cth), and its employees, acting in the ordinary course of its insurance business (s 28(2)(c) and (d));
(c) a member of Chartered Accountants Australia and New Zealand, CPA Australia or the Institute of Public Accountants, "while acting in the ordinary course of the accountant's profession" (Security and Related Activities (Control) Regulations 1997 (WA) reg 13A(2)(daa));
(d) people appointed, authorised or directed under particular provisions of the Public Sector Management Act 1994 (WA) to conduct a special inquiry, an investigation, a disciplinary matter, a report or a special disciplinary inquiry, and people employed or engaged to assist them (reg 13A(2)(a), (b), (c), (da), (d) and (e)). An outsider is covered only while acting under such a direction: in Mann v Employing Authority, Government Employees Superannuation Board [2008] WAIRC 00044, the Public Service Appeal Board held that outsiders directed under that Act to investigate a breach of discipline were not investigators while doing that work;
(e) public officers, meaning people employed by the Crown or by a body that is an agent of the Crown, while performing official duties: s 5(2) and (3) excuse them from Part 4 of the Act, which holds the investigator provisions. The Local Government Act 1995 (WA) makes a local government a body corporate (s 2.5) and does not say it is an agent of the Crown, so a council should not assume this exemption covers its HR staff.
There is no exemption for HR consultants or "workplace investigators" as such.
What about your own HR staff?
The Act does not answer this clearly. The definition turns on investigating "for remuneration", and an employee is paid. The Act's definition of a security officer expressly leaves out a person employed by one employer to guard that employer's property (s 12(2)), but the definition of an investigator has no equivalent carve-out for an employer's own staff. The only general exemption for employees is the one for public officers in s 5(2). We have found no decision on whether a private sector employer's HR manager, investigating a complaint as part of their job, is an "investigator" under the Act.
If they are, the risk is not only theirs. Employing an unlicensed person as an investigator is an offence by the employer (s 32), and your HR staff are your employees under a contract of service (s 4). There is an argument the other way: a licensed investigator may act only as an employee of an inquiry agent, a person who "supplies the services of investigators" (ss 27 and 31), which suggests a scheme written for investigators supplied as a service rather than an employer's own staff. The Act does not say so, and no court or tribunal has decided the point. If you are setting up a standing internal investigations role, or your HR staff spend much of their time investigating, get advice first.
The penalty
The penalty stated for acting as an investigator without a licence is "a fine of $15 000" (s 30). The same figure applies to acting as an inquiry agent without a licence (s 29), to a licensed investigator acting other than as an inquiry agent's employee (s 31), to employing an unlicensed investigator (s 32) and to advertising investigation services without an inquiry agent's licence (s 33). Each of those offences can instead be dealt with by an infringement notice with a modified penalty of $500 (s 88A; Regulations reg 58 and Schedule 5, items 10 to 14).
The offences fall mainly on the investigator and the business supplying them. The offence of employing an unlicensed investigator (s 32) uses the Act's meaning of employment, which is employment under a contract of service (s 4). So an employer that engages an outside consultant probably does not commit the s 32 offence itself. But knowingly engaging an unlicensed investigator carries a risk of being treated as a party to their offence: The Criminal Code (WA) s 7 makes a person who aids, or counsels or procures, an offence guilty of it, and the Code's definition of an offence is not limited to Code offences (s 2). We found no decision applying that to this Act. The larger practical risk is what the investigation is worth later.
What if your investigator was not licensed?
The Act does not say what happens to an investigation done by an unlicensed investigator, and we have found no tribunal decision that deals with it. In the national system the Commission makes its own finding on the evidence (Gosek at [92]), but whether it would also count an unlicensed investigator against the employer has not been decided. You do not want to defend a dismissal while the employee's lawyer points out that the person who gathered your evidence was committing an offence by doing so. Check the licence at the start.
What to check before you engage someone
(a) Ask for the individual's investigator's licence, and the inquiry agent's licence of the business that employs them, unless they hold both. Note the licence numbers and expiry dates in your file.
(b) If they say they are exempt, ask which exemption applies. For a lawyer, check they hold a current practising certificate, and have the engagement letter record that they are engaged as legal practitioners, and whether they are to investigate only or also to advise (see below).
(c) Put the licence, the scope and the fact that they are independent of the parties in the engagement letter.
Should a lawyer investigate?
A lawyer acting in the ordinary course of legal practice does not need an investigator's licence in WA. The more important question is whether the same lawyer, or the same firm, should both investigate and advise you on what to do with the findings.
Keep investigating and advising separate
An investigator's job is to find facts, fairly, without acting for either side. A lawyer advising you on discipline or a claim is acting for you. Running the two together undermines the independence the investigation needs. In Stephen v Seahill Enterprises Pty Ltd [2021] FWCFB 2623, the employer's solicitors and HR consultant told the employee, and the Commission, that an investigation by a barrister was independent and required by its bullying policy, when the barrister had in fact been engaged by the solicitors to help them advise on the employee's own anti-bullying application. The Full Bench found the representations "were not consistent with the true basis upon which" the barrister had been commissioned, "and to that extent were misleading" (at [70]). It quoted an earlier Full Bench: "[t]here is a very real difference between an independent inquiry and the provision of legal advice to a client" (at [71]). An application to the Full Court of the Federal Court for judicial review of the decision was dismissed (Stephen v Seahill Enterprises Pty Ltd [2022] FCAFC 85).
The usual ways to keep the roles apart are:
(a) your lawyer advises you and engages an independent investigator (a licensed consultant or another lawyer) to find the facts; or
(b) a lawyer investigates and reports findings only, and you take advice on the outcome from someone else.
Whichever you choose, describe the investigation to the employees accurately. Do not call it independent if it is not.
Legal professional privilege
Involving a lawyer can make an investigation report privileged, so that it need not be produced later, but only if the dominant purpose of commissioning it is legal advice or litigation. A lawyer running it does not make it privileged on its own (Stephen at [71]). Our article on investigation reports and privilege covers this in detail.
Skills matter as much as status
A licence or practising certificate does not tell you someone is good at investigating. Look for:
(a) workplace experience, not only general investigation or surveillance work;
(b) for sexual harassment or assault complaints, a trauma-informed, person-centred approach: one well-prepared interview with the complainant rather than several, a clear explanation of the investigator's role, and welfare support for everyone, the respondent included;
(c) a clear method: terms of reference before anyone is interviewed, a plan for the interviews, and findings made on the right standard (weighing evidence and making findings);
(d) the capacity to finish in a reasonable time, especially if someone is stood down.
Not sure a formal investigation is needed? Start with when to investigate.
Getting help
If you have a complaint to deal with and are not sure who should investigate it, or you want an investigation run or reviewed by lawyers, contact us or read more about our workplace investigations service. If a dismissal has already led to a claim, see defending a claim.