Apprentice sacked by abusive text ultimatum wins unfair dismissal
Mr Jordan Lamacq v Smerff Electrical [2019] FWC 181
- Decided by
- Fair Work Commission
- Date
- 14 January 2019
- Outcome
- $11,400 compensation
- Result
- Employee succeeded

An apprentice electrician was given an abusive text ultimatum by his employer: hand over information about a former co-worker or lose his job. The Fair Work Commission found he had been dismissed, that the small business had not followed the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code, and that the dismissal was unfair. He was awarded $11,400, and a Full Bench refused the employer permission to appeal.
Key points
- An abusive ultimatum followed by "you've lost your apprenticeship" was a dismissal at the employer's initiative, not a resignation.
- Casual work of one to two days a fortnight was regular and systematic, so it counted towards the 12-month minimum period for a small business.
- The Small Business Fair Dismissal Code protects a summary dismissal only where the employer genuinely believed, on reasonable grounds and after a reasonable investigation, that the conduct was serious.
- Compensation was limited to 12 weeks' pay because the Commission found the job would not have lasted much longer.
What happened
Jordan Lamacq started at Smerff Electrical, a small electrical business in south-east Queensland, as a casual trade assistant on 23 January 2017. On 6 September 2017 he began a full-time, four-year apprenticeship there, with a work van of his own. Staff could do the occasional private "cash job".
On 31 March 2018, with the owner's permission, Mr Lamacq did a cash job alongside a former co-worker the owner had dismissed in February. The owner said that in May 2018 he found this former employee had been buying diesel on the company fuel card, although the business had no diesel vehicles. He decided that Mr Lamacq, a friend of that man, must know something.
On 15 May 2018 the owner sent Mr Lamacq a run of text messages, laced with abuse and threats, demanding the address of the cash job and the address where the former employee now worked. The deadline: "Info or job by 4 pm." Mr Lamacq did not give him the information. That afternoon the owner texted that he was a thief and that his TAFE blocks were being cancelled. Late that night an email told him: "You've lost your apprentice ship." The next day Mr Lamacq handed back the van keys.
The claim and the first two hurdles
Mr Lamacq applied to the Fair Work Commission for an unfair dismissal remedy under s 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The owner refused to take part in conciliation, and in a later email called the claim a "Friday extortion attempt" and threatened to publish material about Mr Lamacq so that it would be "number 1 of page 1 of google search results" for his name.
The employer raised two threshold points. First, a worker at a small business (fewer than 15 employees) must have served 12 months to bring a claim (s 383), and Mr Lamacq's full-time service was only about eight months. Under s 384(2)(a), casual service counts only if it was "regular and systematic" and the worker reasonably expected it to continue. "Regular" means a pattern of repetition, not necessarily frequent work. The owner conceded Mr Lamacq had worked one to two days a fortnight through the quiet months, and Deputy President Asbury found that his casual service counted.
Second, the owner said Mr Lamacq was never dismissed: he walked away by ignoring the ultimatum. Under s 386(1), a person is dismissed if the employer ends the employment. The Deputy President found that even if asking for the address was arguably reasonable, that "does not excuse or mitigate" the abuse, and that it was "inconceivable" an employee receiving such messages could think anything other than that the employer had ended the job.
The Small Business Fair Dismissal Code
A small business that follows the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code has not unfairly dismissed anyone. The Code allows dismissal without notice or warning where the employer believes on reasonable grounds that the employee's conduct is serious enough to justify immediate dismissal. That needs a genuine belief at the time, on reasonable grounds, after a reasonable investigation.
The Deputy President did not accept that the owner genuinely believed Mr Lamacq had stolen or knew of theft. Most, if not all, of the investigation came after the dismissal. His real motive, she found, was revenge against the former employee. Mr Lamacq's silence in the face of the abuse was "entirely understandable" and no sign of guilt. The dismissal was not consistent with the Code.
Why it was unfair
Section 387 then required the Commission to weigh, among other things, whether there was a valid reason and whether Mr Lamacq was told of it and could respond. There was no valid reason. Private use of the van and fuel card had been allowed, the cash job had been approved, and refusing an ultimatum couched in that language was reasonable.
Nor was he properly told the reasons: the owner had already decided he was guilty. Small size was no excuse. The Deputy President said she had never encountered a small business owner with "such a deplorable attitude to human resource management". The dismissal was harsh, because a first-year apprentice lost his apprenticeship; unjust, because he was not guilty of the misconduct alleged; and unreasonable.
How much was awarded
Mr Lamacq did not seek reinstatement. The Commission found the job would probably have lasted only another 12 weeks, because the relationship had soured. She noted that this finding, in effect, rewarded the owner's behaviour. At $25 an hour for a 38-hour week ($950), 12 weeks came to $11,400. Nothing was deducted for misconduct, since he had committed none.
The business sought permission to appeal. On 26 March 2019 a Full Bench refused it, finding no arguable error. It also noted that the owner had not paid, and said an appeal by a party who had not complied with the Commission's order would not be in the public interest.
What this means for you
If your employer gives you an abusive ultimatum and then treats you as gone, the law may treat that as a dismissal, not a resignation. Keep the messages; here they were the central evidence. Regular casual work before a permanent job can count towards the minimum period.
For small business owners, the Code protects a summary dismissal only where you genuinely believe, after a reasonable investigation done before you act, that the conduct was serious. Put the allegation calmly and listen to the answer. A worker who wants to claim unfair dismissal must usually apply within 21 days of the dismissal taking effect.
The takeaway
An employer cannot sack a worker with an abusive ultimatum and then call it a resignation. Even a small business must have a genuine, reasonably based belief of serious misconduct before dismissing on the spot.
Note: A Full Bench refused the employer permission to appeal: Smerff Electrical v Jordan Lamacq [2019] FWCFB 1767 (26 March 2019). The law applied here is unchanged: a small business (fewer than 15 employees) can still rely on the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code, its workers still need 12 months' service to claim, and casual service still counts towards that period only if it was regular and systematic (s 384(2)(a)). The wording of s 384(2)(a) changed in 2021: casual service now counts if the worker was a "regular casual employee", defined in s 12 as a casual employed on a regular and systematic basis, so the test is the same in substance. The definition of a casual employee itself has also changed (in 2021 and again from 26 August 2024). Compensation is still capped at the lesser of 26 weeks' pay and half the high income threshold; for dismissals from 1 July 2026 the threshold is $190,100 and the cap $95,050.
Fair Work Commission · 14 January 2019
Mr Jordan Lamacq v Smerff Electrical [2019] FWC 181, Deputy President Asbury. Read the full decision
This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.
Does this sound like your situation?
More case studies

Fair Work Commission · 17 December 2018
Sacked over a police check, but a false résumé cost him any remedy
Kelvin Njau v Superior Food Group Pty Ltd
A Melbourne food company dismissed a storeworker for failing a National Police Check, more than a year after it received his full criminal record. The Fair Work Commission found the dismissal unfair. But at the hearing he admitted inventing five years of work history on his résumé, so he got neither his job back nor compensation.
Unfair, but no compensation or reinstatementTermination#unfair dismissal#misconduct#procedural fairness
Read the case study
Fair Work Commission · 5 June 2019
Warned on sales, then paid less in a new role before pay was agreed
John Simon v NGS Group Pty Ltd ATF NGS Discretionary Unit Trust
After 18 years with a small signage business, a struggling account manager asked about a move back to the tools and was given a written performance warning. The business started paying him a lower hourly rate before the new pay had been agreed. The Fair Work Commission found the pay cut repudiated his contract, that he was dismissed when he accepted that, that the dismissal was unfair, and ordered $36,280 in compensation.
$36,280 compensationTermination#unfair dismissal#forced resignation#performance
Read the case study
Fair Work Commission · 13 December 2018
Cash guard sacked after $58,710 went missing wins her job back
Bedford v Linfox Armaguard Pty Ltd
An armoured-car crew leader was summarily dismissed after a bag holding $58,710 was left in her truck's transfer safe and later stolen from a repair workshop. The Fair Work Commission found she had been careless, but that she was only one link in a chain of failures, many of them the company's own. It ordered her reinstatement with most of her lost pay.
Reinstated, plus $40,792.25 lost payTermination#unfair dismissal#misconduct#procedural fairness
Read the case study