An employee has lodged an unfair dismissal claim: what a WA employer does next

Updated 17 November 2026

If the Fair Work Commission has sent you a former employee's unfair dismissal application (Form F2), it expects your response on Form F3 within 7 days after the day it was served on you. Use that week to check whether the employee could claim at all and gather your records. Most claims are settled at a free conciliation about five weeks after the application. A claim that does not settle is decided by a Commission Member, who can order reinstatement or compensation of up to 26 weeks' pay, capped at $95,050 for 2026-27.

If your business is in the WA state system (for example a sole trader, a partnership, or a trust whose trustee is a person rather than a company), the claim runs in the Western Australian Industrial Relations Commission (WAIRC) instead, under different rules and a 21-day response time. Both are covered below.

Deadlines that start when the claim arrives:

  1. Fair Work Commission: lodge Form F3, and send a copy to the employee, within 7 days after the day the application was served on you (Fair Work Commission Rules 2024 r 66(1)).
  2. WAIRC: lodge Form 2A within 21 days of being served.

Do not ignore the claim. In either commission, a business that does not respond can have the matter decided without its side being heard.

Which commission is the claim in?

Look at the form you received.

A claim in the wrong commission is itself a ground of objection. Conversely, the WAIRC must not decide a claim while the employee has an application about the same dismissal on foot in the Fair Work Commission, unless that application is withdrawn or dismissed for lack of jurisdiction (IR Act s 29AA(1), (2)).

Check also what kind of claim it is. A general protections claim (Form F8) alleges you dismissed the employee for a prohibited reason, such as a complaint, a workplace right or illness. It runs differently: there is no minimum employment period, and the business must prove its real reason (FW Act s 361). See general protections. The rest of this guide is about unfair dismissal.

What to do in the first week

  1. Read the application and what the employee wants.
  2. Put the deadlines in the diary, and the conciliation date, which is in the Commission's letter.
  3. Preserve every document about the employment and the dismissal: contract, warnings, reviews, investigation notes, emails and messages, the show cause letter and response, and the termination letter. Tell the managers involved not to delete anything. Pay, time and other prescribed employee records must be kept for 7 years in any event (FW Act s 535).
  4. Tell your insurer if the business has employment practices cover, and check the policy's notice requirements.
  5. Decide who will act for the business. In the Fair Work Commission, a lawyer or paid agent needs the Commission's permission to appear, given if it would make the matter more efficient or refusing it would be unfair (FW Act s 596). A small business without specialist HR staff, facing an employee represented by a union official or another experienced advocate, is an example the Act gives. A lawyer can advise you behind the scenes without permission.

How do you fill in Form F3?

Form F3 asks for the dates the employee started and was dismissed, the award or agreement that covered them, the reasons for the dismissal, your answer to what the employee says, and any objection. Answer every question; if one does not apply, write "not relevant" rather than leaving it blank.

Attach only the documents that matter now, such as written warnings and the termination letter. The Commission will ask for witness statements and other evidence later if the claim goes further. Lodging the response costs nothing.

Write it carefully: the employee and, later, a Commission Member will read it. Keep to the facts, say what the reason was and how you told the employee, and do not add reasons that played no part in the decision.

Can you object to the claim?

Yes, if the employee was not able to claim. This is a jurisdictional objection, raised in Form F3. Saying you had a good reason for the dismissal is not one: that is the merits, which come later.

The Commission must decide four matters before it looks at the merits (FW Act s 396):

  1. Whether the application was made within 21 days after the dismissal took effect (s 394(2)). The Commission can allow more time only in exceptional circumstances, weighing the reason for the delay, any action the employee took to dispute the dismissal, prejudice to you, the merits and fairness (s 394(3)). "Exceptional" means out of the ordinary, unusual or uncommon, though not necessarily unique: Nulty v Blue Star Group Pty Ltd [2011] FWAFB 975 at [13], on the identical words in the general protections time limit.
  2. Whether the employee was protected from unfair dismissal (s 382). That needs both:
    • (a) the minimum employment period: 6 months, or 12 months if the business is a small business employer (s 383). Casual service counts only if it was regular and systematic with a reasonable expectation of continuing (s 384(2)(a)); and
    • (b) coverage by a modern award or enterprise agreement, or annual earnings below the high income threshold, which is $190,100 for dismissals from 1 July 2026.
  3. Whether the business was a small business employer that followed the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code (ss 385(c), 388). A small business has fewer than 15 employees at the time of the dismissal, counting regular casuals and associated entities (s 23). For a summary dismissal under the Code, the question is whether you believed on reasonable grounds, after a reasonable inquiry, that the conduct was serious enough to justify immediate dismissal; the Commission does not decide whether you were right: John Pinawin T/A RoseVi.Hair.Face.Body v Domingo [2012] FWAFB 1359 at [29]. See our Small Business Fair Dismissal Code checklist.
  4. Whether the dismissal was a case of genuine redundancy (s 389). The job must no longer be required to be done by anyone because of operational changes, you must have consulted as any award or agreement required, and redeployment within the business or an associated entity must not have been reasonable. The High Court has held that, depending on how the business uses its workforce, the redeployment question can reach work being done by contractors or labour hire: Helensburgh Coal Pty Ltd v Bartley [2025] HCA 29 at [7].

Three other objections are common:

  • Not an employee, or not your employee. A genuine independent contractor cannot claim, and a labour hire worker's employer is usually the agency, not your business.
  • Not dismissed. Unfair dismissal requires a dismissal (s 385(a)). A fixed-term contract that simply ran out is usually not one (s 386(2)(a)). A resignation can be a dismissal if it was forced by your conduct, or if it was said in the heat of the moment and you acted on it without checking after a reasonable time that the employee meant it: Bupa Aged Care Australia Pty Ltd t/a Bupa Aged Care Mosman v Tavassoli [2017] FWCFB 3941 at [47].
  • Another claim already made. An employee cannot run two claims about the same dismissal, for example unfair dismissal and a general protections or discrimination claim (s 725).

A late application is usually heard before conciliation. Other objections are usually dealt with after conciliation, or with the merits at the final hearing, although you can ask for a separate hearing first. Raising an objection does not stop the claim running in the meantime.

What happens at conciliation?

The Commission usually lists a conciliation about five weeks after the application. It is voluntary, private, usually online and up to about 90 minutes long. A conciliator, who decides nothing, talks with both sides together and then separately, carrying offers between them. The Commission reports that about 3 in 4 cases are resolved at conciliation.

Settlement can be on any terms both sides accept, such as a payment or an agreed reference. Record it in a written deed of release, and make sure the application is then discontinued. If an employee who has settled unreasonably fails to discontinue, you can apply to have the application dismissed (s 399A(1)(c), (2)).

If it does not settle, how does the Commission decide?

The claim goes to a Commission Member, who decides it at a private conference or a public hearing (ss 397 to 399). You will be directed to file an outline of your case, witness statements and your documents. Witnesses give evidence under oath and can be cross-examined.

A dismissal is unfair if it was harsh, unjust or unreasonable (s 385(b)). The Commission must take into account each matter in s 387:

(a) whether there was a valid reason related to the employee's capacity or conduct;

(b) whether the employee was told that reason;

(c) whether they had a chance to respond;

(d) any unreasonable refusal of a support person;

(e) for poor performance, whether they were warned first;

(f) and (g) the size of the business and whether it had HR expertise; and

(h) anything else relevant.

For a misconduct dismissal, the Commission decides for itself, on the evidence before it, whether the conduct happened. It is not enough that you believed it on reasonable grounds: King v Freshmore (Vic) Pty Ltd [2000] AIRC 1019 at [24], a Full Bench decision under the predecessor Act that the Commission still applies to s 387(a). Bring the witnesses who saw what happened.

A dismissal may be unjust because the employee did not do what was alleged, unreasonable because it rested on inferences that could not reasonably be drawn, or harsh because it was disproportionate: Byrne v Australian Airlines Ltd (1995) 185 CLR 410 at 465 (McHugh and Gummow JJ). See also managing and ending employment.

What can the Commission order?

Reinstatement is the primary remedy. The Commission can order compensation only if it is satisfied reinstatement is inappropriate and compensation is appropriate (s 390(3)). Reinstatement may be ordered with back pay for the time out of work (s 391(3)).

Compensation is worked out under s 392. The Commission estimates how long the employee would have stayed but for the dismissal, deducts what they have earned since, and discounts for contingencies: the long-standing Sprigg approach, set out by the Full Bench in Bowden v Ottrey Homes Cobram and District Retirement Villages Inc [2013] FWCFB 431 at [24] to [28]. Three rules limit it:

(a) it cannot include anything for shock, distress or humiliation (s 392(4));

(b) it must be reduced if the employee's misconduct contributed to the decision (s 392(3)); and

(c) it cannot exceed the lesser of 26 weeks' pay and half the high income threshold, which is $95,050 for 2026-27 (s 392(5), (6)).

The Commission must also consider the effect of an order on the viability of your business (s 392(2)(a)). It says the median award is between 5 and 7 weeks' pay.

Will you have to pay the employee's legal costs?

Usually not. Each side bears its own costs in the Fair Work Commission (s 611(1)). The Commission can order costs against a party only in narrower cases:

(a) an application or response made vexatiously or without reasonable cause, or one that should reasonably have been seen to have no reasonable prospect of success (s 611(2));

(b) an unreasonable act or omission in running the matter that caused the other side costs (s 400A); and

(c) against a lawyer or paid agent who encouraged a hopeless case or acted unreasonably (s 401).

An application for costs must be made within 14 days after the matter is decided or discontinued (s 402). The rules cut both ways: a hopeless defence can attract costs too.

What is different for a WA state system employer?

If the claim is in the WAIRC, the steps are similar but the law is not.

  • The response is Form 2A, due within 21 days of service. The WAIRC must try conciliation first unless it would not help (IR Act s 32(1)), usually at a private, without prejudice conference before a Commissioner.
  • The employee has 28 days to lodge, and the WAIRC can accept a late claim if it would be unfair not to (s 29(2)(a), (3)).
  • There is no minimum employment period and no Small Business Fair Dismissal Code. A short agreed probation (under 3 months) is only a factor (s 23A(2)).
  • The income cap applies only if no award or industrial agreement covers the job and the contract salary is above the prescribed amount (s 29AA(3)), which the WAIRC publishes as $212,800 from 1 July 2026.
  • The test is whether the dismissal was harsh, oppressive or unfair, with no statutory checklist. See What makes a WA dismissal unfair?
  • Compensation, only if reinstatement and re-employment are impracticable, is for "loss or injury" caused by the dismissal, capped at 6 months' remuneration (s 23A(6), (8)). The federal Act, by contrast, excludes distress.
  • The WAIRC cannot order either side to pay the other's lawyer's or agent's fees (s 27(1)(c)), and lawyers may appear as of right in an unfair dismissal claim (s 31(1)(c)(ii)).

The full process is on Unfair dismissal in the WA state system.

What should you not do?

  • Do not pressure the employee to withdraw. Lodging the claim and taking part in a Commission conference are workplace rights (FW Act s 341(1)(b), (2)(a)). Threatening action to make someone drop a claim, or to stop a current employee giving evidence, risks a coercion or adverse action claim with civil penalties (ss 340, 343). Settlement talks are fine; threats about references, debts or counter-claims are not.
  • Do not alter, tidy up or destroy records. A document created after the event, or records that have gone missing, damage a defence far more than an unhelpful document does.
  • Do not dismiss or sideline someone else because they support the claim or are a witness.

Get advice early

The week after the claim arrives is when the business has the most choices. Perth Employment Lawyers acts for employers in the Fair Work Commission and the WAIRC, from the response through conciliation to a hearing. See defending a claim against your business, or contact us today.