Childcare educator sacked for refusing a free flu shot
Ms Bou-Jamie Barber v Goodstart Early Learning [2021] FWC 2156
- Decided by
- Fair Work Commission
- Date
- 20 April 2021
- Outcome
- Claim dismissed
- Result
- Employer succeeded

A long-serving childcare educator in Queensland was dismissed after she refused the flu vaccine her employer made compulsory in 2020 and could not get a doctor to support a medical exemption. The Fair Work Commission found the vaccination rule was a lawful and reasonable direction, and that refusing to follow it was a valid reason for dismissal. Her unfair dismissal claim was dismissed.
Key points
- An employee must follow an employer's lawful and reasonable directions, and refusing to can be a valid reason for dismissal.
- A direction is reasonable if a reasonable employer in the same position could have adopted it, even if a better policy was possible.
- Where a policy allows a medical exemption, it is up to the employee to produce real medical evidence that supports one.
- The Commission found the vaccination was not an inherent requirement of the job, but the dismissal was still fair because of her conduct.
What happened
Ms Barber had worked for Goodstart and its predecessor since December 2006, most recently as a Lead Educator at a Goodstart Early Learning centre in Gladstone, Queensland. Goodstart is a not-for-profit with about 17,500 staff and 671 centres across Australia.
On 17 April 2020, early in the COVID-19 pandemic, Goodstart decided that all staff had to be vaccinated against the flu unless they had a medical condition that made it unsafe. The vaccine was free, and Goodstart offered to cover the cost of a doctor's visit to support an exemption.
Ms Barber objected. She has coeliac disease, described a sensitive immune system, and said she had reacted to a flu vaccine about 11 years earlier. She gave Goodstart two medical certificates. The first described her immune condition and said she reported reacting badly to a flu vaccine. The second, from a different doctor, said she reported an allergic reaction but the surgery had no record of it. Goodstart supplied a form for a doctor to complete, but no doctor would sign it.
The show cause process and the dismissal
Over about four months Goodstart wrote to her, met with her and extended its deadlines. In July 2020 it told her that her objection had not been accepted and asked her to show cause why her employment should not end. In her reply she said she had provided all the information she could.
Goodstart dismissed her on 13 August 2020, with four weeks' pay in lieu of notice. The termination letter said she did not meet an inherent requirement of her role: being vaccinated against the flu. She applied to the Fair Work Commission for an unfair dismissal remedy and asked to be reinstated.
The legal test
Under s 385 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), a dismissal is unfair if, among other things, it was harsh, unjust or unreasonable. Section 387 lists what the Commission must consider, starting with whether there was a valid reason related to the worker's capacity (their ability to do the job) or their conduct.
Employees have a duty to obey any lawful and reasonable direction. A direction is lawful if it relates to the job and involves nothing illegal. It is reasonable if a reasonable employer in the same position could have adopted it. The question is not whether a better policy existed.
What the Commission decided
Deputy President Lake found the policy reasonable. Goodstart had safety duties to its staff and to the children in its care. Children and educators are in close contact for up to 12 hours a day, social distancing is impractical, and babies under six months cannot be vaccinated. On the expert evidence the vaccine was on average about 40% to 60% effective, and 29% in its worst year, which still reduced the risk. The policy allowed medical exemptions, Goodstart paid the costs, and it gave Ms Barber extra time.
The policy was also lawful. It fell within the scope of her employment. Her argument that a vaccination rule amounted to assault or battery failed: she was never vaccinated, and the idea that Goodstart would force a vaccine on her was "fanciful".
Ms Barber had not shown a valid medical exemption. Her reaction was unrecorded and was not anaphylaxis, and several doctors had declined to say the vaccine was unsafe for her. Over one hundred other Goodstart employees had exemptions accepted. The Commission also rejected her claim that she had been treated differently from others, accepting that Goodstart applied its process evenly to all employees.
Conduct, not capacity
The Commission did not accept Goodstart's reason. Being vaccinated did not change Ms Barber's ability to do the work, and a policy cannot create an inherent requirement artificially. If the requirement were removed, the role would be essentially the same. So there was no valid reason based on capacity.
But s 387(a) covers conduct too. Refusing a lawful and reasonable direction was a valid reason based on her conduct. Because the dispute had always been about the medical exemption, her answers would have been the same either way, so she still had a fair chance to respond. The Deputy President described her as an exemplary, long-serving employee, but found the dismissal was not unfair and dismissed the application.
What this means for you
If your employer brings in a health or safety rule you disagree with, refusing to comply is risky. The test is whether a reasonable employer could adopt the rule, not whether you think it is the best one. If the rule allows exemptions, get clear evidence from your doctor early.
The Commission stressed that the decision was about the flu vaccine in childcare, and that applying it to other industries would be "audacious". If you are dismissed, the time limit for a Fair Work unfair dismissal claim is 21 days.
The takeaway
An employee who refuses a lawful and reasonable workplace health direction, without evidence for an exemption, risks a fair dismissal. Even an employer that gives the wrong label for the reason can still win if the facts show a valid one.
Note: We found no appeal from this decision. It was decided before COVID-19 vaccine mandates were common; the public health orders of that period have since been lifted, and each case on a vaccination rule turns on its own workplace. The unfair dismissal test in s 387 still applies. For dismissals from 1 July 2026, the high income threshold is $190,100 and the compensation cap is $95,050.
Fair Work Commission · 20 April 2021
Ms Bou-Jamie Barber v Goodstart Early Learning [2021] FWC 2156, Deputy President Lake. Read the full decision
This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.
Does this sound like your situation?
More case studies

Fair Work Commission · 29 March 2021
The mine said his job had gone, but nobody proved it
Peter Guinea v Workpac Pty Ltd
A labour hire haul truck operator at a Queensland coal mine was told the mine no longer needed him and was made redundant during the COVID-19 border closures. The Fair Work Commission found the labour hire company had not proved the job was really gone and had not consulted him as its enterprise agreement required, so the dismissal was unfair. Because the border would have kept him from working for most of the period, compensation was small.
$1,928.06 compensationTermination#redundancy#unfair dismissal#compensation
Read the case study
Fair Work Commission · 26 April 2021
Sacked for recommending a rival swim school on Facebook
Jasmine Besanko v R.B. Aquatics Pty Ltd T/A Swimmers
A 19-year-old casual swim instructor answered a community Facebook post by recommending a rival swim school, where she also worked. Her employer of three years dismissed her on the spot for disloyalty. The Fair Work Commission found the dismissal unfair, but awarded no compensation because she had lost no earnings.
Unfairly dismissed, but no compensationTermination#unfair dismissal#social media#small business
Read the case study
Fair Work Commission · 19 March 2021
Mushroom picker sacked over a knife on the wrong hook
Helen Robertson v Imperial Mushrooms Pty Ltd
A mushroom picker with almost 15 years' service hung her harvesting knife on the wrong hook at the end of a shift. Her employer called it serious misconduct and handed her a pre-prepared dismissal letter. The Fair Work Commission found it was an unintended mistake, not serious misconduct, and awarded her $19,240.
$19,240 compensationTermination#unfair dismissal#misconduct#procedural fairness
Read the case study