Interviewing in a workplace investigation: complainant, witnesses and the person accused

Updated 17 November 2026

Most workplace investigations are won or lost in the interviews. Speak to the complainant first. Then interview the person accused and the witnesses, in whichever order suits the case, and make sure the person accused can answer everything new. Ask open questions before narrow ones.

If the matter ends in a dismissal, the Fair Work Commission or the Western Australian Industrial Relations Commission (WAIRC) will look closely at the interviews. This page is part of our guide to running a workplace investigation and builds on our workplace investigations page.

Three things that cause the most trouble in WA:

(a) recording an interview without the consent of everyone in it can be an offence under the Surveillance Devices Act 1998 (WA);

(b) choosing the employee's support person for them, or unreasonably refusing their choice, can count against you in a Fair Work unfair dismissal claim;

(c) questioning the person accused without first telling them what the interview is about can, with other failings, make an otherwise justified dismissal unfair.

Before the first interview

Settle the scope and the allegations in writing first (see terms of reference and allegation letters), and read the documents, such as emails, messages, rosters and CCTV, before you start.

Invite each person in writing: say whether they are a witness or the subject of an allegation, tell them they may bring a support person, give them your employee assistance program (EAP) details, and ask whether they need an interpreter.

Give enough notice to arrange a support person and prepare. The law sets no fixed minimum: a Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission did not regard four days, including a weekend, as too short for a meeting about a list of allegations (Victorian Association for the Teaching of English Inc v de Laps [2014] FWCFB 613 at [53]). Give the parties more time than a witness, and more again for serious allegations.

Check that each person is well enough to take part. If the person accused is being stood down, see suspension and stand down.

Who should be interviewed first?

Start with the complainant: you need their account in detail before you know what to ask anyone else.

After that, there are two common orders:

(a) the person accused second, then the witnesses either side names;

(b) the witnesses second and the person accused last. The risk is that the investigator forms a view after hearing only one side.

Either can be fair, provided the person accused hears and can answer all the evidence against them, so you will often interview them twice. If they raise something new, check it with the witnesses.

Interview witnesses one at a time and ask them not to discuss their evidence with each other. Weighing their accounts is covered in weighing evidence and making findings.

How should I question people in an investigation interview?

Start by explaining your role: to find out what happened, not to act for anyone. Explain who may see the evidence, and do not promise an outcome or confidentiality you cannot keep.

Then move from broad to narrow:

(a) open questions first ("tell me what happened at the Friday meeting"), letting the person give the whole account without interruption;

(b) clarifying questions next, filling in who, what, when and where, and separating what they saw or heard themselves from what they were told. Avoid questions that suggest the answer ("he was shouting, wasn't he?");

(c) testing questions last, putting any inconsistencies within their account, or with the documents or other witnesses, and asking them to explain.

Never tell an interviewee you do not believe them or that they are lying. It suggests you decided before gathering all the evidence, and it ends the cooperation. Ask instead what led them to that view, and whether a message, a photo or another person would support it. Credibility is for the report. Do not judge it by demeanour: nervousness and poor eye contact can come from stress, culture or personality.

At the end, summarise the main points back and check you have them right. Afterwards, give the interviewee a written record to correct and sign.

Interviewing the person accused

In the national system, the Fair Work Commission must take into account whether the employee was notified of the reason for the dismissal and given an opportunity to respond to it (Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 387(b) and (c)). In the WA state system, the Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) has no equivalent list. The WAIRC asks whether the dismissal was harsh, oppressive or unfair, and a denial of procedural fairness is one factor it weighs, not decisive on its own (Abuy v Town of Port Hedland [2025] WAIRC 00301 at [162]). In either system, much of that opportunity is given in the investigation interview.

Give the person accused each allegation in writing beforehand, with enough detail (who, what, when and where) to answer it. In Jarmain v Linfox Armaguard Pty Ltd [2018] FWC 3255, an employee asked to come to the depot because the security team wanted to talk to him was questioned in a recorded interview about complaints from two clients that he had not been told about. The Commission said the process "had all the characteristics of an ambush" (at [63]). There was a valid reason for the dismissal, but that failing, together with the employer choosing his support person and suspending him without pay in breach of the enterprise agreement, made it unfair "by fine margin only" (at [77]–[79]).

In the interview, take them through each allegation, ask for their response, then put the evidence you rely on: what each witness said, the documents and any footage. If there is a lot, let them respond in writing within a reasonable time.

Does the rule in Browne v Dunn apply to a workplace investigation?

The rule in Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 R 67, a House of Lords decision, is a courtroom rule. The High Court has described it as an obligation to give a party and their witnesses notice of any imputation you intend to make against them, and has said that, ordinarily, if a witness's evidence is to be challenged, the grounds must be put to that witness (MWJ v The Queen [2005] HCA 74 at [18], [38]).

An internal investigation is not bound by the rule as such, but its idea makes a good working rule: make no finding against anyone, the complainant and witnesses included, on a point they have not had a chance to answer.

Support persons

Do I have to allow a support person at an investigation interview?

In the national system, the Commission must take into account "any unreasonable refusal by the employer to allow the person to have a support person present to assist at any discussions relating to dismissal" (Fair Work Act s 387(d)). It is a factor in deciding whether a dismissal was unfair, and it turns on refusal: a Full Bench has said it "is not concerned with whether or not the employee was informed that he or she could have a support person present", although that may be relevant under s 387(h) (Jurisic v ABB Australia Pty Limited [2014] FWCFB 5835 at [84]).

Offer one anyway, to everyone you interview: an interview with a support person present is harder to attack later.

Let the employee choose who it is. In Jarmain, the employer chose the support person, which the Commission treated as in practice refusing the employee a support person of his choice (at [65], [77]). You can object to a particular person, such as another witness in the same investigation, but explain why, allow time to find someone else, and consider reasonable requests to reschedule.

What can a support person do in the interview?

A support person is not an advocate. A Full Bench held that, given what s 387(d) provides and with no other obligation to allow one, refusing an employee an advocate at a disciplinary meeting was not procedurally unfair (de Laps at [52]). Check whether an enterprise agreement, contract or policy gives a right to representation.

But they need not sit in silence. In Goss v Health Generation Pty Ltd [2021] FWC 1751, the Commission said a support person "should not hijack a lawful and reasonable process or answer for an employee", but rejected the view that they should "only be seen and not heard", because they can help when the employee is struggling to follow the process or an explanation is being misunderstood (at [48]).

So explain the role at the start. A support person may take notes, ask for a break and ask a question to clarify the process. They should not answer for the interviewee or argue the case. If they do, pause and remind them of the role.

What about the WA state system?

The Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) has no provision like s 387(d): the only matters s 23A(2) lists are probation and work in a private home. The WAIRC treats a support person complaint as part of the general question of fairness. In Abuy, the employee said her preferred support person had been prevented from attending a performance meeting. She was offered a postponement and chose to go ahead, and the Commission found no unfairness (at [177]–[181]). Her appeal was dismissed (Abuy v Town of Port Hedland [2026] WAIRC 00261). Offering a support person and a chance to reschedule is the safe course in both systems. Public sector employers should also check their own discipline rules: see WA public sector employees.

Confidentiality directions to interviewees and support persons

You can direct employees to keep an investigation confidential, and a breach can be a disciplinary matter. But the direction must be reasonable, and any discipline for breaching it must be proportionate. Two decisions show where the lines fall.

(a) In Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v MSS Strategic Medical and Rescue [2014] FWC 4336, a dispute under an enterprise agreement rather than an unfair dismissal claim, an employee acting as a colleague's support person forwarded the employer's letter to that colleague to his work group and his union. The letter said the investigation was confidential. The direction in it was addressed to the colleague, not to him, but the Commission found that anyone acting as a support person should understand the process is private and respect its confidentiality (at [48]–[50], [63]). Even so, a final written warning was harsh: the letter contained little that was confidential, he had a long clean record and he meant no harm. The Commission found a written warning was the appropriate response (at [54], [57]–[66]).

(b) In Goss, an employee who had complained of sexual harassment was told she could discuss the investigation only with her support person or her lawyers. She told her partner about her interview, he sent threatening messages to a witness, and she was dismissed. The direction was lawful but unreasonable: it was unrealistic to stop her confiding in both her lawyers and the person she relied on for support. The dismissal was unfair (at [49]–[50], [64]).

In practice:

(a) give the direction in writing and repeat it at the interview, to the interviewee and any support person, and ask each to confirm they understand it;

(b) allow the interviewee to talk to their lawyer, doctor, union and a partner or close family member, on the basis that they keep it confidential too;

(c) do not use a confidentiality direction to stop someone going to a regulator or exercising another legal right;

(d) do not promise an interviewee that what they say will be kept from the person accused. If it is adverse to them, fairness will usually require you to put its substance to them.

Can I record an investigation interview?

Only with consent. In WA, it is an offence to use a listening device to record a private conversation you are a party to (Surveillance Devices Act 1998 (WA) s 5(1)(b)), unless an exception applies. Two exceptions matter here:

(a) each principal party to the conversation, meaning each person who speaks or is spoken to, consents expressly or impliedly (s 5(3)(c)). This is the exception to rely on;

(b) one principal party consents and the recording is reasonably necessary to protect their lawful interests (s 5(3)(d)). Whether that applies turns on the facts, tribunals have read it narrowly, and an investigator should not rely on it to record an interview covertly.

Video is covered in the same way for what is seen (s 6(1)(b), (3)). Separately, passing on a recording, or a report of what it captured, is restricted (s 9). The Act is on the WA legislation register.

That includes a video-call recording. If you want to record, say so in the invitation, ask everyone present (support person included) to consent at the start, and record that consent. If anyone refuses, take notes instead, and ask the interviewee and support person to confirm they are not recording either.

Employees do sometimes record secretly. In Thompson v John Holland Group Pty Ltd [2012] FWA 10363, a Perth decision, an employee secretly recorded a meeting with two managers and played it to a colleague. There was no proper basis to think recording was needed to protect his lawful interests, so the recording was not admitted into evidence, and the recording and the replaying were each a valid reason for dismissal (at [132]–[135], [138]–[139]). In Stoddard v Crushing Services International Pty Ltd [2025] FWC 2673, a WA mine truck driver's secret smartwatch recording was misconduct, though not serious enough to justify dismissal, and his unfair dismissal compensation was cut by 20% because of it (at [136], [160]). See our case notes on that driver and on a retail worker who secretly recorded her managers.

Reluctant witnesses and directions to attend

People hold back because they fear retaliation or think the outcome is decided. Explain the process and the protection against victimisation first: a willing witness gives better evidence than a directed one.

If that fails, you can generally direct an employee to attend, if the direction is lawful and reasonable. In Abdulrahim v QBE Management Services Pty Limited [2016] FWC 2985, an employee was directed in writing to attend an interview about a possible conflict of interest, warned that refusing could lead to dismissal, and offered a different investigator when he objected to the first. His continued refusal was a valid reason for dismissal, and the dismissal was not unfair (at [17]–[19], [29], [31]–[32]).

Employees must also answer reasonable questions honestly. A Full Bench held that an employee "had an obligation to answer [the employer's] reasonable inquiries honestly", even about personal matters, where those matters were affecting the workplace (Telstra Corporation Ltd v Streeter [2008] AIRCFB 15 at [15], [20]).

Put any direction in writing, with the reason, the right to a support person and the consequences of not attending. Deal with genuine objections, and get medical information before directing someone on sick leave. You cannot direct people who are not your employees, such as former staff or customers; you can only ask.

Looking after people during the interviews

Investigations are stressful for everyone, including the person accused. Check on welfare before and after each interview, offer the EAP to everyone, keep the timetable as short as fairness allows, and if someone says they feel unsafe, act straight away.

Get advice before the interviews start

If you are planning an investigation, or a problem has come up in one under way, contact us. We can advise on the process or conduct the investigation for you: see our workplace investigations page.