Her manager was sacked, then rehired. She sued him personally

Leung v Chung (Human Rights) [2022] VCAT 216

Decided by
Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal
Date
30 March 2022
Outcome
$10,000 general damages
Result
Employee succeeded
Illustrative image. It does not show the people in this case.

A production coordinator complained that her manager had touched her and commented on her body. He was dismissed, she resigned days later, and he was re-engaged within a month. With the company in liquidation, she pursued him personally: the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal found he had sexually harassed her and ordered him to pay $10,000 in general damages, but refused her claims for lost wages and aggravated damages.

Key points

  • A co-worker or manager can be personally liable for sexual harassment, so a claim can survive even when the employer has gone into liquidation.
  • Whether conduct was unwelcome is judged from the worker's point of view; whether it was sexual is judged objectively.
  • Not every touch is harassment: contact during a genuine product fitting was found to be unwelcome but not harassment in that setting.
  • Lost wages after a resignation are recoverable only if the harassment is what stopped the worker from working, and here the Tribunal was not satisfied it was.

What happened

Ms Leung, a 35-year-old woman born in Hong Kong, started work as a full-time production coordinator with Gumboots Australia Pty Ltd on 19 August 2019. Her direct manager was the production manager, Mr Chung. Both spoke Cantonese, and she often spoke to him in that language because she found his English hard to understand.

Over the next five months she said he slapped her on the buttocks three times, touched her chest while checking a tote bag she was modelling, asked why her upper body was so big but her bottom so skinny, pulled her towards him and tickled her waist when they were alone locking up, and the next day offered her a shoulder massage at her desk, which she said she declined. He denied the slaps, gave innocent explanations for the rest, and said any contact was the friendly support of a mentor for his protégé.

She complained in early January 2020. Mr Chung was dismissed on the spot the same day she met the company's owner, but Ms Leung resigned on 14 January 2020, the second working day after her complaint was dealt with, saying co-workers' questions about his dismissal made the workplace too stressful. Within a month the company had re-engaged him.

The claim

Ms Leung brought a claim under the Equal Opportunity Act 2010 (Vic), which says in s 93(2) that an employee must not sexually harass another person employed by the same employer. Her claim against the company was struck out on 20 November 2020 because it had been placed into liquidation, so the case proceeded against Mr Chung alone.

She claimed $110,000 in general damages, $53,050.95 in special damages (mostly lost wages) and $20,000 in aggravated damages.

Section 92 defines sexual harassment as an unwelcome sexual advance, an unwelcome request for sexual favours, or other unwelcome conduct of a sexual nature, in circumstances where a reasonable person would have anticipated that the other person would be offended, humiliated or intimidated. Conduct of a sexual nature includes any act of physical intimacy and any remark with sexual connotations made to or about a person in their presence.

Following an earlier VCAT decision, the Tribunal applied two different lenses. Whether conduct was unwelcome is subjective: how did this worker experience it? Whether it was of a sexual nature is objective. Ms Leung had to prove her case on the balance of probabilities, meaning more probably than not.

What the Tribunal decided

Senior Member Burdon-Smith found that six of the seven incidents were sexual harassment. On the three slaps, the Tribunal preferred Ms Leung's evidence, noting it would have been difficult for a seated Mr Chung to reach her shoulder, as he claimed. It found Ms Leung was considerably younger, junior to him and in a vulnerable position, and that a slap on the buttocks is an act of physical intimacy.

The body comment was found to be vulgar and inappropriate. Even if he only meant she was unsuited to modelling garments, it was a statement with a sexual connotation. The embrace, when they were alone, was an act designed to create physical intimacy, and the tickling was also of a sexual nature; his explanation that a sore knee made him lose his balance was rejected for want of medical evidence. Ms Leung forcing a laugh did not mean the contact was welcome.

Two findings went the other way, or not quite as she said. Ms Leung denied that any massage was given, but the Tribunal found it did happen, preferring Mr Chung's account that she said 'thank you'. It held that, given the escalating physical contact, it was still unwelcome conduct of a sexual nature. The tote bag fitting was not harassment: running a hand down the straps was normal in the industry, so a reasonable person would not have anticipated offence in that setting.

How much was awarded

The Tribunal accepted the medical evidence that her stress and anxiety were a consequence of the harassment, but noted her substantial recovery. The amount she claimed sat at the high end of awards, which had been made where the harassment was overt, manipulative and aggressive, and her case differed significantly from those. It awarded $10,000 in general damages.

The lost wages claim failed. The company had encouraged her to take time off, its director asked her to stay, and when she resigned she knew Mr Chung had gone. The Tribunal was not satisfied she was prevented from working there. Medical expenses failed for want of invoices, and aggravated damages were refused.

What this means for you

If you have been sexually harassed by a manager or co-worker, the person who did it can be held responsible personally, not just the business. That matters if the employer has closed or gone into liquidation. Keep a record of each incident as it happens, because the case turned on which account the Tribunal found more credible.

Think carefully, and get advice, before resigning. A claim for lost income can depend on whether the harassment, rather than your own choice, is what ended the job. Time limits apply to harassment complaints, so it is worth acting early.

The takeaway

A manager who harasses a junior worker can be ordered to pay damages personally, even after the employer has collapsed. But resigning quickly, after the harasser has already gone, can cost a claim for lost wages.

Note: This was a Victorian case under the Equal Opportunity Act 2010 (Vic). A Perth worker would usually complain under the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (WA) or the federal Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth). Since this decision the federal law has moved: employers have had a positive duty under the Sex Discrimination Act to take reasonable and proportionate steps to eliminate workplace sexual harassment since 13 December 2022, and since 6 March 2023 the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) has prohibited sexual harassment in connection with work and lets the Fair Work Commission deal with those disputes. No appeal from this decision was found.

$10,000 general damagesSexual harassmentCompensation

Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal · 30 March 2022

Leung v Chung (Human Rights) [2022] VCAT 216, Senior Member Burdon-Smith. Read the full decision

This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.

Does this sound like your situation?

More case studies