Sacked for a resume that stretched one job by four years

Charles Tham v Hertz Australia Pty Limited T/A Hertz [2018] FWC 3967

Decided by
Fair Work Commission
Date
4 July 2018
Outcome
Claim dismissed
Result
Employer succeeded
Illustrative image. It does not show the people in this case.

A Hertz vehicle services attendant was dismissed after the company found his resume claimed five years with a former employer when he had worked there for less than one. The Fair Work Commission found the false dates were deliberate, gave Hertz a valid reason, and outweighed the company's rushed process. A Full Bench refused him permission to appeal.

Key points

  • Deliberately false information in a job application can be a valid reason for dismissal, even when it is found months after the worker starts.
  • The Commission rejected the worker's claim that the false dates were typing mistakes once cross-examination showed half a dozen other errors.
  • Hertz did not give him a fair chance to respond, and the Commission counted that against it, but the seriousness of the dishonesty outweighed it.
  • A Full Bench of the Commission refused permission to appeal on 25 September 2018.

What happened

In September 2016 Charles Tham applied for a customer service job with Hertz in Victoria. His resume said he had worked for Conrock as a quality control checker from August 2010 to September 2015. Hertz hired him as a vehicle services attendant, the person who takes back the cars customers return, and he started on 25 November 2016.

Before he started he signed an acknowledgement, and later a second one, that providing false information or withholding information relevant to his application could lead to the withdrawal of the job offer or to termination.

The relationship soon became strained. Mr Tham made a workers' compensation claim for a shoulder injury and, over the following months, complaints to WorkSafe, Victoria's equal opportunity commission and, Hertz said, the Fair Work Ombudsman. In June 2017 he received a first written warning about his conduct. Hertz's senior human resources business partner, concerned about his character, then checked what he had said when he applied: she contacted former employers, tried to verify his degree and searched Google.

The search turned up an unfair dismissal claim he had brought against Conrock in 2011, after being dismissed on 1 June 2011. He had worked at Conrock from August 2010 to June 2011, not until September 2015.

The dismissal

On 24 August 2017 Hertz gave Mr Tham a letter alleging serious misconduct and told him to attend a meeting at 10am the next day. He said he needed more time. Hertz suspended him without pay. He did not attend the meeting, later explaining that he was anxious and could not arrange a support person and an interpreter in time. That afternoon he sent medical certificates to his manager at 1:49pm. At 2:02pm Hertz emailed him a termination letter.

Mr Tham applied to the Fair Work Commission for an unfair dismissal remedy. He said he had told Hertz about the "mistake" before he started, by phoning a manager and raising it at his interview, and that dismissal was out of proportion. Hertz said he had lied to avoid questions about a four-year gap in his work history.

Under s 387 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), the Commission decides whether a dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable by weighing a list of factors. The first is whether there was a valid reason related to the worker's conduct or capacity: a reason that is "sound, defensible and well-founded". The Commission does not stand in the employer's shoes; it checks that the reason really existed. It must also consider whether the worker was told the reason and given a chance to respond, whether a support person was unreasonably refused, the employer's size and HR resources, and any other relevant matter.

What the Commission decided

Commissioner Harper-Greenwell did not find Mr Tham a credible witness, and preferred Hertz's witnesses wherever their accounts conflicted. Under cross-examination he accepted further "mistakes" in his resume, including a "big mistake" in the dates of another job. An application he had made to a different employer gave a significantly different work history for the same years.

The Commissioner asked why, if he had really owned up before starting, he had disclosed only the one error Hertz later relied on and not the other "half a dozen or so". She found the errors were not inadvertent: he had altered the dates to suggest a history of stable, long-term work. A vehicle services attendant is the point of contact for returned cars, where customers may leave valuables, so Hertz relied on his honesty. That gave Hertz a valid reason.

The process was another matter. The Commissioner accepted that 24 hours' notice of the meeting was enough, and that he could have arranged a support person. But she found Hertz had not given him a sufficient opportunity to respond: it acted hastily when he did not turn up, and reasonable enquiries would probably have revealed his medical certificates. Because Hertz is a large company with HR specialists, she made no allowance for that.

Weighing everything, she found nothing Mr Tham had said would have changed the outcome, and that the gravity of the deliberate dishonesty was fundamentally inconsistent with continuing the employment. The dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable, and the claim was dismissed.

The appeal

In Tham v Hertz Australia Pty Limited [2018] FWCFB 5972, decided on 25 September 2018, a Full Bench found that the Commissioner's findings, based on her view of the witnesses' credibility, were open to her and that she had weighed the procedural failings against the misconduct in the usual way. Permission to appeal was refused.

What this means for you

If you are applying for a job, a deliberately false date or job title can cost you the job long after you start, and an explanation that it was a typing error will be tested against everything else you have written. If your resume is wrong, correct it in writing early.

If you are an employer, this case shows that dishonesty in recruitment can justify dismissal, but it is not a licence to skip the process. Hertz was criticised for rushing, and with less serious conduct that criticism could have tipped the result. The Commissioner also noted that workers are entitled to pursue their legal rights against employers, and considered Mr Tham's past claims only for what they revealed about his work history. A worker who wants to challenge a dismissal in the Fair Work Commission has only 21 days to apply.

The takeaway

A deliberate lie in a job application can be a valid reason for dismissal even when found months later, but the employer must still give the worker a fair chance to answer it.

Note: A Full Bench refused permission to appeal in [2018] FWCFB 5972 (25 September 2018). The s 387 factors and the 21-day time limit for unfair dismissal applications are unchanged since this decision.

Fair Work Commission · 4 July 2018

Charles Tham v Hertz Australia Pty Limited T/A Hertz [2018] FWC 3967, Commissioner Harper-Greenwell. Read the full decision

This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.

Does this sound like your situation?

More case studies