Performance improvement plans in WA: what the law requires, for employees and employers

Updated 17 November 2026

No law requires an employer to use a performance improvement plan, and no law sets its length or its form. But if a plan ends in dismissal, the Fair Work Commission (or, for a WA state system employer, the WAIRC) will ask whether the employee was warned that the job was at risk, given a real chance to improve, and told the reason and allowed to respond before the decision. A plan built to fail, or started because the employee complained, can lead to an unfair dismissal or general protections claim.

What is a performance improvement plan (PIP)?

A performance improvement plan (PIP) is a written document that tells an employee where their work is said to fall short, the standard expected, the support the employer will give, and the dates on which progress will be reviewed. It is also called a performance management plan: see our performance management page.

The Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) does not mention plans. The law judges the fairness of any dismissal that follows, and protects employees from plans used for an unlawful reason.

Does the law require a PIP before a dismissal for poor performance?

No. For a national system employee who is protected from unfair dismissal, the Commission decides whether a dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable by taking into account the matters in s 387 of the FW Act. For a performance dismissal the ones that matter most are:

(a) whether there was a valid reason related to the employee's capacity or conduct (s 387(a));

(b) whether the employee was notified of that reason (s 387(b));

(c) whether the employee was given an opportunity to respond to it (s 387(c));

(d) any unreasonable refusal to let the employee have a support person at discussions relating to dismissal (s 387(d));

(e) whether the employee had been warned about the unsatisfactory performance before the dismissal (s 387(e));

(f) the size of the employer's enterprise (s 387(f));

(g) the absence of dedicated human resources expertise (s 387(g)); and

(h) any other relevant matter (s 387(h)).

A written plan is one good way to give the warning and the chance to improve, but it is not the only way. A Full Bench has said that coaching, counselling or retraining "remain relevant to fairness even though they may not be a 'warning' within the meaning of s 387(e)" (Komeyui Management Pty Ltd v Goonewardena [2024] FWCFB 425 at [55]).

What counts as a warning?

For many years the Commission followed Fastidia: a warning should identify the part of the employee's performance that concerns the employer and make clear that the job is at risk unless it is fixed. A "mere exhortation for the employee to improve his or her performance" is not enough (Fastidia Pty Ltd v Goodwin [2000] AIRC 223 at [43]-[44]).

In 2024 a Full Bench said that a warning which does not mention dismissal still counts under s 387(e), but "may well be given less weight" than one that does (Komeyui at [53]-[54]). The safe course for an employer has not changed: say in writing that the job is at risk.

Does a PIP replace the chance to respond?

Not usually. A Full Bench has held that s 387(b) and (c) are not satisfied just because the employee knew their performance was poor and had a chance to improve, and that the reason must be put and answered "before the decision to dismiss is made" (Appeal by Trimatic Management Services Pty Ltd [2013] FWCFB 5160 at [23]). At the end of a plan, put the proposed reason to the employee and consider the reply, often by a show cause letter.

Small businesses

For a small business employer (fewer than 15 employees) relying on the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code, a Full Bench has said the crucial questions for a dismissal that is not summary are whether the employer gave a valid reason why the employee was at risk, warned of dismissal without improvement, allowed a response to the warning and gave a reasonable chance to fix the problem (Lloyd & Co Pty Ltd v Suttie [2016] FWCFB 144 at [19]). See our guide to the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code.

What makes a PIP fair?

There is no legal template. A plan is more likely to stand up if it gives specific concerns with examples, achievable measurable standards, real support, enough time with written feedback, a plain statement that the job is at risk, and an open mind.

When is a PIP unfair, or a sham?

Signs that a plan is "set up to fail" include targets nobody in the team meets, a timeframe too short to show change, concerns that were never raised before a complaint or a request for leave, feedback that never arrives,, and a replacement recruited mid-plan.

An unfair plan is not automatically unlawful. Depending on what follows, it may mean there was no valid reason for a dismissal (s 387(a)), adverse action, or bullying. Each is covered below.

Can my employer put me on a PIP after I made a complaint?

Yes, if the plan is genuinely about performance; not if the complaint is part of the reason. Under the general protections in Part 3-1 of the FW Act, an employer must not take adverse action against an employee because the employee has exercised a workplace right (s 340). Being able to make a complaint or inquiry about your employment, including to your employer, is a workplace right (s 341(1)(c)(ii)), although the Federal Court has differed on exactly which complaints count (Alam v National Australia Bank Limited [2021] FCAFC 178 at [65]). Adverse action includes dismissal, injuring an employee in their employment, and altering their position to their prejudice (s 342(1), item 1). Whether a plan on its own is adverse action is not settled and depends on the facts. A plan that can lead to dismissal is more likely to be. These protections are for national system employees. In the WA state system the closest are unfair dismissal in the WAIRC, unlawful termination under the FW Act (s 772) and the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (WA): see which claim fits you in WA.

Three rules make these claims different from unfair dismissal:

(a) the prohibited reason need only be one of the reasons (s 360); the Full Federal Court has described it as a "substantial and operative" reason (Alam at [14], citing Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education v Barclay [2012] HCA 32);

(b) once the employee alleges the action was taken for a prohibited reason, it is presumed to have been, unless the employer proves otherwise (s 361); and

(c) a claim can be brought while the employee is still employed, not only after a dismissal.

A complaint is not a shield, though. The Federal Court has said that steps taken to deal with management issues raised through a complaint are "not thereby automatically" adverse action taken because of the complaint (Ramos v Good Samaritan Industries [2013] FCA 30 at [132]).

Is a PIP bullying?

Usually not. Under the FW Act anti-bullying law, reasonable management action carried out in a reasonable manner is not bullying (s 789FD(2)), and a Full Bench has said that placing an employee on a PIP "clearly falls within" management action (Blagojevic v AGL Macquarie Pty Ltd [2018] FWCFB 4174 at [19]).

To show the decision to impose the plan was unreasonable, you must show it "lacked any evident and intelligible justification" (Mac v Bank of Queensland Ltd [2015] FWC 774 at [102], approved in Blagojevic at [21]-[23]). How the plan is run is judged separately. Our case study Is a performance improvement plan bullying? covers Mac. If you work for a WA state system employer, the WAIRC has a similar power: see bullying in the WA state system.

What if I am sick, injured or stressed during a PIP?

The FW Act does not say a plan must stop while you are on leave or unwell. But a Full Bench has accepted that continuing a plan where the worker is not well enough to take part "may, depending upon the circumstances, constitute unreasonable behaviour" (Blagojevic at [78]).

If illness, injury or disability is affecting your work, tell your employer in writing and give it medical evidence. Taking adverse action because of a physical or mental disability is prohibited (s 351(1)), subject to the exceptions in that section. For the rules on dismissal during sick leave or workers' compensation, see can I be sacked while on workers' compensation or sick leave in WA?.

Employers should pause or adjust a plan if medical evidence shows the employee cannot take part.

Can I bring a support person to PIP meetings?

You can ask. The FW Act does not require the employer to offer one, but the Commission takes into account any unreasonable refusal to let you have a support person at discussions relating to dismissal (s 387(d)). That matter arises only if the employee asks (Li v PPD Australia Pty Ltd [2022] FWC 496 at [152]-[153]).

Do I have to sign a PIP?

Nothing in the FW Act requires an employee to sign a plan, and a plan can operate without a signature. If you disagree with it, you can sign to acknowledge receipt only and put your disagreement in writing, with examples.

What you must not do is refuse to take part. An employee must obey a direction that relates to the employment, involves no illegality and is reasonable (R v Darling Island Stevedoring & Lighterage Co Ltd; Ex parte Halliday [1938] HCA 44; (1938) 60 CLR 601, Dixon J). A direction to attend plan meetings and work to a plan will usually be reasonable:

(a) in Li v PPD Australia Pty Ltd [2022] FWC 496 at [136]-[137], the employee's refusal to take part in a behavioural improvement plan was a valid reason for dismissal, even though the plan had flaws. The dismissal was still unfair, because he had not been told plainly that refusing put his job at risk, and was not given a proper chance to respond before the decision was made (at [141]-[142], [148]-[151]);

(b) in Kokke v Momentum Energy Pty Ltd [2024] FWC 1710 at [9]-[10], an employee who refused to accept a performance plan and to follow other lawful and reasonable directions was found to have engaged in serious misconduct, and her dismissal was not unfair. A Full Bench refused permission to appeal (Kokke v Momentum Energy [2024] FWCFB 336 at [17]). Our case study tells the story: she refused a performance plan, and lost her job and her claim.

For employers, Li is the lesson: if an employee refuses to take part, warn them in writing that refusal itself may lead to dismissal, and give them time to reconsider and respond.

Should I resign while I am on a PIP?

A resignation is generally the end of an unfair dismissal claim, unless you were forced to resign because of your employer's conduct or course of conduct (s 386(1)(b)). A plan you dislike, run reasonably, is unlikely to meet that test. See resigning or forced resignation and get advice before you resign.

Can I be dismissed at the end of a PIP?

Yes, if the standard was fair, the warning was clear, the support was real and the performance did not improve.

Time limits are short:

(a) an unfair dismissal application to the Fair Work Commission must be made within 21 days after the dismissal took effect (s 394(2)), and you must have served the minimum employment period of 6 months, or one year with a small business employer (s 383), and be covered by an award or agreement or earn less than the high income threshold (s 382);

(b) a general protections dismissal application must also be made within 21 days (s 366(1)). The Commission can allow either late only in exceptional circumstances (s 394(3), s 366(2)), so do not rely on it; and

(c) a WA state system employee has 28 days from the day employment ended to refer an unfair dismissal claim to the WAIRC (Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) s 29(2)(a)), which may accept a late claim if it would be unfair not to (s 29(3)).

See which claim fits you in WA, unfair dismissal and general protections.

PIPs in the WA state system

Sole traders, partnerships, unincorporated employers and most WA government bodies and local governments are in the WA state system: check am I covered?.

In the state system the question is whether you were harshly, oppressively or unfairly dismissed (Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) s 29(1)(c)). There is no s 387 checklist and no Small Business Fair Dismissal Code. In a 2026 appeal about a dismissal after a PIP, the Chief Commissioner, for the Full Bench, repeated his earlier statement that "contemporary standards of industrial fairness require in my view, that before an employee is dismissed, the employee be given some fair warning that his or her employment is at risk if his or her performance or conduct does not improve as required by the employer", and that this "requires more than a mere exhortation to improve" (Abuy v Town of Port Hedland [2026] WAIRC 00261 at [11], Full Bench, appeal dismissed, quoting Scott v Consolidated Paper Industries (WA) Pty Ltd (1998) 78 WAIG 4940 at 4943). Our page what makes a dismissal unfair in the WA state system covers performance dismissals in the WAIRC, and unfair dismissal in the WA state system covers the claim.

WA public sector employees are also subject to the Public Sector Management Act 1994 (WA). See WA public sector employees and WA public sector discipline, redeployment and redundancy.

A checklist for employers

Before you start a plan:

(a) write down the concerns, with dated examples, and check none of them is new since a complaint, a leave request or a disclosure of illness;

(b) choose a decision-maker who is not the subject of any complaint by the employee;

(c) set measurable standards, real support and a realistic period, and say plainly that the job is at risk; and

(d) follow your own performance management policy, or record why you departed from it.

Then give the promised feedback and support. See terminating employees.

What to do if you have been put on a PIP

(a) Take part, meet the deadlines and keep notes of your work, the feedback and any support promised but not given.

(b) Put requests for detail, any disagreement, and any illness or caring responsibility affecting your work in writing.

(c) Get advice early if the plan followed a complaint, leave or another protected reason, and before you resign.

Talk to us

Whether you have just been handed a plan or you are an employer about to start one, early advice is the best protection. Contact us for a free, confidential discussion with a Perth employment lawyer.