Manager who waited for Novavax loses unfair dismissal claim

Kathryn Roy-Chowdhury v The Ivanhoe Girls' Grammar School [2022] FWC 849

Decided by
Fair Work Commission
Date
12 April 2022
Outcome
Claim dismissed; appeal refused
Result
Employer succeeded
Illustrative image. It does not show the people in this case.

A Melbourne girls' school dismissed its Risk and Compliance Manager after she stayed unvaccinated under Victoria's 2021 vaccination direction for education workers, saying she would wait for the Novavax vaccine. The Fair Work Commission found the dismissal was not unfair, because part of her job had to be done on site and the law barred her from being there. A Full Bench refused her permission to appeal.

Key points

  • Being legally barred from a workplace your job needs you to attend can be a valid reason for dismissal related to capacity, without any misconduct.
  • Working from home during lockdown did not prove the role could normally be done remotely: on-site tasks had been put off or done by others.
  • The Commission will not rule a public health order invalid; it treats such orders as lawful until a court says otherwise.
  • The school gave her a written warning, two meetings and four extra weeks to decide, so the process was fair.

What happened

Kathryn Roy-Chowdhury started at Ivanhoe Girls' Grammar School in Melbourne on 20 January 2021 as its part-time Risk and Compliance Manager. Her role covered risk management, compliance and policy, and workplace health and safety, and she sat on the school's COVID-19 Management Committee.

On 1 October 2021 Victoria's Acting Chief Health Officer issued a mandatory vaccination direction under the Public Health and Wellbeing Act 2008 (Vic). From 18 October 2021 schools had to take reasonable steps to keep unvaccinated education workers off the premises, unless the worker had a first dose booked by 25 October. A school that did not comply committed an offence.

Ms Roy-Chowdhury helped write the school's own vaccination policy: she chaired the committee meeting on 5 October 2021 that endorsed the final draft. The policy warned that staff who did not comply could face disciplinary action "up to and including termination of employment".

Waiting for a different vaccine

On 8 October 2021 she emailed the school that she intended to be vaccinated once the Novavax vaccine became available, and asked to work from home or take unpaid leave until then. She said she had been able to "100% perform my duties from home".

The principal replied on 11 October that the school could not exempt her. At a video meeting the next day, the principal told her that waiting for Novavax would not comply with the direction. It was agreed she would work from home until 25 October, then go on unpaid leave until 15 November, giving her four weeks to get advice and decide.

At a second meeting on 8 November she said she would still wait for Novavax. The Commission later found that the principal told her then that if she was still unvaccinated on 15 November, her employment would be terminated. On 12 November she asked for the school's COVID-19 vaccination risk assessment. The school did not reply, and had not carried one out. She was dismissed by letter on 15 November 2021.

The claim and the decision

Representing herself, Ms Roy-Chowdhury applied to the Fair Work Commission for an unfair dismissal remedy under s 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). She argued that she could do her whole job from home, as she had for 16 weeks during lockdowns; that vaccination was not in her contract; that the direction was unlawful; and that she had been coerced.

On 12 April 2022 the Deputy President found the dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable, and dismissed the application.

Under s 387 of the Act, the Commission decides whether a dismissal was "harsh, unjust or unreasonable" by weighing a list of matters. The main ones are whether there was a valid reason related to the worker's capacity (ability to do the job) or conduct, whether the worker was told of that reason and given a chance to respond, and whether a request for a support person was unreasonably refused. A valid reason is one that is "sound, defensible or well founded".

Deputy President Young first dealt with the direction. The Commission treats legislation as valid until a court says otherwise, and the school "simply did not have a choice" about complying.

The key question was whether the job could be done from home. The position description did not say so either way, but it required a working with children check, which would be unnecessary if she never came on site. The Deputy President accepted the school's evidence that the role involved on-site incident follow-ups, audits and emergency drills. The 16 weeks at home did not prove otherwise: lockdown was "an emergency arrangement during which no students and few staff were present", and on-site tasks had been put off or done by others.

Because part of her job required her on site and the direction barred her from being there, she was not "ready, willing and able" to do her job. That was a valid reason related to her capacity. The school never accused her of misconduct. Her contract argument failed because the requirement came from the direction, not the school, so no question arose of whether a school instruction was reasonable.

On process, she had been told on 8 November what would happen, and had several chances to respond. She never asked for a support person. She was owed no notice pay because she was on unpaid leave and working no hours. The missing risk assessment carried no weight, because the vaccines were approved by the Therapeutic Goods Administration and the direction applied regardless. The Commission also weighed the extra four weeks the school had given her.

What happened next

She sought permission to appeal, but instead of submissions sent four documents titled "Notice of Demand" asking the Commission to prove its jurisdiction. On 14 June 2022 a Full Bench refused permission, finding none of her grounds reasonably arguable: "The Appellant was dismissed because she was unable to lawfully perform her duties."

What this means for you

If a law stops you from attending work and your job genuinely needs you there, being unable to work can be a valid reason for dismissal, without any misconduct. Having worked from home during an emergency does not show that the job can normally be done remotely.

If you are told your job is at risk, it is worth responding in writing, taking up the meetings offered, bringing a support person, and getting advice early. A claim for unfair dismissal must be lodged with the Fair Work Commission within 21 days of the dismissal.

The takeaway

When a law stops you attending work and your job genuinely needs you there, an employer can fairly end the employment for that reason alone. A fair process still matters, and here the school gave clear warnings, meetings and extra time.

Note: The Victorian COVID-19 vaccination directions in this case are no longer in force. Without a public health order, a vaccination requirement imposed by an employer itself is judged by asking whether it is a lawful and reasonable direction, which this decision did not need to decide. In CFMMEU v Mt Arthur Coal Pty Ltd [2021] FWCFB 6059, a Full Bench found a NSW mine's own site-access vaccination requirement was not a reasonable direction, mainly because the employer had not consulted its workers as work health and safety law required. Ms Roy-Chowdhury's appeal was refused permission by a Full Bench on 14 June 2022: Roy-Chowdhury v Ivanhoe Girls' Grammar School [2022] FWCFB 101.

Fair Work Commission · 12 April 2022

Kathryn Roy-Chowdhury v The Ivanhoe Girls' Grammar School [2022] FWC 849, Deputy President Young. Read the full decision

This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.

Does this sound like your situation?

More case studies