A workplace investigation decides each allegation on the balance of probabilities: is it more likely than not that the conduct happened? The more serious the allegation, the stronger the evidence you need before you are satisfied of it. That is the Briginshaw approach, and it is not a higher standard of proof.
Findings are where investigations are most often attacked. If the person is dismissed and brings a claim, the tribunal will test how you reached them. This page explains how to weigh the evidence so your findings hold up.
National system employers (most companies): in an unfair dismissal claim the Fair Work Commission makes its own finding on whether the conduct occurred. Your reasonable belief is not enough, unless you are a small business that followed the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 23, 388; Coogee Legion at [55]).
WA state system employers (sole traders, partnerships, unincorporated employers, most state public sector bodies and local governments): for dishonesty and serious misconduct, the Western Australian Industrial Relations Commission (WAIRC) may ask whether you honestly believed, on reasonable grounds and after a proper investigation, that the misconduct happened. For other misconduct you must show it happened. Not sure which system you are in? See Am I covered by the WA state system?
For the whole process, start with running a workplace investigation.
What standard of proof applies in a workplace investigation?
The balance of probabilities. The High Court has said this remains the standard "even where the matter to be proved involves criminal conduct or fraud" (Neat Holdings Pty Ltd v Karajan Holdings Pty Ltd [1992] HCA 66 at [2]). You do not need proof beyond reasonable doubt, even for theft or assault: a Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission rejected that suggestion in Coogee Legion Ex-Service Club Ltd v Giblin [2024] FWCFB 270 at [55] and [61].
What is the Briginshaw standard?
It is a way of applying the balance of probabilities, not a third standard. In Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336 at 361–362, Dixon J said that "reasonable satisfaction is not a state of mind that is attained or established independently of the nature and consequence of the fact or facts to be proved". Three things affect whether an allegation is proved:
(a) how serious the allegation is;
(b) how inherently unlikely the event is;
(c) how grave the consequences of a finding would be.
For a serious allegation, satisfaction "should not be produced by inexact proofs, indefinite testimony, or indirect inferences" (at 361–362). In Coogee Legion at [57] the Full Bench applied this to allegations of criminal conduct at work.
In practice, an allegation of sexual harassment, assault, fraud or dishonesty calls for clear and cogent evidence (first-hand where you can get it, or circumstances that point firmly one way) and a clear explanation of why it is enough.
Does the Evidence Act apply?
Not to your investigation. The Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) applies in federal courts (s 4), where s 140 requires a civil case to be decided on the balance of probabilities, taking into account "the gravity of the matters alleged" (s 140(2)(c)). That matters if a complaint reaches the Federal Court, for example as a general protections claim. It does not bind the tribunals that hear unfair dismissal claims:
(a) the Fair Work Commission "is not bound by the rules of evidence and procedure" (Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 591);
(b) the WAIRC "must not be bound by any rules of evidence" (Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) s 26(1)(b));
(c) WA courts are not federal courts, and s 140 is not among the provisions extended to every Australian court (s 5).
The Commission still applies Briginshaw (Coogee Legion), and so does the WAIRC when it decides for itself whether conduct occurred. Neither is bound by the rules of evidence, but both must act on evidence that logically supports the finding, not on rumour.
Will a tribunal accept your investigation's findings?
Not automatically.
National system: the Commission makes its own findings
The Commission must consider whether there was a valid reason for the dismissal (Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 387(a)). Where the reason is misconduct, "The test is not whether the employer believed, on reasonable grounds after sufficient enquiry, that the employee was guilty of the conduct which resulted in termination" (King v Freshmore (Vic) Pty Ltd [2000] AIRC 1019 at [24], Full Bench, decided under the former Act and still applied under s 387(a)). The Commission decides on the evidence before it, so "If the employer reached that conclusion based on a flawed investigation then that is irrelevant" to valid reason (Illawarra Coal Holdings Pty Ltd v Gosek [2018] FWCFB 749 at [92]).
Your evidence and reasons still become the core of your case. The fairness of the process is still weighed under s 387(b), (c) and (h). See defending a claim.
In Wilson v Anglo Coal (Moranbah North Management) Pty Ltd [2017] FWC 4386, an employer's sexual harassment findings did not survive the hearing: the accounts were in direct contradiction, the Commission preferred the employee's, and found no clear and cogent proof (at [130]–[131]). He was reinstated. See our case study.
WA state system: be ready to prove the conduct, and to defend your belief
The WAIRC asks whether the dismissal was harsh, oppressive or unfair. How it treats the misconduct depends on the allegation.
For dishonesty, such as theft, and for misconduct grave enough to harm the business or to raise safety or public interest concerns, the WAIRC applies an honest-belief approach (Minister for Health v Drake-Brockman [2012] WAIRC 00150 at [56], [61]–[62]). In Trestrail v City of Karratha [2025] WAIRC 00820 at [23]–[24], the Full Bench restated it. The employer meets its evidentiary onus if:
(a) it investigated as fully as was reasonable in the circumstances;
(b) it gave the employee every reasonable opportunity and enough time to answer the allegations;
(c) it then honestly and genuinely believed, on reasonable grounds and on the information it had at the time, that the employee was guilty of the misconduct;
(d) taking into account any mitigating circumstances, the misconduct justified dismissal.
The belief must be that the misconduct occurred, not merely that there was a risk of it (Trestrail at [26], [28]). "The gravity of the alleged offence will dictate the nature and extent of the inquiry" (at [25]). The approach has been applied to an allegation of sexual assault on a student (Parnell v The Roman Catholic Archbishop of Perth [2021] WAIRC 00102 at [118]).
Outside that category, "where misconduct is alleged or relied upon there is a burden on the employer to demonstrate that the alleged incident did occur" (Drake-Brockman at [63], applying Garbett v Midland Brick Company Pty Ltd [2003] WASCA 36 at [72]). Even within it, the WAIRC may decide for itself whether the conduct occurred (Drake-Brockman at [58]). In Amaya v Director General, Department of Education [2013] WAIRC 00412, a sexual misconduct case, it did so, applying Briginshaw (at [5], [21]).
So in WA, run the investigation so that you could prove the conduct happened, and so that your belief would stand up if that is what is tested. See what makes a dismissal unfair in the WA state system.
How do you weigh the evidence?
For each allegation, list what is agreed and disputed, then work through the evidence by topic and date, not witness by witness.
Direct and circumstantial evidence
An allegation can be proved by inference from established facts if the inference is the more probable one, but not by guesswork. Weigh the circumstances together, not one at a time.
In Law v Groote Eylandt Mining Company Pty Ltd [2018] FWC 1824, company property was found in an employee's checked bag and nobody saw him pack it. Considering the cumulative effect of the evidence, including the recorded weights of the bag and the improbability of his explanations, the Commission found it more probable than not that he had put the items there, and the dismissal stood (at [104]–[105], [110]–[112]).
Consistency
Test each account against itself, against what the person said earlier, and against the documents. Records made at the time usually carry more weight than memory months later.
In Amaya, a WA public sector cleaner was dismissed after a co-worker said he had touched or tried to touch her inappropriately on three occasions. He denied the conduct alleged. The WAIRC preferred her evidence: it matched what she had told the investigators and what she had told two co-workers soon afterwards, and an eyewitness supported one incident. His evidence at the hearing differed from what he had told the investigators, and his explanation for the difference was not accepted (at [22], [24]).
Plausibility
Ask what is likely to have happened, given everything else you know, and test each account against the setting and the timeline. In Drake v Melba Support Services Australia Limited [2023] FWC 677 at [22]–[23], the Commission rejected a claim that a sound could be heard through a heavy door with music playing, and a witness's claim to have watched a colleague continuously for five minutes.
Why you should not rely on demeanour
Whether someone looked nervous or confident is a poor guide to truthfulness. The High Court has noted research casting doubt on anyone's ability to tell truth from falsehood from a witness's appearance, and that this has encouraged judges to reason "as far as possible, on the basis of contemporary materials, objectively established facts and the apparent logic of events" (Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118 at [30]–[31]).
Collusion between witnesses
Similar wording or timing across complaints is a reason to ask questions, not proof of collusion. In Thompson Healthcare Pty Ltd v Adamopoulos [2017] FWCFB 6922, a finding that three staff had colluded in complaints against their manager, based on similar wording and emails sent within 14 minutes, was overturned. "A finding of collusion is a serious matter" (at [9]); the complaints were not strikingly similar, and the timing suggested some discussion but not collusion (at [15], [22]). The evidence was "too fragile a base" (at [23]).
Similar conduct by the same person
Evidence of past similar conduct can show a pattern, but it can also tempt you to decide on reputation. In a federal court, evidence of a person's conduct is not admissible to prove a tendency to act in a particular way unless, ordinarily, notice has been given and the court thinks it has significant probative value (Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 97). A similar rule governs reasoning from the similarity of several complaints (s 98). You are not bound by either, but take the caution behind them:
(a) say what you are using the evidence for;
(b) prefer conduct established by an earlier proper process over untested rumour;
(c) put it to the respondent before relying on it (see investigation interviews);
(d) still decide the allegation on its own evidence.
Missing witnesses and documents (Jones v Dunkel)
If a party could be expected to call a witness and does not, without explanation, a court may infer the evidence would not have helped them. The inference cannot fill a gap in the evidence: it only makes it easier to accept evidence already given, or to draw an inference already open (Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298, Kitto J at 308, Menzies J at 312).
The Commission has drawn it against employers. In Matthews v Qantas Airways Limited [2022] FWC 654 at [97], the employer did not call a participant whose signed investigation statement covered a disputed point, and the inference was drawn against it on that point. A Full Bench refused permission to appeal (Qantas Airways Limited v Matthews [2022] FWCFB 111).
As an investigator, if a party says a witness or document supports them, ask for it. If it is not provided without good reason, you may give that part of their account less weight, but explain why. And if you did not speak to an obvious witness, a tribunal will ask why.
He said, she said: what if there are no witnesses?
You can still make a finding. "Unable to be determined" is not the automatic answer.
Certainty is not required. In Drake at [32], the Commission said it was not certain the conduct happened, but that "certainty is not required". It accepted the co-worker's account because it was clear, detailed and consistent, fitted the surrounding circumstances, and she had no motive to lie (at [24], [27], [30]). The dismissal stood. Wilson shows the opposite result.
To decide a two-person allegation:
(a) look for anything that can be checked, including who each person told at the time, and speak to those people;
(b) test both accounts for consistency and plausibility, and record the points for and against each;
(c) weigh any suggested motive to invent the complaint only on evidence;
(d) if the respondent says the complaint is invented, both sides are alleging something serious. In a choice between "competing and mutually inconsistent allegations", generalisations about the need for clear and cogent proof are "likely to be at best unhelpful and at worst misleading": be conscious of the gravity on both sides, and decide on the balance of probabilities (Neat Holdings at [3]).
Do not let distress decide the question. The finding is about what happened. In Matthews at [119], the Commission criticised an investigation that "focussed on the subjective reactions of the complainant rather than properly balancing with a fuller consideration of what unfolded and the context", and the employee was reinstated. See our case study.
Substantiated, not substantiated or unable to be determined?
These are reporting labels, not legal categories. On the balance of probabilities an allegation is either proved or not. Most investigators use:
(a) substantiated: it is more likely than not that the conduct occurred;
(b) not substantiated: the evidence does not establish that it occurred, or shows that it did not;
(c) unable to be determined: for evidence that is genuinely evenly balanced or incomplete. Use it sparingly and explain why.
Define the labels in the report and use them consistently. Also:
(a) "not substantiated" does not mean the complainant lied. Say so. A finding that a complaint was false or vexatious needs its own evidence;
(b) saying you "prefer" one account is compatible with the balance of probabilities (Drake at [41]), but give your reasons;
(c) where an allegation is partly made out, say which parts;
(d) make the finding of fact first. Whether it breaches a policy or the law is a separate step, and what to do about it is another. Check that each allegation was put to the respondent in the form you decide it (terms of reference and allegations). Report structure is covered in investigation reports and privilege.
Get help with findings that will stand up
If you are weighing serious allegations or about to act on findings that could end someone's employment, talk to us first. We can review findings, run the investigation, or advise on the outcome. Contact us or read about our workplace investigations service.