Bank executive's $317,500 win cut to four weeks' pay

Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Barker [2014] HCA 32

Decided by
High Court of Australia
Date
10 September 2014
Outcome
$11,692.31 (four weeks' pay) instead of $317,500
Result
Employer succeeded
A senior bank manager leaves his keys and work phone on an emptied desk, a packing box at his feet.
Illustrative image. It does not show the people in this case.

A Commonwealth Bank executive of 27 years was made redundant, then cut off from the email and phone the Bank used to offer him redeployment. Two courts awarded him $317,500 for breach of an implied duty of mutual trust and confidence. In 2014 the High Court held that no such duty exists in Australian employment contracts, and he was left with four weeks' pay.

Key points

  • Australian employment contracts do not contain an implied term of mutual trust and confidence.
  • A court will imply a term only where it is necessary, not merely because it would be fair or reasonable.
  • The High Court said whether to create such a broad duty is a question for Parliament, which already regulates dismissal, discrimination and safety.
  • Mr Barker kept only the damages the Bank conceded for ending his job without the four weeks' notice his contract required.

What happened

Stephen Barker joined the Commonwealth Bank in November 1981. By 2009 he was a senior executive in Adelaide, Executive Manager Adelaide Corporate Banking, employed under a written agreement that let either side end the job on four weeks' written notice.

The agreement also dealt with redundancy. If his position became redundant and the Bank was unable to place him in an alternative position in keeping with his skills and experience, it would pay him a set amount of compensation.

On 2 March 2009 two managers told Mr Barker that his position was being made redundant as part of a national restructure, and that it had nothing to do with his performance. They said the Bank would prefer to redeploy him, but if that did not happen his employment would end in about four weeks. He was told to clear his desk, hand in his keys and mobile phone, and not come back. His access to his work email, voicemail and the intranet was cut off the same day.

Cut off from the redeployment process

The Bank then tried to contact him about redeployment through the channels it had just switched off. An email from human resources urging him to look for other roles went to his work address, and he did not see it until it reached his personal email around 23 March. The career support officer responsible for helping him never spoke to him during the redeployment period.

On 26 March he was sent the description of one possible role, but the High Court noted it was unlikely an application by him would have succeeded. On 9 April 2009 the Bank ended his employment for redundancy. His retrenchment payments came to $182,092.16.

The claim

As a senior executive Mr Barker earned too much to bring an unfair dismissal claim, so he sued the Bank in the Federal Court for breach of contract. His main argument relied on an implied term. An implied term is a promise that forms part of a contract even though nobody wrote it down or discussed it.

The term he relied on was mutual trust and confidence: that neither employer nor employee will, without reasonable cause, act in a way likely to destroy or seriously damage the relationship of trust between them. English courts had recognised that term in every employment contract. Mr Barker said the Bank broke it by botching his redeployment, and that he lost the chance to keep his job.

He won at trial. Justice Besanko accepted that the term existed and had been breached, and assessed his damages at $317,500. A majority of the Full Federal Court agreed that the term existed, although for slightly different reasons, and upheld the award. The Bank appealed to the High Court.

What the High Court decided

On 10 September 2014 the High Court unanimously allowed the Bank's appeal. Its answer to the central question was no: Australian law does not put an implied term of mutual trust and confidence into every employment contract.

That left Mr Barker with one thing he had already established. The Bank had conceded that it ended his employment without the four weeks' notice his contract required, so judgment was entered for him for $11,692.31 plus interest instead of $317,500. As it had undertaken when seeking leave to appeal, the Bank was ordered to pay his costs of the High Court appeal.

Courts imply terms in two ways. A term implied in fact fills a gap in one particular contract, where it is needed to make that contract work. A term implied in law is attached to every contract of a certain kind, such as every employment contract. Either way the test is necessity, not fairness: as the joint judgment put it, terms that might be thought reasonable are not necessary for that reason alone.

The Court found that a duty of mutual trust and confidence is not necessary for employment contracts to operate effectively. The duty was also broad and uncertain, and it would bind employees as well as employers. Deciding whether to create it involved complex policy choices that the Court said were more appropriate for Parliament than for judges, especially as unfair dismissal, anti-discrimination and workplace safety laws already regulate the relationship.

Mr Barker's fallback argument also failed. He could point to nothing in his own agreement that made the term necessary in fact. Justice Kiefel added that the agreement already dealt with redeployment in its redundancy clause, but his case had never been run as a claim for breach of that clause.

What this means for you

Barker is still the leading authority, and it has not been overturned. A worker cannot sue simply because an employer treated them in a way that destroyed trust. A contract claim has to rest on something the contract actually says, or a duty the law already recognises, such as the employer's duty to provide a safe system of work or the duty to cooperate so the other side gets what the contract promises.

The written terms therefore matter, especially for senior staff who earn above the high income threshold ($190,100 for dismissals from 1 July 2026) and cannot claim unfair dismissal unless an award or enterprise agreement covers them. If redundancy, redeployment or notice is spelt out in your contract, or in a policy that forms part of it, a claim should be built on those terms. Read your contract before you sign it, and get advice early if your role is made redundant.

The takeaway

Your employment contract means what it says: courts will not add a general duty of fair treatment to it. If a redundancy or redeployment promise matters to you, make sure it is written into your contract.

Note: Barker remains the law; the High Court's decision was the final appeal. The Court left open whether contracts carry a general duty of good faith. Since this decision the high income threshold has risen: for dismissals from 1 July 2026 it is $190,100, and an employee earning more than that can claim unfair dismissal only if an award or enterprise agreement covers them.

$11,692.31 (four weeks' pay) instead of $317,500ContractsExecutivesRedundancy

High Court of Australia · 10 September 2014

Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Barker [2014] HCA 32, Chief Justice French and Justices Kiefel, Bell, Gageler and Keane. Read the full decision

This is a plain-English summary of the published decision, for general information. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts.

Does this sound like your situation?

More case studies