A senior prison officer's private-life assaults cost him his job

Sparkes v Industrial Relations Secretary in respect of the Department of Communities and Justice (Corrective Services NSW) [2022] NSWIRComm 1021

Decided by
Industrial Relations Commission of New South Wales
Date
31 March 2022
Outcome
Appeal dismissed; termination upheld
Result
Employer succeeded
Illustrative image. It does not show the people in this case.

A senior correctional officer in New South Wales was found guilty of assaulting a junior co-worker with whom he had an affair. His employer terminated his employment, giving him the chance to resign first. He argued the conduct was private and never affected his work, but the NSW Industrial Relations Commission upheld the decision.

Key points

  • Misconduct does not have to happen at work, or affect the worker's own performance, to justify dismissal.
  • Under the NSW public sector rules, a finding of guilt for a serious offence is misconduct even if it happened off duty.
  • The Commission looked at the effect on the co-worker, who was his junior, and at the trust placed in a senior prison officer.
  • Attacking the victim's credibility while admitting the conduct, and showing no real remorse, counted against him.

What happened

Mr Sparkes joined Corrective Services NSW as a probationary correctional officer in April 2011 and was promoted to Senior Correctional Officer in May 2017. In 2016 he received a Commissioner's Commendation for Bravery. In 2018, though, he was found to have used excessive force against inmates on two occasions, and was fined.

In about November 2018 he began an extra-marital relationship with a female correctional officer. He was her superior officer throughout. The judgment calls her by the pseudonym "Ms Jones", and a non-disclosure order protects her identity.

In November 2019 he was arrested and charged with two counts of common assault, domestic violence related, and with stalking and intimidation. In September 2020 he pleaded guilty to the assaults, and the stalking charge was withdrawn. The agreed facts recorded that he had repeatedly slapped, poked and pinched her during the relationship, and that she told him to stop each time. The court found him guilty without recording a conviction and placed him on a 12-month conditional release order.

The disciplinary process

In May 2021 the custodial director for the region wrote to him. Because he had been found guilty of a serious offence, the letter said, he had engaged in misconduct, and termination was proposed, with an opportunity to resign. He was invited to respond in writing or in person.

He attended an interview with his union representative. A few days later the director confirmed the decision, and Mr Sparkes resigned on 28 May 2021. He then appealed the decision to the NSW Industrial Relations Commission.

His case: private life, no effect on work

Mr Sparkes accepted that he had engaged in misconduct. Under the Government Sector Employment Act 2013 (NSW), a finding of guilt for a serious offence counts as misconduct, and the Act says misconduct can relate to conduct while the employee was not on duty. So the only question was what disciplinary action was right.

He argued that termination was too harsh. The assaults happened in a private relationship, outside work. His work performance had never been in question, and he had kept working on active duty after the guilty finding. He also said his conduct was part of what he called consensual "sexual horseplay" that went too far, and he attacked the co-worker's credibility, including by pointing out that she had stayed in the relationship.

What the Commission decided

Commissioner Sloan dismissed the appeal and rejected the horseplay account. Mr Sparkes had admitted in the agreed facts that she told him to stop on each occasion, and his attempt to back away from them was "half-hearted and unconvincing". The Commissioner found the co-worker a witness of truth and preferred her evidence.

The Commissioner also refused to weigh against her the fact that she stayed, and would not place great weight on an argument that a domestic violence victim is less believable "simply by virtue of remaining in an abusive relationship". Making that argument while admitting the conduct, the Commissioner said, lacked integrity.

Why: off-duty conduct can still end a job

The key finding was that misconduct does not have to affect the worker's own performance to justify termination, and it is not enough to say it happened in private. The Commissioner gave two reasons why the private setting did not reduce the seriousness here.

First, the relationship spilled into work. Mr Sparkes accepted that their difficulties carried over into the workplace. The co-worker gave evidence that he was often her direct manager, moved staff so she would not work alone with another man, and sometimes followed her home or waited for her in the car park. She was his subordinate, which mattered.

Second, his role. A correctional officer guards and rehabilitates inmates, including people jailed for violence, and a senior officer with ten years' service is expected to set an example.

The Commissioner also took his 2018 misconduct into account, and found no real remorse: his written apology was equivocal, saying he had "acted like a silly teenager". His complaint that the interview, which he said lasted nine minutes, was unfair also failed, because the letter set out the case against him and he had union help to answer it.

What this means for you

What you do outside work can cost you your job, particularly where it involves a co-worker, is criminal, or clashes with a role built on trust. Public sector employees often have written codes of conduct that expressly cover off-duty behaviour. In the federal unfair dismissal system the test is different, but out-of-hours conduct can still be a valid reason for dismissal where it has a real connection to the job.

If you are facing disciplinary action over conduct outside work, it is worth getting advice early, before you respond. Your response should be accurate and consistent with anything you have already admitted elsewhere.

The takeaway

Saying "it happened in my private life" is not a defence when off-duty misconduct affects a co-worker or the trust a role depends on. Admitting the conduct while attacking the victim's credibility only made this officer's position worse.

Note: This is a New South Wales public sector decision under the Government Sector Employment Act 2013 (NSW) and the Industrial Relations Act 1996 (NSW), so its rules do not apply directly in Western Australia or the federal system. WA public sector employees have their own disciplinary rules under the Public Sector Management Act 1994 (WA), and most private sector employees fall under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). We found no record of an appeal from this decision, but the data we searched holds few NSW Industrial Relations Commission decisions.

Appeal dismissed; termination upheldMisconductPublic sectorProcedural fairness

Industrial Relations Commission of New South Wales · 31 March 2022

Sparkes v Industrial Relations Secretary in respect of the Department of Communities and Justice (Corrective Services NSW) [2022] NSWIRComm 1021, Commissioner Sloan. Read the full decision

This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.

Does this sound like your situation?

More case studies