Professor's reinstatement overturned after encounter with student

Australian National University v Scott Morrison [2022] FWCFB 83

Decided by
Fair Work Commission (Full Bench)
Date
30 May 2022
Outcome
Reinstatement overturned on appeal
Result
Employer succeeded
Illustrative image. It does not show the people in this case.

An associate professor at the Australian National University was dismissed after a consensual, intimate encounter with an Honours student on a beach during a university retreat. The Fair Work Commission first ordered his reinstatement, but a Full Bench overturned that decision on appeal, finding the university had a valid reason to dismiss him.

Key points

  • Conduct at a work event, such as a university retreat, is connected with the job even if it happens at night and away from the formal program.
  • That the contact was consensual, and even started by the other person, did not stop it being a valid reason for dismissal for a senior academic with a student at that event.
  • Remorse, apologies and whether dismissal was too harsh are weighed in the overall fairness assessment, not in deciding whether there was a valid reason.
  • Statements to an employer's investigation that turn out to be untrue can count against an employee later.

What happened

Dr Scott Morrison was an associate professor in the Mathematical Sciences Institute at the Australian National University (ANU), where he had worked since June 2012. In November 2017 he coordinated a mathematics retreat at the university's coastal campus at Kioloa, on the New South Wales south coast. One of the students invited was an Honours student who had been taking a course he lectured.

On the evening of 21 November 2017, after the evening lecture, he and the student walked down to the beach to look at bioluminescence in the water. He was about 37; she was 22. Over about 30 minutes they swam and were physically intimate, in the water and then on a grassy area behind the beach. At one point he asked whether she wanted to go further, and she declined. The student never alleged harassment or assault, and the university never claimed it.

Several personal conversations followed, and his wife became involved. Almost a year later he emailed the student asking her to "just keep away", mentioning his seminar. She finished her degree with first class honours in June 2018 and made a confidential disclosure to the university in August 2019. After an investigation and an internal review, ANU dismissed him with effect from 27 February 2020.

The first decision: reinstated

Dr Morrison applied to the Fair Work Commission under s 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). On 21 February 2022 Deputy President Dean found he had been unfairly dismissed.

She found there was no valid reason. ANU's policies did not ban consensual relationships with students, a half-hour interaction was not a "close personal relationship" he had to report, and he had already submitted the final grade sheets before the retreat. She found the student had started the kissing. His handling of things afterwards was "clumsy to say the least", but she held that it was not a valid reason for dismissal.

She ordered ANU to reinstate him, keep his continuity of service, and pay him six months' lost pay. ANU appealed, and the reinstatement order was put on hold until the appeal was decided.

Under s 385, a dismissal is unfair only if, among other things, it was harsh, unjust or unreasonable. To decide that, the Commission weighs the matters listed in s 387. The first, in s 387(a), is whether there was a valid reason for the dismissal related to the employee's conduct or capacity.

The Full Bench restated the settled rules. A valid reason is one that is "sound, defensible and well-founded". The conduct must have happened and must justify dismissal, though it need not justify instant dismissal. Matters raised in mitigation, such as remorse, and whether dismissal was a proportionate response, are weighed later, under s 387(h), as part of the overall judgment about fairness.

What the Full Bench decided

On 30 May 2022 a Full Bench of three members granted ANU permission to appeal, upheld the appeal and quashed the first decision. The key point: the conduct was not private. The retreat was a university educational activity on university premises, and Dr Morrison was there as a senior academic and an organiser.

Consent did not answer the problem. The Full Bench said it "should be obvious" that a senior academic should not, during an educational activity, become sexually intimate with a student taking part, "even if the intimacy was consensual and initiated or invited by the student". It added that it was not taking a "wowserish" approach: a private relationship with someone who happens to be a student, with no connection to the job, would be hard to treat as a valid reason on its own.

It found that the Deputy President had wrongly counted his apologies and remorse at the valid reason stage, and that her reasoning showed she thought dismissal too harsh, which belongs elsewhere. It also found errors of fact. Final grades were not released until 30 November 2017 and he could still change them, so there was at least a perceived power imbalance. His email asked her to keep away from him, including from his seminars. And parts of what he told the university's investigation and review were untruthful.

The Full Bench concluded that his conduct at the beach, his failure to disclose it, his later dealings with the student and his lack of honesty in the investigation amounted to a valid reason for dismissal.

What happened next

The Full Bench did not finish the case. It called it "finely balanced": there was a valid reason, but the dismissal might arguably have been harsh because it appeared to cost him his whole academic career. It said it would decide that question itself, after further evidence and submissions, but first sent the parties to a conciliation conference before another member. No later published decision has been found, so the final outcome is not on the public record.

What this means for you

If you hold a position of trust, such as a lecturer, teacher, coach or supervisor, conduct at a work event is connected with your job, even after hours, and consent may not end the question.

A valid reason does not always mean a dismissal was fair: the Commission still weighs harshness, including what the dismissal costs you. If you are under investigation, answer honestly and completely, because a misleading account can become part of the case against you. An unfair dismissal application must be made within 21 days of the dismissal taking effect, so consider getting advice early.

The takeaway

Consent did not make this conduct private. For a senior academic at a university event, intimacy with a student taking part was a valid reason for dismissal, though whether dismissal was harsh is a separate question.

Note: The old version of this article reported only the first decision ([2022] FWC 301), which ordered reinstatement. That decision was quashed by the Full Bench on 30 May 2022 ([2022] FWCFB 83). The Full Bench sent the matter to conciliation and we found no later published decision. The valid reason principles the Full Bench applied are still the law, and s 387 has not changed since.

Fair Work Commission (Full Bench) · 30 May 2022

Australian National University v Scott Morrison [2022] FWCFB 83, Vice President Hatcher, Deputy President Asbury and Commissioner Bissett (on appeal from Deputy President Dean). Read the full decision

This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.

Does this sound like your situation?

More case studies