Juice bars and their manager hit with almost $277,000 in penalties

Fair Work Ombudsman v Skypac Group Pty Ltd & Ors [2020] FCCA 2332

Decided by
Federal Circuit Court of Australia
Date
26 August 2020
Outcome
$276,929.75 in penalties
Result
Employee succeeded
Illustrative image. It does not show the people in this case.

Two companies running juice bars in Werribee and Geelong underpaid almost thirty workers under the Fast Food Industry Award, kept false pay and time records, and made one worker hand money back. After the companies and their general manager admitted the contraventions, the Federal Circuit Court ordered penalties totalling $276,929.75.

Key points

  • Paying less than the award's minimum hourly rate, casual loading or weekend and public holiday rates is a breach of s 45 of the Fair Work Act.
  • A manager who runs pay and rostering can be personally liable as a person involved in the employer's contraventions.
  • Making false pay records and requiring workers to hand back recovered wages were treated as among the most serious conduct.
  • Claims of cultural difference or limited English did not reduce the penalty, and the court rejected the argument that the underpayments were not deliberate.

What happened

Two related companies, Skypac Group and Skypic Group, ran Hello Juice stores in Werribee and Geelong, in Victoria. One person was the general manager of both businesses and ran their day-to-day management, including hiring, rostering and pay.

The workers were covered by the Fast Food Industry Award 2010, a modern award: a legal instrument setting the minimum pay and conditions for an industry. Many were casual employees, and several were juniors entitled to the award's junior rates.

After an investigation in 2017, the Fair Work Ombudsman, the federal agency that enforces workplace laws, alleged that the two companies had underpaid almost thirty employees. The companies and the manager later admitted the contraventions. The judge described the conduct at the start of the judgment, quoting an earlier case, as "a case about greed and the exploitation of the vulnerable".

What the businesses did wrong

The companies admitted failing to pay the award's minimum adult and junior hourly rates, the casual loading, and the Saturday, Sunday and public holiday penalty rates. They also failed to give pay slips within one working day of paying staff, and failed to keep the employee records the law requires.

The more serious conduct went further. The first company made and used false or misleading records of hourly rates, amounts paid, penalty rates and hours worked. It required one worker to pay it $896 in relation to her tax return, and to pay back $4,046.19 in relation to a rectification payment: money recovered for her because she had been underpaid. The second company failed to comply with the Ombudsman's notice to produce records.

The general manager was found to have been involved in each of the companies' contraventions. Under s 550 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), a person "involved in" a contravention is treated as having contravened the law too, so a manager can be ordered to pay a penalty personally.

The court's task: an agreed penalty

The companies and the manager made full admissions, and they agreed with the Ombudsman on the declarations to be made and on a range of penalties. The question for Judge O'Sullivan was how much they should pay.

An agreement does not bind the court. The judge said the court's role was not to simply "rubber stamp" an agreed penalty, though it is desirable to impose it if it is appropriate. The maximum penalty is the yardstick, and the main purpose of a civil penalty, a sum paid to the Commonwealth for breaking the law, is deterrence: discouraging both this employer and others.

The court worked through a list of factors used in penalty cases, including the nature of the conduct, the loss it caused, any previous similar conduct, the size of the business, whether the breaches were deliberate, whether senior management was involved, and contrition and cooperation.

The judge found the conduct serious. Records were kept in a way that concealed the contraventions, the underpayments came to over $30,000, and there were attempts to claw back underpaid amounts. The impact was greater because the workers relied on the award. The businesses said they had not deliberately set out to avoid their obligations; the court rejected that.

The businesses argued that the manager's conduct was affected by a "Chinese Culture difference" and "average English". The judge rejected those claims as a reason to reduce the penalty and said the fact they were made underscored the need for deterrence.

The parties grouped related contraventions together, and the court proceeded on that basis. Where conduct overlapped, the court imposed no penalty or a nominal one for some breaches and a substantial penalty for others. On the agreed grouping, the maximum penalties were $657,000 for the first company, $432,000 for the second and $217,800 for the manager. Then the court applied the totality principle: a final check that the combined penalty fits the conduct as a whole.

How much was ordered

After a 30% reduction for totality, the first company was ordered to pay $161,988.75 and the second company $80,325. The manager received a larger 50% reduction, partly because of evidence that neither store would operate after June 2020 and the effect of COVID-19 on her finances, and was ordered to pay $34,616. She could pay $5,000 within 28 days and the rest within 12 months.

The penalties are paid to the Commonwealth, not to the workers. Penalties are separate from the wages owed.

What this means for you

If you work in fast food, retail or hospitality, it is worth checking your pay slips against your award: the base rate, the casual loading and the weekend and public holiday rates. Not getting a pay slip at all is a breach in itself.

If your employer asks you to hand back money you were paid for an underpayment, or to pay them money in some other way, that may be unlawful. Consider getting advice early, and keep your own record of the hours you work.

The takeaway

Underpaying award wages, keeping false records and clawing back wages can cost a business and its managers a great deal more than the wages saved, and a manager who runs the payroll can be personally liable.

Note: The Federal Circuit Court is now the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2), since 1 September 2021, and the award is now the Fast Food Industry Award 2020. The law has since become tougher. The Closing Loopholes changes altered the civil penalty amounts for conduct after 27 February 2024, and for underpayment conduct after 1 January 2025 a penalty can be calculated by reference to the amount underpaid. From 1 January 2025, intentionally underpaying an employee is also a crime under s 327A of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), with a maximum of 10 years' imprisonment for an individual. No appeal from this decision was found.

$276,929.75 in penaltiesUnderpaymentPenaltiesFor employers

Federal Circuit Court of Australia · 26 August 2020

Fair Work Ombudsman v Skypac Group Pty Ltd & Ors [2020] FCCA 2332, Judge O'Sullivan. Read the full decision

This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.

Does this sound like your situation?

More case studies