She raised a real concern, then lost her job over how she argued it
Tiffany Stodart v The Employer [2022] FWC 277
- Decided by
- Fair Work Commission
- Date
- 4 March 2022
- Outcome
- Claim dismissed; permission to appeal refused
- Result
- Employer succeeded

A supermarket supervisor in suburban Adelaide found out a co-worker had an old conviction and asked her employer to remove him. When it would not, she insulted two managers and a group of co-workers, was given a first and final warning, and was dismissed after a further outburst on the shop floor. The Fair Work Commission found a valid reason for the dismissal, and a Full Bench refused her permission to appeal.
Key points
- Disagreeing with an employer’s decision, even strongly, is not misconduct. Expressing that disagreement in an insulting or insubordinate way can be.
- An earlier warning does not wipe out the conduct it was given for. The Commission can weigh that conduct when deciding whether there was a valid reason for a later dismissal.
- A less serious incident that would not justify dismissal on its own can still trigger a fair dismissal when it repeats behaviour covered by a recent first and final warning.
- Apologising helps, but its weight falls away if the same kind of behaviour happens again.
What happened
Tiffany Stodart started with a supermarket business in suburban Adelaide in October 2017 as a check-out operator. Within a few weeks she was a customer service supervisor. She was contracted for at least 25 hours a week but, keen to use her skills, usually worked about 35. The Commission accepted she was generally respected by staff and managers.
In July 2021 she searched a co-worker’s name online and found a media report that he had been convicted of an historic sex offence and, after serving time, released. She told management. The employer took legal advice and, on 8 July 2021, told her there were no grounds to act against him simply because of his past conviction. It asked for details of any workplace conduct or the names of staff who felt uncomfortable so it could investigate. The Commission found she gave none.
The roster meetings
At her request, she was rostered away from the front of the store when he was working. That frustrated her. At a meeting on 9 August 2021 she was offered a transfer to another store, which she did not want. As she left, she walked back into the room and told a senior human resources manager she was not doing a very good job.
At a second meeting on 23 August 2021 she was told her permanent roster: one day in variety, two on the front end and two in the online department. She saw online work as a demotion and said it was something for monkeys. When the store manager said online staff would not appreciate that, she repeated it about the people who worked there. She then told her supervisor she was a "shit front-end manager" who did nothing all day.
Two days later she texted an apology for her "atrocious behaviour". The employer still held a disciplinary meeting and, on 30 August 2021, gave her a first and final warning. The decision-maker said she chose a warning over dismissal because of the stress Ms Stodart was under.
The final incident and the dismissal
On 27 September 2021, after being told to take a required break during a busy online shift, she raised her voice and waved her arms on the shop floor, near customers, complaining that lunch had been a waste of time because of the orders still to pick. She kept going after her manager asked her to calm down. After a further meeting at which she was invited to respond, she was dismissed on 30 September 2021 with four weeks’ pay in lieu of notice. She applied for an unfair dismissal remedy.
Why: the legal test
Under s 387 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), the Commission decides whether a dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable by weighing a list of factors. The first is whether there was a valid reason related to the worker’s conduct, meaning a reason that is sound, defensible and well-founded on the facts the Commission itself finds, not just on what the employer believed. Others include whether the worker was told the reason and could respond, and any other relevant matter.
Deputy President Anderson drew a clear line. It is not misconduct to disagree with an employer’s response to a workplace issue, even one reasonably made. Ms Stodart had raised a genuine concern in good faith, and describing the co-worker as she did in a closed meeting about that concern was not misconduct. The question was whether she showed her disagreement in a way that was insubordinate or breached her duties.
The Commission found that she did. The remark to the senior manager was insubordinate; the abuse of her supervisor was misconduct at the higher end of the scale; repeating the monkeys comment after being cautioned was insubordinate. It did not accept one further allegation, a swear word reported only second-hand, because it was not proved. The shop-floor outburst was misconduct at the moderate end of the scale: on its own it would have warranted counselling, not dismissal.
Her lawyers argued that the conduct already dealt with by the warning could not be counted again. The Commission disagreed. A warning does not erase the conduct behind it, and taking it into account is not punishing twice. It would be perverse, the Deputy President said, if an employer that gave a second chance were worse off for doing so. Taken together, the incidents showed a pattern that gave a valid reason for dismissal. The process was fair, and her apologies carried less weight because the same behaviour followed them.
What happened next
Ms Stodart sought to appeal. On 2 June 2022 a Full Bench refused permission to appeal, finding the Deputy President had applied orthodox principles and was entitled to look at her conduct as a whole rather than only the final incident ([2022] FWCFB 88).
What this means for you
If you have raised a concern at work and you are unhappy with the answer, you are entitled to keep disagreeing and to use the complaint processes available to you. What puts your job at risk is how you show that disagreement: insults, outbursts in front of customers or co-workers, and repeating a remark after being told it is inappropriate.
If you are on a first and final warning, even a smaller incident can be enough. If you have been dismissed, a Fair Work unfair dismissal claim must be lodged within 21 days, so it is worth getting advice early.
The takeaway
Disagreeing with your employer is not misconduct, but insulting managers and co-workers about it can be. A recent first and final warning means a later, smaller incident can be enough to justify dismissal.
Note: Permission to appeal was refused by a Full Bench on 2 June 2022 ([2022] FWCFB 88). The parts of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) applied here, including s 387 and the 21-day time limit in s 394, have not changed in a way that affects this result. The employer’s name was withheld by a confidentiality order, and parts of the published decision are redacted.
Fair Work Commission · 4 March 2022
Tiffany Stodart v The Employer [2022] FWC 277, Deputy President Anderson. Read the full decision
This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.
Does this sound like your situation?
More case studies

Industrial Relations Commission of New South Wales · 25 February 2022
Officer removed for harassing a colleague: autism report not enough
Mounce-Stephens v Commissioner of Police
A senior constable who had already been demoted for sexual harassment kept asking a female colleague out during one shift, asked to message her and made a remark about a mattress. He was removed from the NSW Police Force. The Industrial Relations Commission upheld the removal, finding a psychiatrist's report of mild autism did not show the condition caused his conduct.
Removal upheld, application dismissedTermination#misconduct#sexual harassment#disability
Read the case study
Industrial Relations Commission of New South Wales · 10 March 2022
Sacked over a Hitler meme of the Premier, but still compensated
Lichi v Industrial Relations Secretary on behalf of Department of Communities and Justice
A NSW child protection caseworker was dismissed after attending an anti-lockdown rally in breach of a public health order and sharing a Facebook image of the Premier with a Hitler moustache. The Commission found a valid reason and a fair process, but held the dismissal harsh given her personal circumstances, and ordered 12 weeks’ pay.
12 weeks’ pay compensationTermination#unfair dismissal#social media#public sector
Read the case study
Fair Work Commission · 22 February 2022
1,260 personal texts at work, and the dismissal was fair
Lynda Murphy v Clear Day Pty Ltd
A safety manager on $48 an hour ran a growing farm stay business from her desk, sending hundreds of texts during work hours. After a firm verbal warning to switch her phone off, she carried on, and was dismissed without being asked for her side. The Fair Work Commission found valid reasons and held the dismissal was not unfair, despite the flaws in the process.
Claim dismissedTermination#unfair dismissal#misconduct#procedural fairness
Read the case study