Dismissed? Unfair dismissal or general protections, and how to choose

Type
Guide
Topic
Termination of Employment
First published
13 August 2016
Illustrative image.

Most dismissed workers have two main options under the Fair Work Act: an unfair dismissal claim, which asks whether the dismissal was fair, and a general protections claim, which asks why the employer acted. This guide explains who can make each claim, how each is decided, what each can achieve, and why choosing the right one early matters.

Key points

  • Unfair dismissal needs a minimum period of employment and, unless an award or agreement covers you, earnings under $190,100 (for dismissals from 1 July 2026); compensation is capped at 26 weeks' pay or $95,050, whichever is less.
  • A general protections claim has no minimum period, no income threshold and no compensation cap, but it must be about a prohibited reason such as a complaint, leave or a protected attribute.
  • You generally cannot run both claims about the same dismissal, so the choice matters.
  • Both claims must be lodged within 21 days of a dismissal; WA state system unfair dismissal claims have 28 days.

Two main claims

If you have lost your job and think it was wrong, the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) gives most workers two main ways to challenge it: an unfair dismissal claim and a general protections claim. They ask different questions, have different eligibility rules and lead to different remedies.

In broad terms, an unfair dismissal claim asks whether the dismissal was fair. A general protections claim asks why your employer acted, and whether the reason was one the law prohibits. You generally cannot run both about the same dismissal (ss 725–732), so the choice matters from the start.

Unfair dismissal

You are dismissed if your employment ended on your employer's initiative, or if you were forced to resign because of your employer's conduct (s 386). The second kind is often called constructive dismissal.

To claim, you must have served the minimum employment period: six months, or 12 months if your employer had fewer than 15 employees (s 383). You must also be covered by a modern award or enterprise agreement, or earn less than the high income threshold, which is $190,100 for dismissals from 1 July 2026.

The Fair Work Commission then decides whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable. It must consider each matter in s 387: whether there was a valid reason related to your capacity or conduct, whether you were told the reason and given a chance to respond, any unreasonable refusal to let you have a support person at discussions about the dismissal, any warnings about poor performance, the size of the business and its access to human resources staff, and any other relevant matter. A dismissal that was a genuine redundancy under s 389 cannot be unfair, but a redundancy is genuine only if the job was no longer needed, any duty to consult was met, and redeployment would not have been reasonable.

The remedy is reinstatement or, if that is inappropriate, compensation. Compensation is capped at the lesser of 26 weeks' pay and half the high income threshold ($95,050 for dismissals from 1 July 2026), and nothing is awarded for shock or distress (s 392).

An example: treated differently

In Fagan v Department of Human Services [2012] FWA 3043, a youth justice worker with about 25 years in the Victorian public service was dismissed after he opened a young person's door alone during lockdown hours to hand over toilet paper. The young people overpowered him and several escaped.

Commissioner Cribb found there was a valid reason for the dismissal and that the process was fair. But a colleague had opened a door alone during lockdown to deliver water a few days earlier and faced no disciplinary action. Weighing that different treatment together with the worker's age and long service, Fair Work Australia (now the Fair Work Commission) found the dismissal harsh "on fine balance" and ordered $20,419.10 in compensation. The case shows that even where there is a valid reason, the other matters in s 387 can still tip the result.

General protections

A general protections claim is about adverse action taken for a prohibited reason. Adverse action includes dismissing you, injuring you in your employment, changing your position to your detriment, or treating you differently from other employees. For a job applicant it includes refusing to employ them.

The prohibited reasons include that you have, used or proposed to use a workplace right (such as a right to pay, leave, or to make a complaint or inquiry about your employment), that you engaged in industrial activity, or a protected attribute (s 351). Separately, you must not be dismissed because you were temporarily absent through illness or injury (s 352). The attributes are race, colour, sex, sexual orientation, breastfeeding, gender identity, intersex status, age, physical or mental disability, marital status, family or carer's responsibilities, subjection to family and domestic violence, pregnancy, religion, political opinion, national extraction and social origin, with limited exceptions such as the inherent requirements of the job.

Once you allege that your employer acted for a prohibited reason, and show the action happened and that you had the right or attribute you rely on, the law presumes your employer acted for that reason, and your employer must prove it did not (s 361). This is called the reverse onus.

Which claim fits

A general protections claim has no minimum employment period, no income threshold and no cap on compensation, and a court can award compensation for hurt and humiliation. It also protects prospective employees and, in some situations, independent contractors. But it succeeds only if a prohibited reason was behind the action. If your employer simply acted unfairly, without any prohibited reason, unfair dismissal is usually the better fit, if you are eligible.

If you have been dismissed, both claims must be lodged with the Fair Work Commission within 21 days. Since 7 July 2026 a general protections claim can proceed at the Commission on an alleged dismissal, so an employer's argument that you resigned does not stop the application. If you work in the WA state system, for example for a sole trader, a partnership, a WA local government or a WA public sector employer, an unfair dismissal claim goes to the WA Industrial Relations Commission instead, with a 28-day time limit. Because the choice of claim is hard to undo, it is worth getting advice early.

The takeaway

Unfair dismissal asks whether the dismissal was fair; general protections asks why it happened. Work out which question fits your situation, and act within 21 days.

Note: First published in August 2016 and rewritten in October 2026. The old article gave the 2016 high income threshold ($138,900) and compensation cap ($69,450); these are updated to the figures for dismissals from 1 July 2026 ($190,100 and $95,050). It also described the Fagan case as a prison officer dismissed after a lockdown; the judgment shows a youth justice worker at a juvenile justice centre. Other updates: the s 389 test for genuine redundancy, the protected attributes added since 2016 (including gender identity, intersex status and subjection to family and domestic violence), the reverse onus, the rule against bringing both claims, the WA state system route, and the general protections change from 7 July 2026 (Act No. 62, 2026), under which an alleged dismissal is enough to start a claim at the Commission.

General information about the law as it stands, not legal advice. Every situation turns on its own facts. First published 13 August 2016; updated 21 October 2026.

Does this sound like your situation?

More case studies