No work for 21 months: stevedore wins the right to take redundancy

Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Qube Ports Pty Ltd T/A Qube Ports & Bulk [2022] FWC 78

Decided by
Fair Work Commission
Date
19 January 2022
Outcome
Voluntary redundancy ordered
Result
Employee succeeded
Illustrative image. It does not show the people in this case.

When COVID-19 shut cruise ships out of Sydney Harbour, a 60-year-old stevedore had no work for 21 months and was eventually stood down without pay. His employer refused to let him take voluntary redundancy, saying the ships would come back. The Fair Work Commission held that the enterprise agreement's downturn clause required the employer to declare his position redundant and offer him a voluntary redundancy, and a Full Bench refused the employer permission to appeal.

Key points

  • An enterprise agreement can give rights beyond the Fair Work Act, including a staged process an employer must follow when work dries up.
  • Once the employer triggered the agreement's downturn clause, the Commission held its steps were mandatory, not optional.
  • An employer's hope that work will return 'at some unknown time' was not a reasonable reason to refuse a voluntary redundancy.
  • An offer of work at another port was not acceptable alternative employment once the worker's family circumstances were taken into account.

What happened

Mr Johnson, 60, loaded and unloaded cargo from cruise ships at Sydney Harbour for Qube Ports. He was a variable salary employee: he had no fixed roster and worked when ships were in, but he was guaranteed a minimum fortnightly payment of $2,790.57. If he was paid the guarantee without working enough hours to earn it, the shortfall was carried forward as a debt to be worked off later.

Sydney Harbour was the only port where Qube's work related solely to cruise ships. From 18 March 2020 the Commonwealth's COVID-19 restrictions kept cruise ships out of Australian waters, and Qube's Sydney Harbour work stopped entirely.

On 1 April 2020 Qube triggered the "Negative Circumstances" clause of its enterprise agreement. Mr Johnson took six days of annual leave in April, and from 4 May 2020 he was stood down under the JobKeeper scheme, receiving $1,500 a fortnight. JobKeeper ended for Qube on 27 September 2020, and the guaranteed payments, and the debt, started again.

The offer, the refusal and the stand down

In October 2020 Qube offered its non-casual Sydney Harbour stevedores work at Port Kembla, about 95 kilometres away. Most accepted; Mr Johnson declined. He gave evidence that the travel and 12-hour shifts would make his work and travel time about 15 hours a day, and that his wife worked full time and his youngest child was about to start year 11 and 12 ATAR studies. The Sydney cruise rosters had let him collect his children from school and cook the evening meal.

His union then asked Qube to offer him a voluntary redundancy. Qube refused. It said that if it made the offer to him it would have to make it to all its Sydney Harbour stevedores, and that there would be work for them when the ships returned. By December 2020 Mr Johnson's debt to Qube was over $14,000, and on 21 December 2020 Qube stood him down without pay under s 524 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). That section lets an employer stand down an employee who cannot usefully be employed because of, among other things, a stoppage of work the employer cannot reasonably be held responsible for.

The union took the dispute to the Fair Work Commission under the agreement's dispute resolution clause (s 739 of the Act), with a separate stand down dispute under s 526 in reserve. The question was whether Mr Johnson's position was redundant.

The answer turned on clause 13 of the agreement. Once triggered, it set out steps that "are to be followed": consult (Step 1), let employees use leave and other measures (Step 2), and allow downgrades (Step 3), all within 30 days. If those measures had not worked, Step 4 "will be triggered": Qube would declare the number of redundancies needed, employees could volunteer, and "Expressions of interest will not be unreasonably refused." Only Step 5, compulsory redundancies, was left to Qube's discretion.

What the Commission decided

Deputy President Bull accepted that, as a general rule, an employer is not compelled to make a job redundant. But this agreement said the steps were to be followed, and Qube, having chosen to trigger the clause, could not then decide not to complete Step 4.

Steps 2 and 3 had not fixed Mr Johnson's hours shortfall. Qube had not done business at the port for over 21 months and could not say when it would. On that evidence there was "no sustainable argument" that his Sydney Harbour position was anything other than redundant.

Qube's reasons for refusal were not reasonable. The risk of a precedent for other employees "cannot be held against Mr Johnson", and nor could an expectation that work would return at some unknown time. The Port Kembla offer did not change things: the Commission was not persuaded by his financial arguments, but accepted that, given his family circumstances, the offer was not acceptable alternative employment. JobKeeper had likely let Qube set the clause aside while it applied, but from 27 September 2020 Step 4 should have been acted on. Qube was ordered to declare Mr Johnson's position redundant and offer him a voluntary redundancy. It therefore did not need to rule on whether the stand down was valid.

What happened next

Qube appealed. On 6 April 2022 a Full Bench refused permission to appeal. It agreed that the word "will" required Qube to declare a number of redundancies, and held that Qube's intention to resume work at some unidentifiable future time was not the kind of objective economic data the clause required. The Full Bench stressed that this was a redundancy right created by the agreement, which is different from the general redundancy pay rules in s 119 of the Act, and that its decision was confined to that narrow context.

What this means for you

If you have been stood down for a long time with no end in sight, check your enterprise agreement or contract as well as the Fair Work Act. Some agreements set out a process the employer must follow when work dries up, including a right to put your hand up for redundancy.

This case depended on the wording of one agreement. Without a clause like it, an employer is generally not obliged to make a job redundant just because work has stopped. The stand down provisions in s 524 have not changed since this decision; the JobKeeper stand down rules had been repealed before this decision. If you are unsure where you stand, it is worth getting advice early.

The takeaway

An enterprise agreement can give workers rights the Fair Work Act does not. When an employer triggers a downturn clause, it may have to follow it through to the end, including offering voluntary redundancy.

Note: Qube's application for permission to appeal was refused by a Full Bench on 6 April 2022 ([2022] FWCFB 53). The JobKeeper stand down provisions (former Part 6-4C of the Fair Work Act) had been repealed before the decision; s 524 (stand down) and s 119 (redundancy pay) are unchanged since the decision.

Voluntary redundancy orderedRedundancyContracts

Fair Work Commission · 19 January 2022

Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Qube Ports Pty Ltd T/A Qube Ports & Bulk [2022] FWC 78, Deputy President Bull. Read the full decision

This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.

Does this sound like your situation?

More case studies