Called a contractor but treated like staff? Sham contracting explained

Type
Guide
Topic
Problems at Work
First published
18 November 2016
Illustrative image.

Sham contracting is when an employer tells a worker they are an independent contractor when in law they are an employee. The Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) prohibits it, and since 2024 the question of who is an employee turns on how the relationship really works in practice, not just on what the contract says.

Key points

  • Sections 357 to 359 of the Fair Work Act prohibit misrepresenting employment as contracting, sacking an employee to re-engage them as a contractor, and knowingly false statements to push an employee into a contract for services.
  • Since 26 August 2024, s 15AA says whether someone is an employee depends on the real substance, practical reality and true nature of the whole relationship, including how the contract is performed in practice.
  • Since 27 February 2024 an employer has a defence only if it proves it reasonably believed the contract was a contract for services, judged partly by the size and nature of its business.
  • A worker found to be an employee can claim unpaid wages and entitlements, and the business and its directors can face civil penalties.

What sham contracting is

People can work for a business in two ways. An employee works in the employer's business and has the protections of workplace law: minimum award wages, paid leave, superannuation, notice and, in many cases, protection from unfair dismissal. An independent contractor runs a business of their own and has few of those protections.

Because contractors usually cost less, some businesses label workers as contractors when they are really employees. That is called sham contracting. A worker who was treated as a contractor but is found to be an employee can claim the wages and entitlements they missed out on, and the business can face penalties.

What the Fair Work Act prohibits

Three sections of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) deal with sham arrangements. Each is a civil remedy provision, meaning a court can order penalties for breaching it.

Section 357 says an employer that employs, or proposes to employ, someone must not tell them that their contract of employment is a contract for services under which they work as an independent contractor. Section 358 says an employer must not dismiss, or threaten to dismiss, an employee in order to engage them as an independent contractor doing the same, or substantially the same, work. Section 359 says an employer must not make a statement it knows is false to persuade a current or former employee to sign up as a contractor for the same, or substantially the same, work.

There is one defence to s 357. Since 27 February 2024 the employer must prove that, when it made the representation, it reasonably believed the contract was a contract for services. In deciding whether the belief was reasonable, a court must consider the size and nature of the employer's business. Before that date the employer only had to prove it did not know, and was not reckless about, the true position.

How the law decides who is an employee

Calling a worker a contractor has never settled the question on its own. In 2022 the High Court held in CFMMEU v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 1 that, where there is a written contract that is not itself a sham, the answer comes mainly from the rights and obligations in that contract rather than from how the work is actually done.

Parliament changed that for the Fair Work Act. Since 26 August 2024, s 15AA says the question is answered by ascertaining the real substance, practical reality and true nature of the relationship. The whole relationship must be considered, including the contract terms and how the contract is performed in practice.

The factors courts have long looked at remain useful guides, and no single one decides the case. They include:

(a) who controls how, when and where the work is done;

(b) whether the worker is part of the business or runs a business of their own;

(c) whether the work is ongoing or for a specific task or result;

(d) who supplies the tools, equipment or vehicle;

(e) who bears the risk of profit or loss, and whether the worker can delegate or subcontract the work; and

(f) how the worker is paid: by the hour or week, or by invoice for a result.

A worker earning above the contractor high income threshold can, in some cases, opt out of s 15AA by notice (s 15AB). In the WA state system, the Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) has had a similar real substance test since 31 January 2025 (ss 7A and 7B).

An example: a cleaner told to get an ABN

In Fair Work Ombudsman v Jooine (Investment) Pty Ltd & Anor [2013] FCCA 2144, a cleaning company engaged a part-time cleaner for offices in Northbridge, New South Wales. He was in Australia on a working holiday visa. The company told him he was a contractor and required him to apply for an Australian Business Number (ABN). But the company supplied his cleaning products and a uniform bearing its name, and its director inspected his work and told him what to redo. It paid him $12.50 an hour when the award rate was $19.65.

The company and its sole director admitted the contraventions. Judge Lloyd-Jones described the arrangement as a deliberate attempt to avoid the protective provisions of the Act. On 20 December 2013 the Court ordered the company to pay the cleaner the $1,858.53 he was owed, and to pay penalties of $47,520, including $23,760 for the sham contracting. The director was ordered to pay penalties of $9,504.

What this means for you

If you are paid as a contractor but the business sets your hours, tells you how to do the work, supplies the equipment and pays you like staff, you may be an employee. Keep your own records of the hours you work and what you were told when you started, and consider getting advice early: underpayment claims have time limits, and many entitlements depend on your status.

If you run a business, review how each contractor arrangement works day to day, not just what the contract says. A written agreement and an ABN will not protect an arrangement that is employment in substance, and directors and others involved in a contravention can be penalised personally.

The takeaway

Calling someone a contractor does not make them one. Since August 2024 the Fair Work Act looks at how the working relationship really operates, and a business that gets it wrong can owe back pay and penalties.

Note: Rewritten 21 October 2026. The 2016 article described the old law. Since 27 February 2024 the s 357 defence requires the employer to prove a reasonable belief that the contract was a contract for services, having regard to the size and nature of its business (s 357(2)–(3)); before then it was enough to prove it did not know and was not reckless. In 2022 the High Court (Personnel Contracting [2022] HCA 1; ZG Operations v Jamsek [2022] HCA 2) made a genuine written contract the main guide; Parliament reversed that for the Fair Work Act from 26 August 2024 with s 15AA, which looks at the real substance and practical reality of the whole relationship, including how the contract is performed. WA state system employers have had ss 7A and 7B of the Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) since 31 January 2025. Maximum civil penalties have also risen since 2016. The old article misspelled the case name as 'Joonie'; it is Jooine.

General information about the law as it stands, not legal advice. Every situation turns on its own facts. First published 18 November 2016; updated 21 October 2026.

Does this sound like your situation?

More case studies