Sacked for asking a passenger to wear his mask properly, then reinstated

Ms Amie Logsdon v Surfside Buslines Pty Ltd [2022] FWC 392

Decided by
Fair Work Commission
Date
22 April 2022
Outcome
Reinstated, with lost pay
Result
Employee succeeded
Illustrative image. It does not show the people in this case.

A Gold Coast bus driver asked a passenger to pull his mask up over his face, was sworn at, and called for police when he would not get off. Her employer dismissed her for serious misconduct, saying she had tried to enforce the mask mandate against company direction. The Fair Work Commission found there was no valid reason and ordered her reinstatement with lost pay.

Key points

  • Politely asking a passenger to wear a mask he already had on was not 'enforcing' the mask mandate, so the driver broke no company rule.
  • A valid reason for dismissal must be sound, defensible or well founded on the facts as the Commission finds them, not just on the employer's belief.
  • Even if there had been a breach, dismissal was out of proportion to it, which made the dismissal harsh.
  • Reinstatement is the primary remedy, and an employer's claimed loss of trust and confidence must be soundly and rationally based.

What happened

Ms Logsdon drove buses on the Gold Coast for Surfside Buslines from 29 April 2019. On 16 September 2021, during Queensland's COVID-19 mask mandate, a young man boarded her bus without paying his fare, sat in the seats reserved for passengers with a disability, and wore his face mask pulled down under his chin.

She asked him to put it on properly. He asked whether masks were mandatory, then said he had an exemption. When she asked again, he told her to "F*ck off Karen". She told him he could get off at the next stop for verbally abusing her. He refused, so she contacted the company's control room, asked for the police, and asked the other passengers to leave the bus. The man eventually got off and caught the next bus before police arrived.

Six days later the company summarily dismissed her for serious misconduct. Summary dismissal means dismissal on the spot, without notice. Its letter said her "decision to disregard company direction and attempt to enforce the wearing of masks" breached its Code of Conduct and the standards it expected.

The employer's case

The company relied on an instruction from Translink, the division of Queensland's Department of Transport and Main Roads that oversees public transport, which it had passed on to drivers in a safety notice. The notice said enforcing the mask mandate was the job of the Queensland Police Service and that frontline staff were "not expected to undertake any enforcement activities". The company argued she had started the conflict, put herself and passengers at risk, and showed a pattern of not following directions.

For that pattern it pointed to an earlier final warning. More than a year before, she had used her smart watch, rather than the two-way radio, to call the parent of a child who had missed a stop. The company said this breached a rule against using a mobile phone or Bluetooth device while driving.

Under s 385 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), a dismissal is unfair if, among other things, it was harsh, unjust or unreasonable. Section 387 lists what the Commission must weigh, starting with whether there was a valid reason related to the worker's conduct. A valid reason is one that is "sound, defensible or well founded". Where the reason is misconduct, the Commission decides for itself whether the conduct happened. It is not enough that the employer believed it did.

A dismissal can also be harsh, even where there is a valid reason, if it is disproportionate to the gravity of the misconduct or its consequences for the worker are severe.

What the Commission decided

Commissioner Riordan watched the CCTV footage and found that Ms Logsdon "did not engage in any activity which could be identified as being 'enforcement'". She did not stop the bus, did not argue about the mandate and did not leave her seat. She simply asked him to put on his mask while she kept driving. Her final words to him were "please, please put it on". The passenger was told to leave because he abused her, not because of the mask. The Commissioner noted that the Translink notice said drivers were "not expected" to enforce the mandate, not that they were prohibited from doing so. A senior manager also accepted in evidence that he had nothing on hand showing drivers had been told they could not ask a passenger to wear a mask.

The earlier warning fell away too. The Code of Conduct named mobile phones and iPods, and a smart watch was neither. For conduct to be serious misconduct, the Commissioner said, the policy must be concise. Even if it had been a breach, it did not justify a final warning: she "was providing a service to a worried mother". Two incidents more than 12 months apart were not a trend.

There was no valid reason. Even if there had been, the Commissioner found, dismissal was disproportionate to the conduct and so harsh. The Commissioner also criticised the company for not responding to the abuse its driver received, and for a manager's witness statement saying the passenger's words were not abuse, a view he withdrew only under questioning.

Reinstatement, not compensation

The company said it had lost trust and confidence in her, so she should not get her job back. The Commissioner did not accept that she ignored policies, and found she was "clearly a proud and caring bus driver who loves her job". To order only compensation would impose a penalty she did not deserve. He ordered that she be reinstated to her former role, that her continuity of service be maintained, and that she be paid lost wages calculated on her average wage over her last eight weeks of employment.

What this means for you

If you are dismissed for breaking a rule, look closely at what the rule actually says. A tribunal may read a policy strictly, holding the employer to the words it chose, and it will look at what you did, not at the label the employer put on it. An employer that relies on an earlier warning may also find that warning examined.

Reinstatement is the main remedy for an unfair dismissal, and an employer's bare claim that it has lost trust in you will not always prevent it. If you have been dismissed, consider getting advice early: an unfair dismissal application must be lodged with the Fair Work Commission within 21 days of the dismissal taking effect.

The takeaway

Asking a passenger to wear the mask he already had on was not enforcing the mandate, so there was no valid reason to dismiss. The Commission gave the driver her job back, holding that an employer's claimed loss of trust must be soundly based.

Note: The Queensland mask mandate this case concerns has since ended, but the unfair dismissal tests applied (s 387 and the reinstatement provisions in ss 390 and 391) are unchanged. No appeal from this decision was found. For dismissals from 1 July 2026, the high income threshold is $190,100 and the compensation cap is $95,050.

Fair Work Commission · 22 April 2022

Ms Amie Logsdon v Surfside Buslines Pty Ltd [2022] FWC 392, Commissioner Riordan. Read the full decision

This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.

Does this sound like your situation?

More case studies