If your business has fewer than 15 employees and is in the national Fair Work system, a dismissal that follows the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code is not an unfair dismissal. The Code lets you dismiss on the spot when you believe, on reasonable grounds, that the employee's conduct is serious enough. For any other dismissal, it requires a valid reason, a warning, a chance to respond and a reasonable chance to improve.
The Code is only a defence to an unfair dismissal claim. It does not stop a general protections or discrimination claim. And if your business is in the WA state system (for example a sole trader, a partnership or another unincorporated business), there is no Code at all: a dismissed employee can go to the Western Australian Industrial Relations Commission (WAIRC), which decides whether the dismissal was harsh, oppressive or unfair.
Not sure which system your business is in? Most companies are in the national system. Sole traders, partnerships and other unincorporated businesses are usually in the WA state system, as are most state government bodies and local councils. Check Am I covered by the WA state system? before you rely on the Code.
A dismissed employee has 21 days to lodge a Fair Work unfair dismissal claim, and 28 days for a WAIRC claim.
What is the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code?
It is a short instrument made by the Minister under s 388(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act). It has applied unchanged since 1 July 2009 (it still names "Fair Work Australia"). Read the full text of the Code.
The FW Act gives it force in two steps:
(a) a person has been unfairly dismissed only if, among other things, the dismissal "was not consistent with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code" (s 385(c)); and
(b) a dismissal is consistent with the Code if your business was a small business employer at the right time and you complied with the Code in relation to the dismissal (s 388(2)).
If both are met, the claim fails. The Commission does not go on to ask whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable (Guthrie v AJ & T Pulbrook Pty Ltd [2016] FWCFB 2859 at [21]).
Who counts as a small business employer?
A national system employer is a small business employer if, at the time that matters, it has fewer than 15 employees (s 23(1)). The count works like this:
(a) Count people, not full-time equivalents.
(b) The employee being dismissed is counted, and so is anyone else being dismissed at the same time (s 23(4)).
(c) Casual employees are counted only if they are regular casual employees, meaning they have been employed on a regular and systematic basis (s 23(2)(b), s 12). Unlike s 384(2), this test does not ask whether the casual expected the work to continue (Bronze Hospitality Pty Ltd v Hansson [2019] FWCFB 1099 at [13]). What matters is whether the casual was engaged on a regular and systematic pattern, although the days and hours worked are still relevant (at [24]).
(d) Employees of associated entities count as if they were your own: "associated entities are taken to be one entity" (s 23(3)). The meaning comes from s 50AAA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and includes entities under common control. If the same person or company controls several businesses, their staff are usually added together; get advice if ownership is shared.
(e) Genuine contractors are not counted, but a worker you call a contractor may in law be an employee, judged by the "real substance, practical reality and true nature" of the relationship (s 15AA, since 26 August 2024).
When is the count taken?
Immediately before the dismissal or when you gave notice of it, whichever came first (s 388(2)(a)).
What else changes for a small business?
Besides opening the Code, being under 15 means an employee must have worked for you for one year, not six months, before they can claim unfair dismissal (s 383), and you do not owe redundancy pay under the National Employment Standards (s 121(1)(b), except in some insolvencies, s 121(4)), although an award, agreement or contract may still require it.
What does the Code require?
In plain terms:
(a) Summary dismissal. You may dismiss without notice or warning when you believe on reasonable grounds that the employee's conduct is serious enough to justify immediate dismissal. Its examples are theft, fraud, violence and serious breaches of safety procedures. Reporting theft, fraud or violence to the police is "sufficient, though not essential", if you had reasonable grounds for the report.
(b) Every other dismissal. You must:
(i) tell the employee why they are at risk of being dismissed, and the reason must be a valid one based on their conduct or capacity to do the job;
(ii) warn them, verbally or preferably in writing, that they risk being dismissed if there is no improvement;
(iii) give them an opportunity to respond to the warning; and
(iv) give them a reasonable chance to fix the problem, having regard to their response.
(c) Procedural points. In discussions where dismissal is possible, the employee can have another person present to assist, but not a lawyer acting in a professional capacity. If the employee claims unfair dismissal, you will have to produce evidence that you complied, including evidence of a warning (except for summary dismissal). The Code says that evidence may include a completed checklist, copies of written warnings, a statement of termination or signed witness statements.
How does the Commission apply the summary dismissal rule?
Which rule applies?
The summary dismissal rule covers dismissals with immediate effect for serious misconduct. Paying the employee in lieu of notice, or dismissing a few days after the conduct, does not take the dismissal outside that rule. Every other dismissal, including a misconduct dismissal on notice, falls under the "other dismissal" rule (Ryman v Thrash Pty Ltd [2015] FWCFB 5264 at [41]-[42]). "Serious misconduct" takes its meaning from r 1.07 of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) (Ryman at [37]).
The two questions
The leading Full Bench decision is John Pinawin t/as RoseVi.Hair.Face.Body v Domingo [2012] FWAFB 1359. It asks two questions (at [29]):
(a) At the time of the dismissal, did you actually believe that the employee's conduct was serious enough to justify immediate dismissal?
(b) Was that belief based on reasonable grounds? This includes whether you carried out a reasonable investigation.
The Commission does not have to decide whether you were right (Pinawin at [29]). Outside the Code, an employer cannot simply rely on a reasonable belief that the misconduct happened (Coogee Legion Ex-Service Club Ltd v Giblin [2024] FWCFB 270 at [55]).
What the decisions show
(a) Your actions must match the belief. In Ryman, the owners wanted the employee back at work the next working days, which the Full Bench said "cannot be reconciled with" a belief that he had committed serious misconduct justifying immediate dismissal (at [45]).
(b) Only what you knew at the time counts. Something you discover after the dismissal cannot form part of your belief or supply reasonable grounds for it (Grandbridge Ltd v Wiburd [2017] FWCFB 6732 at [33], a Perth case).
(c) The termination letter matters. A letter written at the time of the dismissal was held to be the best evidence of the employer's belief and its grounds (Steri-Flow Filtration Systems (Aust) Pty Ltd v Erskine [2013] FWCFB 1943 at [33]).
(d) Talk to the employee first. Normally you will need to discuss the conduct with the employee and consider their explanation before you can hold a belief on reasonable grounds (Pinawin at [38]). The Code has no rigid rule requiring a meeting (Guthrie at [20]), and what is reasonable takes account of the experience and resources of a small business (Pinawin at [30]). In one case a Commissioner found that a sensible conversation would have shown the owner's belief was wrong, and the Full Bench refused the employer permission to appeal (Plumbtrax Pty Ltd v Walker [2025] FWCFB 219 at [9], [23]-[24]).
Case study: a bartender's parting insult in the staff chat.
How does the Commission apply the rule for other dismissals?
For a dismissal for poor performance, or for misconduct that does not justify immediate dismissal, the Full Bench has described the "crucial considerations" as whether you gave the employee a valid reason why they were at risk of dismissal, warned them of that risk if there was no improvement, gave them an opportunity to respond to the warning, and gave them a reasonable chance to fix the problem (Lloyd & Co Pty Ltd v Suttie [2016] FWCFB 144 at [19]).
Each step must come before the decision to dismiss. A first warning given in the dismissal meeting leaves no chance to improve, so it does not meet the Code, and a warning you cannot prove will not help you, so put it in writing.
Does the Commission consider the Code even if you do not raise it?
Yes. It must deal with the Code before the merits (s 396(c)) whenever the employer is a small business, whether raised or not (TIOBE Pty Ltd v Chen [2018] FWCFB 5726 at [21]-[25]). Still, rely on it expressly in your response to the claim.
A checklist for small business employers
The Fair Work Ombudsman publishes an official Small Business Fair Dismissal Code Checklist with the Code. Complete and date it as you go. Completing it is not required and does not by itself make a dismissal Code compliant: in one first-instance decision the Commission said the checklist "does not render the dismissal 'Code compliant'" (Pewsukngem v Choc Dee Thai Restaurant [2023] FWC 2493 at [6]). The steps below are our own, to use alongside it.
Before any dismissal:
(a) Count your employees by name as at the day you will give notice or dismiss, including the employee, regular casuals and the staff of any associated entity. Keep the list.
(b) Check the employee has worked for you for at least 12 months by the day you give notice (casual service counts only if it was regular and systematic with an expectation of continuing work, s 384(2)(a)). If not, unfair dismissal is not open to them, but other claims may be.
(c) Make sure the real reason is lawful (see below).
For a summary dismissal:
(d) Gather the facts and records, and put the allegation to the employee. Listen to their explanation, with a support person if they ask.
(e) Decide on what you know at the time, and only if you genuinely believe the conduct justifies immediate dismissal. Then act consistently: do not roster them on again.
(f) State the conduct and why it justifies immediate dismissal in the termination letter.
For any other dismissal:
(g) Tell the employee the specific problem, and warn them in writing that they may be dismissed if it does not improve.
(h) Consider their response, and give them a real chance to improve, with clear expectations and any training they need.
(i) If the problem continues, meet again before deciding, and confirm the decision and reason in writing.
For both:
(j) Give the notice or pay in lieu required. Notice under the National Employment Standards is not required where the termination is because of serious misconduct (s 123(1)(b)), and some employees, such as casuals, are outside the notice rules altogether (s 123(1)); check the award and contract too.
(k) Keep the headcount list, warnings, meeting notes, checklist and letter together.
What the Code does not protect you from
The Code answers only an unfair dismissal claim:
(a) Redundancy is outside the Code. The Full Bench held on 7 July 2026 that the Code applies only to dismissals for conduct or capacity, or summary dismissals for serious misconduct. It "does not provide a fallback position" when a small business fails to show a genuine redundancy; the claim then goes to the ordinary unfair dismissal test (Orientile Pty Ltd v Zhang [2026] FWCFB 162 at [25]). See our page on business restructure and redundancy.
(b) General protections claims are still open. An employee of a national system employer dismissed because of a complaint, a workplace right, a temporary absence through illness, pregnancy or another protected attribute can bring a general protections claim within 21 days (s 366), whatever your size and their length of service. Discrimination laws also still apply. You will have to prove the reason was not the unlawful one (s 361). See our page on general protections.
(c) Failing the Code does not make the dismissal unfair. The ordinary test then applies, which takes account of the size of your business and the absence of dedicated human resources staff (s 387(f), (g)). In Ryman, the Code was not met, but the Full Bench found the dismissal was not unfair in the context of a very small family business (at [60]).
Why does the WA state system have no Code?
The Fair Work Act's unfair dismissal laws apply only to national system employers and employees (s 380). Section 23 defines a small business employer only among national system employers. A WA state system employer cannot be one, whatever its size.
State system employees claim under s 29(1)(c) of the Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) (IR Act), that they were "harshly, oppressively or unfairly dismissed". The differences that matter to a small employer are:
(a) No dismissal is deemed fair because you followed a set procedure.
(b) There is no headcount test and no minimum employment period. The WAIRC must have regard to whether the employee was on an agreed probation of less than 3 months (s 23A(2)(a)), but that is a factor, not a bar.
(c) The employee has 28 days after the termination to refer the claim, and the WAIRC may accept a late claim if it would be unfair not to (s 29(2)(a), (3)).
(d) The WAIRC cannot decide a claim by an employee not covered by an award or other industrial instrument whose contract provides a salary above the prescribed amount (s 29AA(3)). Nor can it decide a claim if the employee has applied to the Fair Work Commission about the same termination, unless that application was withdrawn or rejected as outside the Commission's jurisdiction (s 29AA(1), (2)).
For a WA state system employer, the practical answer is to follow the same steps anyway. See unfair dismissal in the WA state system, what makes a dismissal unfair, damaging action and the federal laws that still apply to state system employers.
What to do next
Get advice before you dismiss. See managing and ending employment. If a claim has already been lodged, see defending a claim.
Perth Employment Lawyers acts for small businesses across WA in both systems. Contact us to talk it through.