Told to wait for a wage subsidy, then told to resign

Crystelle Fakhri v MVS Business Partners Pty Ltd [2021] FWC 4965

Decided by
Fair Work Commission
Date
12 August 2021
Outcome
Found forced to resign; employer's objection dismissed
Result
Employee succeeded
Illustrative image. It does not show the people in this case.

After five weeks of work in a new job, a worker said she had still not been paid. Her employer said it was waiting on a government wage subsidy and, when she pressed, told her to resign. The Fair Work Commission found her resignation was forced, and said the subsidy had nothing to do with her right to be paid.

Key points

  • An employer's wait for a government wage subsidy was no reason to hold back wages: the contract was not subject to the subsidy.
  • Answering a worker's request for her pay by telling her to resign turned her resignation into a dismissal under s 386(1)(b) of the Fair Work Act.
  • An employer that says a worker simply resigned still has to explain the emails that led to the resignation; chaotic and irrelevant material did not do that.
  • For applications made from 7 July 2026, the Commission no longer has to decide a 'she resigned' objection before dealing with a general protections dismissal dispute.

What happened

Crystelle Fakhri worked for MVS Business Partners Pty Ltd, looking after its website and social media. In her emails she said her contract provided for pay every fortnight, for 50 hours of work a fortnight.

On 12 April 2021 the company gave her a Jobs Victoria Fund Employee Consent Form, so that it could apply for a government wage subsidy. Ms Fakhri said no one ever told her that her employment depended on that subsidy being approved.

By mid-May, she said, she had not been paid. She texted about it on 14 May 2021, then emailed on 18 May: she had not been paid for five weeks of work, her contract promised fortnightly pay, and she asked to be paid that week.

The replies that led to her resignation

The managing director answered the same day that pay was "not within my control as wage subsidy is controlled by government". She reminded Ms Fakhri that she was on probation, promised payment on 21 May, and added that if that was not enough, she could resign "as there is not enough paid work for you".

Ms Fakhri replied that the tone was disrespectful and that a subsidy was no excuse for not paying wages. She asked for payment of 98 hours by 21 May 2021. The next email began: "Please resign, your probation time is expired, we won’t put up with this at all". Another called her demands "highly explosive", said these were not normal times because of COVID-19, and questioned whether a side business of hers was legal.

Ms Fakhri resigned, effective immediately, saying she had been forced to.

The claim and the objection

On 29 May 2021 she applied to the Commission under s 365 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). That is a general protections claim: she said she was pushed out because she had raised her right to be paid, which is a workplace right the Act protects.

The company objected that she had resigned and so was never dismissed. Under the Full Federal Court's decision in Coles Supply Chain Pty Ltd v Milford, the Commission then had to decide that question first. The managing director said she was too unwell to attend a hearing, and both sides agreed to the objection being decided on the papers.

Under s 386(1) a person is dismissed if the employer ends the job, or if the person resigns but "was forced to do so" because of the employer's conduct. A resignation of that second kind is often called a constructive dismissal, or forced resignation.

The Commission applied the test from Mohazab v Dick Smith Electronics Pty Ltd (No 2): did the employer's action result, directly or as a consequence, in the job ending, so that the worker did not leave voluntarily? It also weighs the circumstances, how serious the issues were, and how each side behaved.

What the Commission decided

Deputy President Hamilton dismissed the objection on 12 August 2021. Ms Fakhri had made "a legitimate request for payment of entitlements", and the company replied by suggesting she resign unless she accepted not being paid. He found she resigned but was forced to do so by her employer's conduct.

On the subsidy he was blunt. The contract of employment "was not subject to employer receipt of a subsidy", and the company had to pay her as the contract required.

The company's own material did not help it. The Deputy President called it "largely chaotic and irrelevant". It first suggested Ms Fakhri had been stood down, then quoted the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code on summary dismissal, then said she had resigned. One email to her he described as threatening, even abusive. Nor did its submission that it could reasonably decline to pay the 50 hours at $30.00 an hour she claimed, rather than $19.38 as a junior; that, he said, if anything supported her case.

What happened next, and the law now

Because the company said it would not take part in a conciliation conference, the Deputy President said he would issue a certificate under s 368, the step that allows the claim to go to court. No later decision in the case has been found.

From 7 July 2026, for an application made from that date, the Commission can deal with a general protections dismissal dispute where a dismissal is alleged, without first deciding an objection like this one. Whether there was a dismissal must still be proved if the claim goes to court, and the s 386 test for a forced resignation has not changed.

What this means for you

If your employer is waiting on a grant, a subsidy or a client's payment, your wages are still owed for the work you have done. Being on probation does not change that, and asking to be paid is a legitimate request.

If you are told to resign because you asked about your pay, keep every message and consider getting advice before you quit. A general protections dismissal application must be made within 21 days of the dismissal.

The takeaway

An employer's cash flow, including a wage subsidy that has not arrived, does not suspend the duty to pay wages, and telling a worker to resign for asking can make her resignation a dismissal.

Note: This decision settled only whether Ms Fakhri was dismissed; the Commission said it would issue a certificate under s 368, and no later decision has been found, so the final outcome is not known. The law has moved since 2021: from 7 July 2026, for a general protections application made from that date, the Commission can deal with the dispute on an alleged dismissal and need not first decide whether there was a dismissal (the Milford approach applied in this case). The forced resignation test in s 386(1)(b) is unchanged. Section 323 of the Fair Work Act still requires wages to be paid in full at least monthly, and since 1 January 2025 intentional underpayment of wages can be a criminal offence.

Found forced to resign; employer's objection dismissedForced resignationGeneral protectionsUnderpayment

Fair Work Commission · 12 August 2021

Crystelle Fakhri v MVS Business Partners Pty Ltd [2021] FWC 4965, Deputy President Hamilton. Read the full decision

This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.

Does this sound like your situation?

More case studies