An HR manager's nine bullying complaints, and why none succeeded
Application by Ms Y [2021] FWC 6347
- Decided by
- Fair Work Commission
- Date
- 16 November 2021
- Outcome
- Stop-bullying application dismissed
- Result
- Employer succeeded

A school's human resources manager asked the Fair Work Commission to stop what she said was bullying by her manager, the deputy principal and the principal. She relied on nine incidents over about eight months. The Commission found that, judged objectively, each was reasonable management action, and dismissed her application.
Key points
- Under s 789FD of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), bullying means repeated unreasonable behaviour that creates a risk to health and safety.
- The test is objective: a worker's genuine distress does not prove the behaviour was unreasonable.
- Reasonable management action carried out in a reasonable manner, such as giving directions, allocating work and declining a proposal, is not bullying.
- A stop-bullying order looks to the future and cannot award money.
What happened
Ms Y had been the human resources manager at a school in Victoria since December 2019. Over time her working relationship with her manager, the school's Director Staff & Strategy, broke down. She applied to the Fair Work Commission for an order to stop bullying, naming her manager, the deputy principal and the principal.
She relied on nine incidents between September 2020 and April 2021. Among them: her manager did not answer an email asking for software training; he declined to support a staff wellbeing video presentation she had prepared; he would not give her a full copy of a planning document; and he twice left her out of staff wellbeing meetings when he was new in his role.
Two disputes were more serious. Her manager directed her to issue a contract to a returning casual employee for a school camp. She refused, believing a fresh police check was needed. She issued it only after he had asked several times and called her email “rude and disrespectful”. Some weeks later she was told to take over the school's volunteer program. She declined the handover meeting twice, saying the work was outside her position description.
In May 2021 the school handed her a without prejudice letter raising concerns about her conduct, with one option involving her resignation. She was admitted to hospital that evening and made a workers' compensation claim, which was accepted. The school suspended her email access while she was off work. She began a graduated return to work on 7 October 2021.
The legal test
A worker can ask the Commission for an order to stop bullying under s 789FC of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The Commission can make any order it considers appropriate under s 789FF, except an order to pay money. Before it can act, it must be satisfied of two things: that the worker has been bullied at work, and that there is a risk the bullying will continue.
Section 789FD says a worker is bullied when an individual or group “repeatedly behaved unreasonably” towards them, and that behaviour creates a risk to health and safety. One incident is not enough. Behaviour is unreasonable if a reasonable person, in all the circumstances, may consider it unreasonable.
There is an important exception. Reasonable management action carried out in a reasonable manner is not bullying. Management action is not confined to formal decisions. It includes performance and disciplinary matters, allocating work and directing how work is done. The action does not need to be perfect. The question is whether it was reasonable, not whether it could have been done more reasonably.
What the Commission decided
Commissioner O'Neill dismissed the application. Where the evidence conflicted, the Commissioner preferred the evidence of the three managers, which was consistent with the emails and documents. Ms Y was found to be a genuine witness, but one whose “highly structured and somewhat inflexible way of thinking” coloured how she saw events.
Each incident failed. Overlooking one email among about 100 a day was “unremarkable”. Declining the presentation, with reasons, was reasonable conduct by a direct manager. Ms Y was not in the senior leadership team and was not entitled to the full planning document. The missed meetings were an oversight that was put right with an apology once her manager learned of it.
On the casual employee, the Commission said Ms Y acted properly in raising her concerns. But once senior staff had considered them and decided a new check was not needed, the direction was reasonable. In the Commissioner's words, “The direction to Ms Y was reasonable, however Ms Y's continued refusal to follow it was not.” Onboarding volunteers was not substantially different from onboarding employees, so that direction was reasonable too.
The letter, the email suspension and the referral to an independent medical examination were also reasonable. The Commission accepted Ms Y was “genuinely highly distressed”, but the law required it to focus on the conduct itself, not her perception of it.
What this means for you
If you feel bullied, the Commission will look at what was actually done and why, not only at how it felt. Directions you disagree with, rejected work and a manager's oversights are usually not bullying unless they are themselves unreasonable. Keeping emails and notes made at the time matters, because the Commission relies heavily on documents when accounts differ.
If you are an employer, this case shows the value of explaining decisions, putting directions in writing and correcting mistakes promptly. A stop-bullying order is about the future: it needs a risk that the bullying will continue, so it is mainly of use while the worker is still in the job, and it cannot award compensation. Consider getting advice early if relationships at work are breaking down.
The takeaway
Feeling bullied and being bullied are different things in law. Reasonable directions, carried out reasonably, are management, not bullying, even when they are unwelcome.
Note: The school, the applicant and the witnesses were anonymised by order of the Commission. Since this decision, the Fair Work Legislation Amendment (Secure Jobs, Better Pay) Act 2022 (Cth) moved the orders to stop sexual harassment out of Part 6-4B of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and into Part 3-5A, from 6 March 2023. The stop-bullying test in s 789FD and the Commission's power to make orders in s 789FF, as applied in this case, are otherwise unchanged as at October 2026. No appeal from this decision has been found.
Fair Work Commission · 16 November 2021
Application by Ms Y [2021] FWC 6347, Commissioner O’Neill. Read the full decision
This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.
Does this sound like your situation?
More case studies

Fair Work Commission · 27 July 2021
A new store manager, a final warning and a stop-bullying order
Tao (Selina) Qu v Monards Gold Coast Pty Ltd; Tak Wing Wong
A long-serving supervisor at a Surfers Paradise jewellery and watch store applied for an order to stop bullying by the team leader brought in above her. The Fair Work Commission went through each incident she raised, found many but not all of them were unreasonable behaviour, and made an order to stop the bullying.
Stop-bullying order madeDiscrimination & bullying#bullying#performance#procedural fairness
Read the case study
ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Appeal Tribunal) · 18 March 2022
Union delegate spoke to the press, then faced possible counselling
Casino Canberra Limited v Kidman (Appeal)
Mr Kidman, a casino inspector and union delegate, told The Canberra Times that staff were in the dark about a pending sale of the casino. Two days later the casino's in-house lawyer wrote to him suggesting he may have breached the employee handbook and foreshadowing formal performance counselling. The ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal found this was unlawful discrimination because of his industrial activity, and on appeal the $4,000 damages and $4,620 costs order stood.
$4,000 damages and $4,620 costs upheldDiscrimination & bullying#discrimination#general protections#investigations
Read the case study
Federal Court of Australia · 20 August 2020
Told she was welcome back, then told to wait for her second baby
Fair Work Ombudsman v Austrend International Pty Ltd (No 2)
After her first baby, Ms Aragon agreed a full-time return date with her Perth employer. When she told them she was pregnant again, they extended her unpaid leave and then denied any agreement. The Federal Court, on the employer's admission, found adverse action because of her sex and pregnancy, ordered $2,000 compensation and ordered the company and its director to pay penalties.
$2,000 compensation and $18,300 in penaltiesDiscrimination & bullying#pregnancy & carers#discrimination#general protections
Read the case study