Warned on sales, then paid less in a new role before pay was agreed

John Simon v NGS Group Pty Ltd ATF NGS Discretionary Unit Trust [2019] FWC 3442

Decided by
Fair Work Commission
Date
5 June 2019
Outcome
$36,280 compensation
Result
Employee succeeded
Illustrative image. It does not show the people in this case.

After 18 years with a small signage business, a struggling account manager asked about a move back to the tools and was given a written performance warning. The business started paying him a lower hourly rate before the new pay had been agreed. The Fair Work Commission found the pay cut repudiated his contract, that he was dismissed when he accepted that, that the dismissal was unfair, and ordered $36,280 in compensation.

Key points

  • A performance warning is only a first step: here it was never followed through, and the employer never relied on it as a reason for dismissal.
  • Cutting an employee's pay without their agreement can repudiate the employment contract; an employee who accepts that repudiation has been dismissed.
  • Asking about another role is not agreeing to whatever pay the employer chooses: the Commission called it not "a blank cheque".
  • The employer gave no reason for the dismissal at all, so there was no valid reason, and the dismissal was not consistent with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code.

What happened

Mr Simon joined NGS Group, a signage business in Heidelberg, Victoria, as an apprentice in September 2000. Over 18 years he worked as a sign installer, became Production Manager in 2012, and in February 2015 was promoted to Sales/Key Account Manager. By 2018 he earned a salary of $90,363 plus superannuation, with a car and a phone. The business had only 12 employees, which made it a small business under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).

2018 went badly. Sales were down, and one client's account under his management had fallen from about $300,000 to under $20,000. On 28 June 2018 he was given a written warning that his employment may be terminated if his performance did not improve. In June he had also complained to the company's director that the general manager and a co-worker were bullying him. In July a doctor diagnosed work-related stress.

In May 2018, already under pressure over his sales, Mr Simon had texted the general manager to ask whether there would still be a position for him if he stepped away from sales.

The pay cut

Before he went on annual leave in August, the two men discussed a move back to the tools as a sign writer. They agreed to discuss his salary when he returned. While he was on leave, the company started paying him $36 an hour, which by his calculation was $71,136 a year. When he came back on 13 August he started the trades work, while still doing some sales tasks.

Mr Simon objected. On 21 August 2018 he was handed a contract for the new role and asked to sign it in the meeting. He refused and asked to negotiate his pay; the general manager said no. From 29 August he was on paid personal leave. His lawyers then wrote three times, saying he rejected the sign writer offer and would return to his account manager role on $90,363. The company did not move on the pay, and he declined its offer of a private mediation. On 21 December 2018 they wrote again, saying he accepted the company's conduct as ending his employment.

The company denied dismissing him. Under s 386 of the Act, a person is dismissed if the employment ends on the employer's initiative. One way that happens is an accepted repudiation: conduct that shows a reasonable person the employer no longer means to keep to the contract or one of its fundamental terms. Commissioner Wilson noted that repudiation may exist where an employer cuts an employee's wages without consent, and that an employee's silence is not acceptance.

The Commissioner found that pay was an essential term. Mr Simon had explored a move, but he did not "irrevocably or unconditionally" commit to it, and the pay was never agreed. Asking about another job was not "a blank cheque". Doing the new work at the lower rate was not accepting that rate, because he had plainly rejected it. By holding to $36 an hour and refusing to return him to his old role, the company repudiated the contract. When Mr Simon accepted that on 21 December 2018, he was dismissed.

Why the dismissal was unfair

A small business (fewer than 15 employees) that follows the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code has not unfairly dismissed anyone. For a dismissal that is not summary, the Code the Commission applied required a valid reason based on conduct or capacity, a warning, and a reasonable chance to fix the problem. The June warning was a first step, but it was never followed through and no reason for dismissal was ever given, so the dismissal was not consistent with the Code.

The Commission then applied the s 387 criteria for whether a dismissal is harsh, unjust or unreasonable. The company had put forward no reason for the dismissal at all, so there was no valid reason, Mr Simon could not have been told of one, and nothing showed it related to his performance. The Commissioner also found it unlikely that his bullying complaint had been taken seriously. The dismissal was harsh because it ended 18 years of service without properly considering what he had asked for.

How much was awarded

Mr Simon did not want his job back. The Commissioner accepted that the warning had been justified, and found his performance problems, his health and the unresolved bullying complaint meant he would probably have stayed only four more months. It also found his lawyers' letters had likely overreached. That was $30,121 in salary plus $2,861 in superannuation. Because of his long service with a single employer, the Commissioner increased it by 10%, to $36,280.

Because of the company's tight cash flow, it was ordered in three instalments, due within 14, 30 and 45 days.

What this means for you

If your employer suggests a different role, the pay and conditions should be agreed before anything changes. If you do not agree, say so clearly and in writing; working on at the new rate is not always agreement. Treating a contract as ended is a serious step, so it is worth getting advice before you take it.

For employers, a warning is the start of a process, not the end of one. A dismissal for poor performance needs a valid reason, a warning, and a fair chance to respond and improve, even in a small business. Time limits are short: an unfair dismissal claim must be lodged with the Fair Work Commission within 21 days of the dismissal.

The takeaway

A performance warning does not let an employer set a lower rate of pay for a new role without the employee's agreement. A unilateral pay cut can repudiate the contract, and if the employee accepts that, the employer has dismissed them; without a valid reason, that dismissal may well be unfair.

Note: No appeal from this decision is recorded. The law it applied still works the same way: s 386 (meaning of dismissed) and s 392 (compensation) have not been amended since 2019, and the July 2026 change that lets general protections disputes proceed on an alleged dismissal does not apply to unfair dismissal. The figures have moved: the high income threshold immediately before Mr Simon's dismissal was $145,400. For dismissals from 1 July 2026 it is $190,100, and compensation is capped at the lesser of 26 weeks' pay and $95,050. The Small Business Fair Dismissal Code the Commission applied, the 2009 declaration under s 388(1), is still the Code in force.

Fair Work Commission · 5 June 2019

John Simon v NGS Group Pty Ltd ATF NGS Discretionary Unit Trust [2019] FWC 3442, Commissioner Wilson. Read the full decision

This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.

Does this sound like your situation?

More case studies