Told to pay union dues or find a job where the wage "sucks"

Tyson v Heiko Constructions trading as Heiko Constructions Pty Ltd [2021] FedCFamC2G 212

Decided by
Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2)
Date
5 November 2021
Outcome
$60,000 penalty ordered paid to him, plus $7,000 compensation
Result
Employee succeeded
Illustrative image. It does not show the people in this case.

A building patcher on a Gold Coast tower project quit the CFMEU over its handling of a safety accident. His foreman called him into the office and told him that if he did not pay the union he could find other work, for a wage that "sucks". The court found the employer had unlawfully coerced him, imposed a $60,000 penalty payable to him and awarded $7,000 for his distress, but his claim about his later dismissal failed.

Key points

  • Section 348 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) stops anyone threatening action against a person to coerce them into industrial activity, and that includes pressuring someone to join, or rejoin, a union.
  • Once the threat is shown, the employer must prove it did not intend to coerce; the court disbelieved the foreman, so the employer failed.
  • A calm, friendly-sounding conversation can still be a threat, and a foreman's words can be the employer's conduct.
  • The penalty can be ordered paid to the worker, but compensation covers only loss caused by the threat itself: here distress, not lost wages.

What happened

John Tyson is a very experienced building labourer whose specialty is patching. From late June 2017 he worked on the Jewel project, a large tower development in Surfers Paradise. He was employed by Heiko Constructions, a labour hire company that supplied workers to another builder on the site, and paid a base rate of $41.13 an hour.

In September 2017 Mr Tyson was the only witness when a co-worker fell and fractured his leg. He believed poor housekeeping caused it and that the area had been tidied up afterwards. When a union delegate read out a report to about 120 workers that, in effect, cleared management, he said it was wrong, and he resigned from the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) at that meeting. From then on he refused to pay union dues.

The meeting in the foreman's office

On 27 April 2018 the foreman, Mr Tyson's effective boss on site, called him into his office. Mr Tyson recorded the conversation. The foreman raised his union dues and said the good wages came from the site's enterprise agreement (EBA). Mr Tyson pointed to a poster in the shed saying workers were free to choose. The foreman replied that he had been around long enough to know how all the politics work.

Then came the bottom line. If he did not want to pay the union, there were other jobs out there: "You don't have to pay the union, but, you know, your wage sucks", for about half the money. In fact the EBA did not cover Mr Tyson. A few days later union officials told him that if he paid, he would be there for another 12 months; if not, it would be in the hands of the owner of the builder Heiko supplied. On 11 May 2018 the foreman told him it was his last day. Nine workers went that day as the project wound down.

The claims and the decision

Mr Tyson, who ran his trial without a lawyer, brought a general protections claim in what was then the Federal Circuit Court. The general protections are the parts of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) that protect workers from being punished for having a workplace right, or for taking part in union activity or staying out of it. His pleaded case was that he was dismissed for complaining about the accident to WorkSafe and to a union safety hotline. That claim failed. The court accepted that the foreman did not know of those particular complaints, although it found Mr Tyson was dismissed predominantly because he was causing trouble with the union. The dismissal had not been pleaded that way.

The coercion claim succeeded. In December 2019 Judge Vasta declared that the employer had contravened s 348 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). Heiko appealed, arguing that the case had not been pleaded under that section. In November 2020 a majority of the Full Federal Court rejected that argument, with Justice Griffiths dissenting, and only reworded the declaration. Heiko then abandoned a bid to go to the High Court.

Section 348 says a person must not take, or threaten to take, action against another person with intent to coerce them to engage in industrial activity. Judge Vasta held that ending union membership is an industrial activity rather than a workplace right, so s 348, not s 343, was the right section.

The judge found a clear threat. Calm or not, the message was that refusing to pay meant losing a well-paid job. Repeating that the EBA paid his wage, when it did not even cover him, was illegitimate and unconscionable pressure, and there is no lawful requirement to be a union member to work on an EBA site.

Under s 361 the employer then had to prove the foreman did not intend to coerce. The foreman said he only wanted to hear Mr Tyson's concerns and remind him it was his choice. After listening to the recording several times, the judge did not accept that he was truthful, so the employer failed to discharge the onus. Because the foreman ran all of Heiko's workers on site, his actions were the employer's actions.

How much was awarded

On 5 November 2021 the judge put the contravention in the worst category. The maximum was $63,000. Heiko had shown some cooperation and had no prior contraventions, but it showed no contrition, and the judge allowed only a nominal discount. The penalty was $60,000, ordered paid to Mr Tyson under s 546(3).

Compensation under s 545(2)(b) covers loss suffered because of the contravention. Mr Tyson said he felt violated. The judge was satisfied he would have felt crushed, and helpless: in the judge's words, it was "David versus Goliath who was tag-teaming with Leviathan". He awarded $7,000. Lost wages were refused: the threat itself did not cost him his job, and the case had not been run on the basis that he was sacked for refusing to rejoin.

What this means for you

Whether to join or rejoin a union is your choice, and an employer, a supervisor or a union official who threatens your job or pay to change your mind may be breaking the law. Keep notes of what was said, and when. If the pressure ends in dismissal, a general protections dismissal claim must be lodged with the Fair Work Commission within 21 days, and it is worth getting advice early so that every reason you believe was behind it is put to the Commission.

The takeaway

A threat does not have to be shouted to be unlawful. Here, telling a worker that refusing to pay union dues meant a worse-paid job elsewhere was found to be coercion under s 348, and the penalty can go to the worker.

Note: Rewritten 21 October 2026 from the judgments. The old article said the worker was dismissed for refusing to join the union; the court did not award anything for the dismissal, and the $7,000 was for distress caused by the threat. The liability decision is Tyson v Heiko Constructions [2019] FCCA 3643, varied in wording only on appeal in Heiko Constructions v Tyson [2020] FCAFC 208. Section 348 has not changed since. Maximum civil penalties under the Fair Work Act are set in penalty units, and the value of a penalty unit has risen since 2018, so the maximum today is higher than the $63,000 that applied here.

$60,000 penalty ordered paid to him, plus $7,000 compensationGeneral protectionsPenaltiesCompensation

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) · 5 November 2021

Tyson v Heiko Constructions trading as Heiko Constructions Pty Ltd [2021] FedCFamC2G 212, Judge Vasta. Read the full decision

This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.

Does this sound like your situation?

More case studies