Milk tanker driver called 'casual' was really a permanent employee
Jess v Cooloola Milk Pty Ltd [2022] FCAFC 75
- Decided by
- Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia
- Date
- 10 May 2022
- Outcome
- Appeal won: not a casual, claims sent back for hearing
- Result
- Employee succeeded

A truck driver hauled milk for a dairy business for more than four years on a set wage, with paid leave and no casual loading, while his employer called him a casual. When he was dismissed soon after asking to be paid for extra hours, the trial judge rejected his claims. The Full Court of the Federal Court held he was not a casual employee, that his question about pay was a protected inquiry, and sent the case back for a new hearing.
Key points
- Calling someone a casual does not make them one: the Full Court looked at whether there was a firm advance commitment to ongoing work, and found there was.
- Regular shifts, a set wage on a 38-hour week, paid sick days and holidays, no casual loading and two weeks' notice all pointed away from casual employment.
- Telling the boss 'I will if you pay me' was an inquiry about overtime, which is a workplace right protected by the general protections.
- Ending a casual's employment can still be adverse action; casual employees are protected too.
What happened
In April 2014 Cooloola Milk needed a new driver for its prime mover and milk tanker, because its existing driver was about to retire. Gregory Jess, an experienced truck driver, started a two-week trial on 2 May 2014. At the end of it the company's managing director, who was also its majority shareholder, told him he "had the job". Nothing was put in writing.
The managing director's evidence was that he told Mr Jess the job was casual. Mr Jess said he had always been a full-time employee. For more than four years he collected milk from dairy farms and drove the "Brisbane run" to distributors on a regular weekly pattern. He was paid a set wage based on a 38-hour week, received no casual loading, and was paid for sick days and holidays.
On 23 December 2018 the managing director asked him to cart cow manure after his Brisbane run on 24 December, and to do three manure runs on 27 December. The manure work had nothing to do with the milk business. Mr Jess answered, "I will if you pay me." His evidence was that on Boxing Day he arrived to find another driver had already taken the truck; he felt humiliated and took a sick day. On 4 January 2019 he was told his services were no longer required and given two weeks' notice.
The claim and the first decision
Mr Jess sued the company, and the managing director as a person involved, in the Federal Circuit Court. He said he had been underpaid, that he was dismissed for exercising a workplace right, and that he had been misled about his entitlements.
The trial judge rejected almost all of it. He found Mr Jess was a casual, and that ending casual employment could not be adverse action. He said "I will if you pay me" was not a complaint or inquiry, just a reply to a request to do extra duties. He accepted the managing director's evidence that pay had not crossed his mind when he decided to dismiss. The only contravention found was a failure to keep employee records, and no penalty was imposed.
What the Full Court decided
On 10 May 2022 the Full Court allowed the appeal, set aside two of the trial judge's orders, and sent the case back to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2). All three judges agreed that Mr Jess was not a casual employee and was entitled to the statutory and award entitlements of a full-time employee, with the amount still to be worked out.
They also agreed that dismissing a casual can be adverse action (the employer conceded the trial judge was wrong on this), that Mr Jess's words were a protected inquiry about overtime, and that the trial judge should not have decided penalties without hearing from the parties as agreed.
The judges split on why Mr Jess was dismissed. Justice McElwaine would have left the trial judge's finding alone. Justices Rangiah and Downes held the trial judge had overlooked important evidence: the managing director accepted the dismissal would "probably not" have happened without the 23 December conversation, he only "had a think" about Mr Jess's efficiency after it, and he spoke of having to "bite the bullet" to stop "rot" spreading if other workers asked for more money. That claim was sent back for a retrial.
Why: the legal tests
At the time, s 15A of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) said a person was a casual employee if the job was offered, and accepted, on the basis that the employer made no firm advance commitment to continuing and indefinite work according to an agreed pattern of work. A court could look only at four things: whether work could be offered and refused at will, whether the worker worked as required by the employer's needs, whether the job was described as casual, and whether a casual loading or casual rate applied.
Here work was always available, there were regular shifts of about seven hours a day, Mr Jess had to ask permission to take leave, and he received paid leave and notice but no loading. The casual label carried little weight against all that.
The general protections in s 340 stop an employer taking adverse action, such as dismissal, because an employee has exercised a workplace right. Under s 341(1)(c)(ii), that includes making an inquiry about one's employment. The award gave Mr Jess an entitlement to overtime, so asking whether he would be paid for extra hours was protected. Under s 361 the employer must prove that the inquiry was not part of its reason.
What this means for you
If you are called a casual but work a steady roster for a set wage, take paid leave and get no casual loading, it is worth checking whether you are really casual, because a permanent employee has rights to leave, notice and other entitlements a casual does not. Asking your employer whether you will be paid for extra hours, where an award or contract gives you a right to that pay, can be a protected inquiry, whether you are casual or permanent. For employers, the label in the letter of offer is not the end of the question, and records of hours must be kept.
If you have been dismissed and believe it was because you raised a pay question, a general protections claim must usually be lodged with the Fair Work Commission within 21 days.
The takeaway
Being called a casual does not make you one. And asking whether you will be paid for extra work can be a protected workplace right, for casuals and permanent employees alike.
Note: The definition of casual employee applied here has since been replaced. From 26 August 2024, under the Fair Work Legislation Amendment (Closing Loopholes No. 2) Act 2024, a person is a casual only if there is no firm advance commitment to continuing and indefinite work and they are entitled to a casual loading or casual rate. The question is judged on the real substance, practical reality and true nature of the relationship, including how it was actually carried out (for employment that began before 26 August 2024, conduct before that date is disregarded). Casuals can now give notice to change to permanent employment after 6 months, or 12 months with a small business. No later decision on the retrial ordered in this case was found.
Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia · 10 May 2022
Jess v Cooloola Milk Pty Ltd [2022] FCAFC 75, Justices Rangiah, Downes and McElwaine. Read the full decision
This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.
Does this sound like your situation?
More case studies

Fair Work Commission · 4 November 2021
Lost contract, new job, but redundancy pay still owed
Savco Vegetation Services Pty Ltd
A vegetation management company lost a major contract and made workers redundant. It helped the rival that won the contract recruit them, then asked the Fair Work Commission to cut nine workers' redundancy pay to nil. The Commission dismissed the application: the company had not obtained the new job, and the new job was not acceptable anyway.
Redundancy pay not reducedPay & contracts#redundancy#for employers#contracts
Read the case study
Fair Work Commission Full Bench · 14 December 2023
Made five staff redundant, then said it couldn't afford redundancy pay
RingIR Pty Ltd v Maryanne Spiers, Lisa Linssen, Richard Hebden, Jacob Filiti, Alex Barry
A technology start-up made five employees redundant and then asked the Fair Work Commission to reduce their redundancy pay, $106,673.08 between them, to nothing, saying it could not afford it. The Commission looked at the whole financial picture, including a $110,000 pay rise for the new CEO, and refused. A Full Bench dismissed the employer's appeal.
$106,673 redundancy pay not reducedPay & contracts#redundancy#for employers
Read the case study
Federal Circuit Court of Australia · 26 August 2020
Juice bars and their manager hit with almost $277,000 in penalties
Fair Work Ombudsman v Skypac Group Pty Ltd & Ors
Two companies running juice bars in Werribee and Geelong underpaid almost thirty workers under the Fast Food Industry Award, kept false pay and time records, and made one worker hand money back. After the companies and their general manager admitted the contraventions, the Federal Circuit Court ordered penalties totalling $276,929.75.
$276,929.75 in penaltiesPay & contracts#underpayment#penalties#for employers
Read the case study