Mine technician sacked over harassment at camp loses his claim

Dean Dunlop v BHP Billiton WAIO Pty Ltd T/A BHP [2022] FWC 790

Decided by
Fair Work Commission
Date
11 April 2022
Outcome
Claim dismissed
Result
Employer succeeded
Illustrative image. It does not show the people in this case.

A 58-year-old service technician at BHP's Yandi iron ore mine was stood down, investigated and summarily dismissed after two young contract cleaners complained of sexual harassment at the mine's accommodation village. He denied everything. The Fair Work Commission heard all three, preferred the cleaners' evidence, and found his dismissal was not unfair.

Key points

  • Where the worker and the complainants give opposite accounts, the Commission decides for itself what happened, after hearing and observing the witnesses.
  • Sexual harassment of a co-worker or contractor in a workplace accommodation village can be a valid reason for dismissal and can amount to serious misconduct.
  • A worker who refuses to attend a show cause meeting may still have had a fair chance to respond, especially where the employer accepts a written reply.
  • A delay in reporting harassment did not make the complainant's account less believable here.

What happened

Mr Dunlop was a service technician in de-watering at BHP's Yandi iron ore mine in the Pilbara. He started with BHP in 2018, worked fly-in fly-out, and lived at the mine's accommodation village between shifts. He was 58.

On 20 June 2021 his superintendent told him he was being stood aside on full pay while allegations of inappropriate behaviour were investigated, and drove him to Newman to catch a flight home. He was not told what the allegations were.

On 15 July 2021 an investigator sent him two allegations. Both came from young women employed by ESS, the contractor that cleans the village. The first, a 21-year-old cleaner, said that one night in mid-January 2021 he grabbed her in a tight hug near the camp tavern, pinning her arms to her sides, and whispered a crude sexual remark in her ear. The second, who was 18 when she started the job, said that on the evening of 19 June 2021 he made a lewd comment to her while she was finishing her housekeeping shift, then grabbed her breast as she tried to walk past him.

The investigation and the dismissal

Mr Dunlop denied both allegations by phone. On 23 July 2021, before the investigation finished, he emailed a resignation letter. His superintendent wrote back that the resignation was not accepted because the investigation was pending.

The investigator found both allegations substantiated. On 12 August 2021 his superintendent rang to say so, told him BHP was considering dismissing him, and invited him to a show cause meeting: a meeting at which the employer sets out what it has found and the worker can explain why they should not be dismissed. On the morning of the meeting he texted that he would not attend, saying he had been found guilty from the start. BHP then sent him a show cause letter asking for a written reply, and he sent a second text maintaining his denial. BHP dismissed him without notice for serious misconduct on 19 August 2021. Six days later he applied to the Fair Work Commission for an unfair dismissal remedy.

Whose evidence did the Commission accept?

The hearing turned on a direct conflict. Both women gave evidence in person; their names were protected by a non-publication order, so the decision calls them Complainant 1 and Complainant 2. Mr Dunlop agreed he had spoken to the second cleaner that evening, offered to have a beer with her and rung her afterwards, but denied the lewd comment and denied grabbing her breast. He denied the tavern hug altogether.

Commissioner Williams noted that the second cleaner's written incident report, made the next day, was consistent in its critical parts with what she later told the investigator and the Commission, and that no reason had been suggested for why she would invent a complaint against a stranger. Having watched both witnesses, he preferred her evidence.

The first cleaner had not reported the January incident at the time. She explained that this kind of behaviour happened regularly when she was out with friends and was usually brushed off, but that when she heard it had happened to another young woman she would not stay silent. The Commissioner reasoned that, to accept Mr Dunlop's denial, he would have to find she had made up a detailed story on the spot and kept it up through an incident report, the investigation and sworn evidence. He preferred her evidence too.

Under s 387 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), the Commission decides whether a dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable by weighing a list of factors. The first is whether there was a valid reason related to the worker's conduct, including its effect on the safety and welfare of other employees. Most of the others look at fairness of process: whether the worker was told the reason, given a chance to respond and allowed a support person, and how the employer's size and HR expertise affected the procedure. Any other relevant matter can also be weighed.

The Commissioner found that each incident was, on its own, a valid reason for dismissal. It was sexual harassment, which amounted to serious misconduct, and it also breached the BHP code of conduct Mr Dunlop was bound by under his contract.

The process was fair too. He was sent the allegations during the investigation and the findings in the show cause letter. He chose not to attend the meeting, but his texts were treated as his response, so he had his opportunity to reply. Nobody refused him a support person, and BHP is a large employer with specialist HR staff. Taking everything into account, including his age and length of service, the dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable, and the application was dismissed.

What this means for you

If you are stood down while allegations are investigated, take the process seriously. The show cause stage is usually your real chance to give your side, and refusing to take part rarely helps. A blanket denial will not carry the day if the Commission finds the other witnesses more believable.

If you have been harassed at work, including in a mining camp, you can report it even months later. Here a delayed complaint was still accepted, partly because it was supported by what the complainant told others on the night.

If you want to challenge a dismissal, the time limit is short: 21 days from the dismissal to lodge an unfair dismissal application with the Fair Work Commission.

The takeaway

Sexual harassment of a co-worker or contractor, even in a camp tavern after hours, can justify dismissal. Where accounts conflict, the Commission weighs the witnesses itself, and an employer that investigates and gives the worker a real chance to respond is well placed.

Note: We found no appeal from this decision (appeals_db and the case graph show none). The s 387 factors are unchanged. The law on workplace sexual harassment has also moved. The Fair Work Regulations now list sexual harassment in the course of employment as an example of serious misconduct (reg 1.07). Since 6 March 2023 Part 3-5A of the Fair Work Act prohibits sexual harassment in connection with work, and the Commission can deal with those disputes. Since December 2022 employers have a positive duty under s 47C of the Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth) to take reasonable and proportionate measures to eliminate it. For dismissals from 1 July 2026 the high income threshold is $190,100 and the compensation cap $95,050.

Fair Work Commission · 11 April 2022

Dean Dunlop v BHP Billiton WAIO Pty Ltd T/A BHP [2022] FWC 790, Commissioner Williams. Read the full decision

This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.

Does this sound like your situation?

More case studies